Hi FatedCinderella!
Good to see you again.Sound to me like some kind of unfinished soul longing. You could have known these two in a previous life?
Even if you do or don't believe in reincarnation, there's "something" to the personality of each of these brothers that you 'need' to complete you, or complete some kind of connection to, even, a Talent that you have, and haven't considered before.
Also-- These men represent 'you' ..
Your masculine-energy that your feminine-side is wanting connection with?
I'd say to take some time, and do some journaling (or even artwork) about those two. Make lists of characteristics they have. Talents they have. How you 'feel' and relate towards both. Lists of things about their lives that you remember.
Make these be 'keywords' or phrases for you.
Then!...
Using either your imagination (or using actual using art-supplies), do cardboard cut-outs. Paste tiny labels?.. Place on these the list of words on their forms, as though 'these' belong to YOU.
Even do a small poster-size collage for each of them? Get it down 'on the paper' so you can appreciate these as outside of you, and as an Expression of you?
What do you think of these?
Is there anything of those traits you 'need' inside of you? Anything you could cultivate that could enhance your life as it is now?
If less-desirable, then, what kind of thought-patterns or 'habits' are illustrated?
Do any of these need reconsideration for the future?
…
Of course, the practical-romantic in me says... Why not contact them to say Hello?
Have a conversation. Pay attention to the feelings you are having while you listen. Pay attention to the 'story' that is going on for *them* in their life right now.
Is there anything you can easily do for them at this time?
Sometimes it good to converse.
It's good to be listened-to, and reflected.
Thank you for your interesting dreams!