Author
|
Topic: Projection?
|
Aste*risk Knowflake Posts: 85 From: U.S. Registered: Nov 2007
|
posted December 14, 2008 09:11 PM
I'm asking those who are mainly familiar with Carl Jung's work. You know in astrology where suppressed aspects of yourself manifests as projection? I read a lot about people just projecting themselves onto one another, seeing them as how they want to see them. But to what extent would a person know who you really are if they're just projecting onto you? And why might you project onto a certain person? Or is it just completely arbitrary? IP: Logged |
LadyNeptune Knowflake Posts: 424 From: Registered: Dec 2007
|
posted December 14, 2008 09:13 PM
Astrologically, I think this would be true if someone puts their personal planets in your 1st house or you put your's in theirs. Psychologically, it's because people don't want to face who they really are. IP: Logged |
Aste*risk Knowflake Posts: 85 From: U.S. Registered: Nov 2007
|
posted December 14, 2008 09:23 PM
Oh, I didn't know that it involved specific placements in astrology.You don't want to face who you really are, so you face it in others, but is this also because there is a connection with the person you project onto? IP: Logged |
LadyNeptune Knowflake Posts: 424 From: Registered: Dec 2007
|
posted December 14, 2008 09:33 PM
I dont think it's because there's a connection. I think it's because they exhibit qualities that you disown, so you see it in them. I, personally, think that about the 1st house in synastry. IP: Logged |
Aste*risk Knowflake Posts: 85 From: U.S. Registered: Nov 2007
|
posted December 14, 2008 09:46 PM
I see, so seeing those certain aspects in them aren't exactly manifested from only yourself? they were already there in the first place? Except they sort of blind the crap out of you all the more, because you don't want to see them. lol, Yep. Sounds like life to me. IP: Logged |
MyVirgoMask Knowflake Posts: 853 From: processing destination...... Registered: Sep 2008
|
posted December 14, 2008 09:47 PM
1st house seems like it would be right in this case for synastry, though if we're talking about the Jungian 'shadow' sense of self, it might link to the 12th house in the natal...all the stuff we tend to disown in ourselves.My moon in the 12th - I do tend to suppress my own emotions well, though they bite me out of nowhere suddenly (the Aries in it lol). Times when my Moon fell into someone's 1st or 4th, I saw them as extremely irrationally emotional and it attracted/repelled me... even if that person was not a 'usually' emotional person. IP: Logged |
MyVirgoMask Knowflake Posts: 853 From: processing destination...... Registered: Sep 2008
|
posted December 14, 2008 09:51 PM
...to continue, the more 'emotional' I became, the less emotionally they reacted. So even in the process of trying to re-own the disowned piece, it felt like a vacuum as though I were taking in their own emotions too (7th/8th house has Neptune).I do think the 7th house can be prominent too in regards to the Jungian stuff. Maybe the stuff in the 1st feels jarring and in-your-face, but when it falls in the 7th it can be highly idealized, as though we reached out for that projection. Does that make sense? IP: Logged |
Aste*risk Knowflake Posts: 85 From: U.S. Registered: Nov 2007
|
posted December 14, 2008 10:07 PM
Yes, definitely the 7th house would have to do with it since the Asc-Desc axis represents the 'self vs. others' thing. But I think planets in the 4th, 8th, 12th houses would represent aspects of yourself that aren't very well seen by others around you, rather than anything in the 7th house which represents aspects that you simply don't accept or understand. That could be the difference there. Our entire lives are spent learning about ourselves, and that usually happens by searching throughout the physical world or throughout the world inside ourselves. IP: Logged |
LadyNeptune Knowflake Posts: 424 From: Registered: Dec 2007
|
posted December 14, 2008 10:09 PM
It makes sense!I think you're right on about the 12th. Whenever people put planets into my 12th they project onto me. I hate that. Grr... The 7th and 10th - don't forget the 10th, are other houses where it could happen. IP: Logged |
darkdreamer Knowflake Posts: 4228 From: Germany Registered: Aug 2006
|
posted December 15, 2008 09:56 AM
Maybe the first and 7th house represent more the Anima / Animus-stuff, whereas the 12th house might represent the shadow? The difference being that ususally you are attracted to someone who reflects your 7th house of partners or feel admiration and a certain familiarity with someone who triggers the 1st house, whereas the 12th house stuff *can* be uncomfortable, as it represents some kind of "blind spot".For example: I have Mars in 12th house conjunct Neptune but also conjunct ASC; so the Martian energy may be partly a part of my shadow (partly because the conjunction to ASC makes it more conscious than if it was in Scorpio (my ASC / Mars is in Sagittarius)). I tend to avoid Martian issues (which is kinda impossible cause I also have Mars conjunct NN), and always pictured myself as rather gentle, soft, void of aggressions and energy. Curiously others view me quite differently at times. Also, for some time in my life I have had a strong aversion against those selfish, selfcentred, dominant, arrogant people who only care for themselves and will mindlessly overrun the more helpless people. Interestingly I think Saturn might be a part of my shadow, too. It is retograde in Cancer in 8th house, a singleton, as it is the only planet on the right half of the chart. However, as much as I didn`t like Martian people, even worse was my rejection of w hat I called "typical Cancer" - lamoryant, full of selfpity, clingy, manipulative, depressing, also selfcentred in a more subtle way, dependent and such things. Of course it was a very onesided view on Cancers (there are wonderful Cancer-people out there, I know that. ):
And it doesn`t come as a surprise, that of course my Mum has a Cancer - ASC, two friends of mine have Cancer-ASC, another friend of mine has Cancer-ASC and Cancer Moon. lol Shortly after my SAturn-Return I finally realized that those "qualities" I almost "loathed" in others just reminded me that I have them deep inside myself. But my Sag-stellium, my Aquarius-Moon and my Capricorn-Venus couldn`t really deal with those things. I believe that I projected them onto my friends and family, but in my case those people were a good "screen", as they indeed have Cancer or strong Moon-energy. I also think that by drawing them into my life, I had and still have to face the issues around the Cancer-symbolism I have and have to reintegrate them. IP: Logged |
Kick It Knowflake Posts: 1129 From: Leeds Registered: May 2008
|
posted December 15, 2008 10:08 AM
quote: Psychologically, it's because people don't want to face who they really are.
What if traits you see in others, you also recognise within yourself. What does projection become then? If all you are doing is picking up traits within yourself, then you dont see anyone clearly.
IP: Logged |
darkdreamer Knowflake Posts: 4228 From: Germany Registered: Aug 2006
|
posted December 15, 2008 10:10 AM
I think it`s a mix up. Some traits you may not see to clearly, but others you see and realize that there is "common ground" between the two of you. I`m not sure it is still projection in this case though.IP: Logged |
Happy Dragon Knowflake Posts: 3129 From: Registered: Apr 2005
|
posted December 15, 2008 11:50 AM
just dropping this in for folk who may be unsure what 'projection' is .. ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ 'projection' (from ~ http://www.happydragon.pwp.blueyonder.co.uk/jkbx/unconscious.html ~ ).. In terms of the subject of relating, perhaps the most important mechanism we possess that enables us to see into the psyche is that of projection. We often use the term in connection with the cinema, and its meaning in this context can help us to undertand it in a psychological sense as well. When we see an image projected upon a screen, we look at the image and respond to it, rather than examining the film or the transparency within the projector which is the real source of the image; nor do we look at the light within the projector which makes it possible for us to see the image in the first place. When a person projects some unconscious quality existent within himself onto another person he reacts to the projection as though it belonged to the other; it does not occur to him to look within his own psyche for the source of it. He will treat the projection as though it existed outside him, and its impact on him will usually trigger a high emotional charge because it is, in reality, his own unconscious self that he is facing. . .. This very simple mechanism is at work whenever we have any highly coloured or irrational emotional reaction, positive or negative, to another person. It's a lifetime's work to introject, to recognise and to bring back into ourselves, these unconscious qualities, so that we can begin to perceive the dim outlines of the other's identity, And we certainly do not come closer, but only move futher away, when we make or break relationships according to responses based on our projections. ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ still trying to rack my brain as to a time i may have 'projected' .. and relating it to my chart .. if i read a forum post .. and react to it as if i've imposed my own emotions onto the post .. is that 'projection' ? ( rhetorical question :-) i know 'bullys' .. well the subject of 'bullying' .. triggers a high emotional charge in me .. and i know what i'd like to subject a 'bully' to .. on a one to one .. in private .. i'd become one nasty bully myself .. i.e. given no moral 'brakes' .. mainly to give back what they give out .. so to speak .. 'payback' .. so .. although i deplore such behaviour .. and would seek to avoid it if possible .. according to the psychologists .. there must be a 'bully' residing in my psyche somewhere .. hhhhmmm .. not a pleasant thought .. IP: Logged |
Kick It Knowflake Posts: 1129 From: Leeds Registered: May 2008
|
posted December 15, 2008 02:15 PM
Ok, let me give an example and you can explain how the projection would work....Mother Teresa calls someone a **** . How does that work then? Is it just a part of her psyche which rejects that bit of character within her? Sounds like 7th house. Though I guess it is about the self more than the other.
12th is sometimes mentioned..... http://thezodiac.com/12thhouse.htm IP: Logged |
Kick It Knowflake Posts: 1129 From: Leeds Registered: May 2008
|
posted December 15, 2008 02:38 PM
Im being serious about the whole Mother Teresa calling someone a slute. It is a good example to explain to others. No, Im not trying to be funny.IP: Logged |
darkdreamer Knowflake Posts: 4228 From: Germany Registered: Aug 2006
|
posted December 15, 2008 03:00 PM
It does depend on her emotional reaction.I think there is often projection, if we`re reacting unreasonably emotionally to something, sometimes not even explainable to ourselves. So if Mother Theresa would have experienced very strong emotions like raging fury or almost hate or very strong contempt for that woman, she called a **** , then this could be a sign of projection. Maybe she would have been boiling inside, because this other woman expressed something she didn`t dare to express or had been denying herself to express all her life, maybe because it just didn`t fit into her high moral, or her perception of herself. Only one possibility I can imagine. I am sure there are others. IP: Logged |
Kick It Knowflake Posts: 1129 From: Leeds Registered: May 2008
|
posted December 15, 2008 03:07 PM
Good reply DD, well explained. I could go on, but I wont.IP: Logged |
Aste*risk Knowflake Posts: 85 From: U.S. Registered: Nov 2007
|
posted December 15, 2008 06:33 PM
It seems that people reject certain traits in others just as, if not more, harshly than they reject those traits in themselves.Maybe if they've had bad experiences with expressing those traits (them getting shut down or hurt from showing those traits) they can't see how others are more easily accepted by expressing those same traits. It could be a matter of what they feel is unfair. IP: Logged |