Author
|
Topic: Sidereal astrology Vs Tropical astrology
|
ash Newflake Posts: 3 From: Registered: Nov 2010
|
posted November 27, 2010 05:22 AM
I have been reading a lot about sidereal & tropical astrology but cant seem to decide which is more accurate? Would appreciate some insights. IP: Logged |
joyrjw Knowflake Posts: 228 From: El Cajon,California, USA Registered: Nov 2010
|
posted December 13, 2010 10:29 PM
I've kind of been having the same problem Ash. But I think that Sidereal in general just makes more sense to me. If the stars moved...shouldn't we move the signs with them? That's my perspective on this. I hope it helps in some way. ------------------ "The most beautiful things in the world cannot be seen or even touched, they must be felt with the heart” `Helen Keller quotes IP: Logged |
Geocosmic* Valentine Knowflake Posts: 1087 From: New York, NY Registered: Apr 2009
|
posted December 14, 2010 03:00 AM
Believe it or not, it's just like choosing between whether to use a Mac or PC. They both work and you can get the same results, however, more people use PC because it's more affordable and the software and accessories are more affordable, etc.I'm an astrologer but I have several friends who are psychics and/or tarot readers, runes readers, etc. When reading on certain events or individuals, more often than not we get the exact same results with some of us able to fill extra little blanks here and there. My suggestion is that if you resonate with one type of system over another, go with your individual flow if it feels good and works for you, whatever gives you the most accuracy. I personally use the tropical zodiac but there are a few excellent vedic astrologers who frequent this site and that system automatically uses the Sidereal zodiac. Good luck and welcome to site. ------------------ Geocosmic Valentine Professional Astrologer geocosmicvalentine@yahoo.com www.myspace.com/geocosmicvalentine IP: Logged |
ash Newflake Posts: 3 From: Registered: Nov 2010
|
posted December 29, 2010 12:39 AM
appreciate ur insights.. i am unsure because when im using sidereal & tropical, both give me the same aspects but different signs. E.g. my moon squares saturn - tis aspect appears in both sidereal & tropical but in different signs each. In Sidereal its Tau Moon Square Leo Saturn In Tropical its Gem Moon Square Vir Saturn So the interpretations of d same aspects wl b quite similar but in different signs it could be a lil off or inaccurate. And tis is d dilemma... i guess i av 2 choose which suits me best ... IP: Logged |