posted October 02, 2007 09:22 AM
From Jomana Karadsheh and Alan Duke
CNN
Decrease font Decrease font
Enlarge font Enlarge fontBAGHDAD, Iraq (CNN) -- An Iraqi police officer who was directing traffic at Baghdad's Nusoor Square on September 16 said Blackwater guards "became the terrorists" that Sunday afternoon when they opened fire on civilians, an incident the Iraqi government said was unprovoked.
art.iraq.car.afp.gi.jpg
An Iraqi man rides through Baghdad's Nusoor Square a few days after the Blackwater incident there.
A 37-year-old Baghdad businessman and a father of four, whose youngest son was killed by a Blackwater bullet, said he wanted no monetary compensation but only for the guards to "admit to the truth."
The police officer and businessman on Monday gave CNN vivid descriptions of the incident in which a senior Iraqi investigator said 17 people were killed and 24 wounded.
Blackwater USA, the private security contractor hired to guard U.S. diplomats in Baghdad, has said its employees responded properly to an insurgent attack, but the State Department has opened an investigation.
The convoy of four Blackwater vehicles drove into the square about half an hour after a bombing prompted another Blackwater team that was guarding a U.S. diplomat to rush from the area and back to the Green Zone, the enclave in Baghdad where U.S. and Iraqi government agencies have headquarters. Video Watch scenes of the square right after the incident »
The police officer, whom CNN is identifying only as Sarhan, said the Blackwater guards "seemed nervous" as they entered the square, throwing water bottles at the Iraqi police posted there and driving in the wrong direction. He said traffic police halted civilian traffic to clear the way for the Blackwater team.
Don't Miss
* Blackwater chief disputes 'baseless allegations'
* Official: Blackwater involved in second shooting
* Blackwater often shoots first, congressional report says
* U.S. general: Contractors use 'over-the-top' tactics
Then, he said, the guards fired five or six shots in an apparent attempt to scare people away, but one of the rounds struck a car and killed a young man who was sitting next to his mother, a doctor.
Sarhan said he and an undercover Iraqi police officer ran to the car but they were unable to stop it from rolling forward toward the Blackwater convoy.
"I wanted to get his mother out, but could not because she was holding her son tight and did not want to let him go," Sarhan said. "They immediately opened heavy fire at us."
"Each of their four vehicles opened heavy fire in all directions, they shot and killed everyone in cars facing them and people standing on the street," Sarhan said.
The shooting lasted about 20 minutes, he said.
"When it was over we were looking around and about 15 cars had been destroyed, the bodies of the killed were strewn on the pavements and road."
Sarhan said no one ever fired at the Blackwater team.
"They became the terrorists, not attacked by the terrorists," he said.
"I saw parts of the woman's head flying in front of me, blow up and then her entire body was charred," he said. "What do you expect my reaction to be? Are they protecting the country? No. If I had a weapon I would have shot at them."
Mohammed Abdul Razzaq was driving into Nusoor Square with his sister, her three children and his 9-year-old son Ali at the same time the Blackwater team arrived.
"They gestured stop, so we all stopped," Razzaq said. "It's a secure area so we thought it will be the usual, we would stop for a bit as convoys pass. Shortly after that they opened heavy fire randomly at the cars with no exception."
"My son was sitting behind me," he said. "He was shot in the head and his brains were all over the back of the car."
The others ducked and were spared, he said.
He later counted 36 bullet holes in his car, six in his sister's headrest.
"Anyone who got out of his car would be killed," he said. "Anyone who would move was killed. Anyone sitting in a car was killed."
"I saw a guy in a small car who got out to flee, they shot him and he hit the ground," Razzaq said. "They fired at him again and again with his blood flowing in the street, but they continued to shoot him."
"It was hell, like a scene from a movie," he said.
More than two weeks later, Razzaq said he is left with questions and nightmares about his son's death.
"He was in school, but last year had to leave school because we were displaced. Now the Americans have killed him -- why? What did he do? What did I do? After what I witnessed, I now jump out of bed at night, I have nightmares, it's experiencing death, bullets are flying from here and there and here explosions, cars hit. Why? Why did they do this?"
Razzaq said he would rather have answers than money from Blackwater and the U.S. government.
"Why should I ask for compensation? What would it do? Bring back my son? It will not."
"I only ask why? Just want them to admit to the truth. Maybe if they admit, then many of victims will drop their compensation claims," he said.
One State Department investigation is focused on the events of September 16, and another will take a broader look at the department's relationship with private security firms.
advertisement
"Obviously, we want to see these firms be effective in what they do but also play by the rules," Nicholas Burns, undersecretary of state for political affairs, told CNN on Tuesday.
"We have lots of people in Baghdad, it's our largest embassy in the world, and they have to be well protected," Burns said. Read more about private security contractors in Iraq » E-mail to a friend
http://www.cnn.com/2007/WORLD/meast/10/02/blackwater.witness/index.html
Skip to main content
/world
*
* Home
* World
* U.S.
* Politics
* Entertainment
* Health
* Tech
* Travel
* Living
* Business
* Sports
* Time.com
* CNN Video
* I-Report
* RSS Feeds
Hot Topics » Chester Stiles • Britney Spears • Planet in Peril • CNN Heroes • More Topics
Weather Forecast International Edition
updated 1 hour, 58 minutes ago
* E-mail
* Save
* Print
Dad: Blackwater blew up son's and wife's 'skulls'
* Story Highlights
* Husband mourns wife, son a month after they were killed in Baghdad
* Man's wife was a doctor; his son hoped to be a surgeon
* Witnesses say the mother held her boy after he was shot, screaming, "My son!"
* The husband says, "All we want is ... justice"
* Next Article in World »
* Read
* VIDEO
From Jomana Karadsheh
CNN
Decrease font Decrease font
Enlarge font Enlarge font
Editor's note: CNN agreed not to use the full name of family members in this report at their request, due to concerns for their own safety.
BAGHDAD, Iraq (CNN) -- Haythem could only recognize his oldest boy from his tall and slim physique as well as what was left of his shoes. His son's head had been blown away, his body charred beyond recognition. His wife of more than 20 years was torn apart.
art.family.jpg
Ahmed and his mother, Mahassen, were killed in the September 16 shootings in Baghdad.
Click to view previous image
1 of 3
Click to view next image
"Only part of her neck and jaw remained," Haythem told CNN. The rest of her was covered by a body bag.
Choking back tears, he said, "Killing them was not enough, blowing up their skulls, they burned them and disfigured them."
Haythem's wife, Mahassen, and his 20-year-old son, Ahmed, were among the 17 Iraqi civilians killed and 27 others wounded in a hail of gunfire September 16 in Baghdad. Video Watch Haythem's video of the charred wreckage »
Guards working for private security firm Blackwater USA are accused of opening fire on the Iraqis.
The Iraqi government has said the Blackwater guards shot without provocation -- something the U.S.-based contractor has denied, saying the guards were in a firefight with gunmen.
An Iraqi government report has accused Blackwater of "premeditated murder," saying the company's guards randomly fired at civilians. An Iraqi panel investigating the shootings has asked Blackwater to pay the families of each of the victims $8 million in compensation.
"Money will not compensate us for what we have lost, even if it were piles of it," Haythem said. "No one can put a price on the lives of those killed."
Haythem, 46, a doctor who specializes in blood diseases, spoke from his temporary home in an upscale Baghdad neighborhood where he is living with his mother and two remaining children -- daughter Maryam, 18, and son Haidar, 17.
While he spoke, his mother sat in a corner of the room, moaning and sobbing, rocking back and forth on a couch. She wore all black.
All Haythem and the family know about the final moments of their loved ones is what two Iraqi police officers who witnessed the shootings have told them -- that Ahmed was shot as he was driving his car in Nusoor Square and his mother clutched him tight as he was bleeding.
Don't Miss
* Blackwater chief: Guards were fired on
* Blackwater incident witness: 'It was hell'
* FBI takes lead in probe
* Survivors of Blackwater shooting tell FBI their stories
"Those who witnessed the incident say that my son's head was scattered and my wife held him and hugged him," Haythem said. "She was screaming, 'My son, my son! Help me! Help me!' "
The car slowly rolled forward until Blackwater guards unleashed more shots that turned the vehicle into a fireball, according to the witnesses.
"They understood the call for help. They sprayed her with bullets," he said.
Blackwater has not discussed specifics about the case, saying the FBI is investigating the matter. Blackwater CEO Erik Prince told CNN Sunday one of the Blackwater vehicles was damaged by small arms fire and that his guards committed no "deliberate violence."
Haythem's wife also was a doctor and his son was attending medical school with hopes of becoming a surgeon.
"They destroyed my family and they killed my beloved wife, my better half," Haythem said calmly. "They deprived me of my eldest son who I have raised into a strong, young man. They deprived him of fulfilling his dream to be a doctor and a surgeon. They planted pain and misery in the hearts of my two younger kids."
His daughter and son live in fear that he too will be slain on the streets of Baghdad, leaving them as orphans.
Maryam sat with her father throughout the interview, not wanting to leave his side. She said she and her mother were close friends -- able to chat like sisters and share stories beyond most mother-daughter relationships.
"My friends would always tell me how much they noticed my mom's love for me. She used to always talk to me about my future and her dreams for me," she said. "I hope I live up to her expectations."
Maryam's last conversation with her mom was the morning of September 16. Maryam had a biology exam that day. Her mom woke her up and reviewed the material with her to make sure she was properly prepared for the test.
"She stayed for another few minutes, joking and laughing," Maryam said, tears running down her cheeks.
Haythem was dropped off at work that day by his wife and son. They then picked up a college application for Maryam, who is hoping to enter dental school. At some point afterward they were killed.
Haythem first began worrying when his wife was late picking him up from work. Then calls to her cell phone went unanswered. In the chaotic world of Baghdad -- where violence and kidnappings are common -- anytime a loved one doesn't show up on time fears of the worst begin.
He eventually made it home and began making more phone calls. The worrying intensified as news reports swirled of a deadly shooting in Nusoor Square. He called his brother, a doctor at a nearby hospital, to check the emergency room and the morgue. The brother found no signs of them.
Haythem's brother then went to the scene and found a burned-out car. He called Haythem and asked for the license plate number.
"My brother collapsed and said, 'The family car is burned and may God bless their souls,' " Haythem said.
Despite his sorrow and anguish, Haythem maintains a calm and peaceful attitude, saying he only seeks justice through the courts and that he trusts the U.S. and international judicial systems.
"All we want is the fair judiciary do us justice. We ask the judge who takes this case to think before he rules, to be satisfied with his ruling as if he were, God forbid, personally involved," he said.
Haythem's and Maryam's faces light up when they speak of their loved ones. Ahmed, they said, was an achiever, an ambitious young man who not only was always at the top of his class but who also enjoyed sports and singing and had an interest in languages. He was fluent in English and was learning French and Italian.
advertisement
"He was quiet and very popular and a leader. This was all wasted in a moment," his father said. "He was guilty of no crime. What compensation is there for that? There can't be any."
Maryam just wishes she could turn the clock back. "I only wish I could relive last month, my family around," she said. "But they are gone. What can we do? If we die, we will do so in Iraq and hopefully we will all meet in heaven." E-mail to a friend E-mail to a friend
All About Nusoor Square • Iraq War • Blackwater USA
* E-mail
* Save
* Print
Sound Off: Your opinions and comments
Steve
updated 15 minutes ago
This is a very sad story. These private security firms have no business in Iraq. They are a bunch of has been soilders who want constant action to satisfy their urge to make a ton of money while doing what they love t ...more
This is a very sad story. These private security firms have no business in Iraq. They are a bunch of has been soilders who want constant action to satisfy their urge to make a ton of money while doing what they love to do- Kill !!! . Our US soilders have many more dangers to face and make 5 times less than "Blackwater" Personel. It is time to get these overpaid thugs out of Iraq !!! It makes me sick to read articles like this. It's too bad the Iraqi Civilians don't have the same weaponary as Blackwater! If the innocent Iraqi people can't get them out by peaceful negotiations maybe a trip back to the US in a coffin might help!!! less
Dave
updated 15 minutes ago
What a terrible and delicate situation. You have Blackwater USA insisting that they were fired on and then you have the victims stating that they did not do anything.
What a terrible and delicate situation. You have Blackwater USA insisting that they were fired on and then you have the victims stating that they did not do anything. less
sim
updated 15 minutes ago
The very idea that we employ mercenaries is repugnant to most Americans--that they operate outside the chain of command, that they commit these kinds of atrocities with impunity and continue to do so--this is the modu ...more
The very idea that we employ mercenaries is repugnant to most Americans--that they operate outside the chain of command, that they commit these kinds of atrocities with impunity and continue to do so--this is the modus operandi of a fascist state. Blackwater is no better than the Waffen SS. A day of reckoning will come. less
Rose
updated 15 minutes ago
I am saddend by any death brought about by this war but I think the press needs to look a little deeper as to why these people were killed. A few years ago the press reported on the death of a young boy who was kille ...more
I am saddend by any death brought about by this war but I think the press needs to look a little deeper as to why these people were killed. A few years ago the press reported on the death of a young boy who was killed by American Forces in Afghanistan. This was shocking to the world. What they didn't know was that not one of the villagers knew this boy and no one would take the time to bury him. Our troops did! It was assumed that the boy was traveling with the Taliban. Has no one ever seen the movie "Rules of Engagement"? less
Brian
updated 15 minutes ago
CNN makes me laugh. Instead of reporting the clear improvements in Iraq and the forward progress brought bu the surge they day after day continue trying to manufacture a scandal with Blackwater. CNN is nothing more th ...more
CNN makes me laugh. Instead of reporting the clear improvements in Iraq and the forward progress brought bu the surge they day after day continue trying to manufacture a scandal with Blackwater. CNN is nothing more than a sham news organization which acts as a mouth piece of the left wing. They are Fox News for liberals! less
Ken
updated 15 minutes ago
What an awful ,awful situation. May this family have some peace.
What an awful ,awful situation. May this family have some peace. less
Kris Hamacek
updated 15 minutes ago
It it a terrible tragedy, horrible things happen in war. Discipline our own but do not compensate the iraqi civilians caught in the middle of a war. Until you are ready to give 8 million to the families of our soldi ...more
It it a terrible tragedy, horrible things happen in war. Discipline our own but do not compensate the iraqi civilians caught in the middle of a war. Until you are ready to give 8 million to the families of our soldiers who have lost their sons, daughters, bothers sisters and parents I see no reason to pay these people. less
Sarah
updated 15 minutes ago
Thank you to CNN for posting this story, and thanks much more for making it the top story.
I wish every American citizen would read this story. I think it would help end the senseless killings... we all have blood on our hands until we rise up to put a stop to this.
Thank you to CNN for posting this story, and thanks much more for making it the top story.
I wish every American citizen would read this story. I think it would help end the senseless killings... we all have blood on our hands until we rise up to put a stop to this. less
Log
updated 15 minutes ago
Wow, CNN, whatever happened to unbiased journalism? Your stand firmly against Blackwater is apparent in your coverage of these related stories. I've yet to see an article about how the Iraqis need to step up and han ...more
Wow, CNN, whatever happened to unbiased journalism? Your stand firmly against Blackwater is apparent in your coverage of these related stories. I've yet to see an article about how the Iraqis need to step up and handle their own security. There wouldn't be a need for private contractors or the US military if the common citizens actually banded together and refused to accept the terrorists, religious factions, and corruption inherent in the mess that is their poltical/governmental system right now. less
ABY
updated 15 minutes ago
The use of private security companies is foolish lets cut to the chase here they are mercenaries. These are former military men who rather then return to the service of thier nation have chosen to hire themselves out ...more
The use of private security companies is foolish lets cut to the chase here they are mercenaries. These are former military men who rather then return to the service of thier nation have chosen to hire themselves out to the highest bidder. If the FBI finds crimminal wrong doing by these men then their contract should be cancelled and they should be pulled out of Iraq. Some other firm whose has shown greater restraint will be more then able to fill the void. less
Tom
updated 15 minutes ago
You all must toast each other when you get stories of Americans doing wrong in the world because it would make the front page everytime over any other story and God forbid a positive story over there ever making the front of CNN.com
You all must toast each other when you get stories of Americans doing wrong in the world because it would make the front page everytime over any other story and God forbid a positive story over there ever making the front of CNN.com less
Phillipe
updated 15 minutes ago
Oh, yes they did nothing wrong nothing at all, they are totally innocent. I love these one sided stories.
Oh, yes they did nothing wrong nothing at all, they are totally innocent. I love these one sided stories. less
Paul
updated 15 minutes ago
This sounds like a tragic event, and one for which we still do not have all of the answers. What is curious to me is that I don't recall CNN writing these kinds of pieces on all of the innocent people blown up by the ...more
This sounds like a tragic event, and one for which we still do not have all of the answers. What is curious to me is that I don't recall CNN writing these kinds of pieces on all of the innocent people blown up by the Taliban, but terrorists... nor do I recall articles of this nature about the families left behind by the 9-11 slaughter.
My prayers are with the Iraqi people, as their plight is much more difficult than can be expressed in a news article. My prayers are also with our brave men and women who are trying to help in a nearly impossible-to-solve situation. less
Meddy
updated 15 minutes ago
And the right wing fanatics will call this propaganda...... We are playing limbo with morality.
And the right wing fanatics will call this propaganda...... We are playing limbo with morality. less
Clif
updated 15 minutes ago
Why is acceptable for our government to hire free-lance mercenaries to fight our war? Where is the chain of command for them? Who do they answer to? I would wager no one; that's probably why this happened.
Why is acceptable for our government to hire free-lance mercenaries to fight our war? Where is the chain of command for them? Who do they answer to? I would wager no one; that's probably why this happened. less
Post a comment | Send a video comment via I-Report
Next 25 comments » | Next 25 comments »
Post a comment
Name
Location
Comment
Submit
From the Blogs: Controversy, commentary, and debate
loading Sit tight, we're getting to the good stuff
powered by Sphere
Top News
Man held in taped sexual assault of child Execution halted, 90 minutes to spare
Most Viewed Most Emailed Top Searches
1. 1 Teacher: Student had look of hate
2. 2 'Complicated' life of Schulz
3. 3 Artist stands by Mohammed cartoon
4. 4 Suspect held in girl's taped rape
5. 5 Spears booked on traffic charges
6. 6 Mom ships Silly String to troops
7. 7 Interpol: ID on suspect pedophile
8. 8 'WKRP's' 'Mama Carlson' dead
9. 9 Commentary: Tune in to 2008 before...
10. 10 Putin backs Iranian nuke program
1. 1 60 grams of fat for breakfast!
2. 2 What to do with your money and when
3. 3 2 moms, too stressed, looking for relief
4. 4 Brits resort to pulling own teeth
5. 5 Throw yourself into intimacy and take...
6. 6 Site posts videos of autistic behaviors
7. 7 Truth of earrings, bikinis and sports...
8. 8 Healthful breakfast tips to keep you...
9. 9 University president's wife...
10. 10 Mom ships 80,000 cans of Silly String...
1. 1 jena 6
2. 2 michael vick
3. 3 oj simpson
4. 4 steve fossett
5. 5 britney spears
6. 6 madeleine mccann
7. 7 youssif
8. 8 blackwater
9. 9 myanmar
10. 10 halo 3
Most Viewed Most Emailed Top Searches
1. 1 A big one that didn't get awayA big one that didn't get away
2. 2 Gas station shootoutGas station shootout
3. 3 Dogs maul womanDogs maul woman
4. 4 Rubik's cube speed freakRubik's cube speed freak
5. 5 Iowa roads under waterIowa roads under water
1. 1 Mustang for a dogMustang for a dog
2. 2 True Husker spiritTrue Husker spirit
3. 3 Rubik's cube speed freakRubik's cube speed freak
4. 4 Inflatable lifesaving jacketInflatable lifesaving jacket
5. 5 T.I.'s home searchedT.I.'s home searched
1. 1 video
2. 2 anderson cooper
3. 3 south korea
4. 4 moos
5. 5 larry king
6. 6 china
7. 7 iraq
8. 8 jeanne moos
9. 9 jena 6
10. 10 ti
1. 1 Britney Spears
2. 2 Planet in Peril: Environmental Coverage
3. 3 Sexual Offenses
4. 4 Chester Arthur Stiles
5. 5 CNN Heroes
• Part Time Jobs
• Sales & Marketing Jobs
• Customer Service Jobs
Quick Job Search
keyword(s):
enter city:
* State
* -------
* AL
* AK
* AZ
* AR
* CA
* CO
* CT
* DE
* DC
* FL
* GA
* HI
* ID
* IL
* IN
* IA
* KS
* KY
* LA
* ME
* MD
* MA
* MI
* MN
* MS
* MO
* MT
* NE
* NV
* NH
* NJ
* NM
* NY
* NC
* ND
* OH
* OK
* OR
* PA
* PR
* RI
* SC
* SD
* TN
* TX
* UT
* VT
* VA
* WA
* WV
* WI
* WY
State
* Job type
* -----------------
* Accounting
* Admin & Clerical
* Automotive
* Banking
* Biotech
* Broadcast - Journalism
* Business Development
* Construction
* Consultant
* Customer Service
* Design
* Distribution - Shipping
* Education
* Engineering
* Entry Level - New Grad
* Executive
* Facilities
* Finance
* General Business
* General Labor
* Government
* Grocery
* Healthcare
* Hotel - Hospitality
* Human Resources
* Information Technology
* Installation - Maint - Repair
* Insurance
* Inventory
* Legal
* Legal Admin
* Management
* Manufacturing
* Marketing
* Nurse
* Other
* Pharmacy
* Professional Services
* Purchasing - Procurement
* QA - Quality Control
* Research
* Restaurant - Food Service
* Retail
* Sales
* Science
* Skilled Labor - Trades
* Strategy - Planning
* Supply Chain
* Telecomm
* Training
* Transportation
* Warehouse
Job type
more options »
Stories you may be interested in based on past browsing
Iraq sends crisis envoy to Turkey
Rice: 'Time for Palestinian state'
Putin arrives in Iran for talks
Brazen pirates step up sea attacks
Thai police name pedophile suspect
Home | World | U.S. | Politics | Entertainment | Health | Tech | Travel | Living | Business | Sports | Time.com
Podcasts | Blogs | CNN Mobile | Preferences | Email Alerts | CNN Radio | CNN Shop | Site Map
CNN en Espaňol | Arabic | Japanese | Korean | Turkish
International Edition | CNN TV | CNN International | Headline News | Transcripts
© 2007 Cable News Network. A Time Warner Company. All Rights Reserved.
Terms of service | Privacy guidelines | Advertise with us | About us | Contact us | Help
"Only part of her neck and jaw remained," Haythem told CNN. The rest of her was covered by a body bag.
Choking back tears, he said, "Killing them was not enough, blowing up their skulls, they burned them and disfigured them."
http://www.cnn.com/2007/WORLD/meast/10/16/dad.blackwater/index.html
P.S - Jwhop, your obsession with the Democrats is frightening. Up to the point where you don't have any remorse for innocent victims.
I think I speak for everyone here when I say who gives a **** about the Dems. This issue has nothing to do with them.
You retard. You probably bad mouth the dems even when you're taking a crap . Get over it!