posted January 29, 2009 02:22 PM
Why should they medicate ADHD?I don't see us as being disordered.
The findings of DRD4 7R gene seem to contradict ADHD as a disorder. I think that it really depends on how ADHD is used and the environment that the ADHDer is in. The same trait was useful for hunting,gathering,traveling,exploring,inventing,art,
creativity,sports,
it's more about the nonlinear nonconformist that don't fit with auditory sequential teachings,linear,routine things
The mainstream classrooms aren't suitable for us. Montessori,Waldorf Schools which focus on multisensory teaching methods are suitable for us. Homeschool is another option. Thomas Edison was homeschooled by his mother after being kicked out of school.
flouresent lights aren't good for us neurodivergents that tend to be extremely sensitive to environment. Those types of lights are pretty much in every mainstream building....especially in schools and offices. I was in the navy,and I hated those lights on the ships.
Thom Hartmann believes that ADHD well suits a person to live in a hunting-gathering world, but that it puts them at a disadvantage in a farming or industrial world. He wrote "For the first two hundred thousand years of human history, ADHDers ruled the world, but now that over 98 percent of the world's population lives in an industrial or developing industrial world, ADHD has become a disadvantage --- unless you're one of those who has learned how reinvent your life to work with,instead of against, your neurological difference."
He believed that ADHDers and Hunters are one and the same. He believes that ADHD traits are hunter-gatherer traits. He believe that the "normal" people who are good with routine,order,obedience,conventional are the farmer types.
A New View of ADHD,
Not as a Disorder but as a natural adaptive trait page 73 from Thom Hartmann's Complete Guide to ADHD
1.Trait As It Appears In the Disorder View
2. How It Appears In The Hunter View
3. Opposite Farmer Trait
1. Distractible
2.Constantly monitoring their environment
3. Not easily distracted from the task at hand
1. Attention span is short,but can become intensely focused for long periods of time
2. Able to throw themselves into the chase on a moment's notice
3. Able to sustain a steady, dependable effort
1. Poor planner: disorganized and impulsive (makes snap decisions)
2. Flexible;ready to change strategy quickly.
3. Organized,purposeful. They have a long-term strategy and they stick to it.
1. Distorted sense of time: unaware of how long it will take to do something
2. Tireless: capable of sustained drives,but only when hot on the trail of some goal.
3. Conscious of time and timing. They get things done in time,pace themselves,have good staying power.
1. Impatient
2. Results oriented. Acutely aware of whether the goal is getting closer now.
3. Patient. Aware that good things take time; willing to wait.
1. Doesn't convert words into concepts adeptly, and vice versa. May or may not have a reading disability.
2. Visual/concrete thinker, clearly seeing a tangible goal even if there are no words for it.
3. Much better able to seek goals that aren't easy to see at the moment.
1. Has difficulty following directions.
2. Independent.
3. Team player.
1. Daydreamer.
2. Bored by mundane tasks; enjoys new ideas, excitement, the hunt, being hot on the trail.
3. Focused. Good at follow-through, tending to details,taking care of business.
1. Acts without considering the consequences.
2. Willing and able to take risks and face danger.
3. Careful, look before you leap.
1. Lacking in the social graces.
2. No time for niceties when there are decisions to be made!
3. Nurturing; creates and supports community values; attuned to whetheer something will last.
Thom Hartmann's views have been confirmed by the discovery of the DRD4 7R Gene too. It is a novelty seeking gene connected approximately half of ADD cases. It is an advantageous gene dated back between 10,000 to 40,000 years ago that helped humans thrive and survive.
I don't believe in medication for something that I don't believe is a disorder but is a variation of the human condition just like I believe the same about Dyslexia,Dyspraxia,Aspergers,and Autism. That's why I believe in and support the neurodiversity movement. I don't believe my fellow Dyslexics,Dypraxics,ADHDers nor do I believe that Aspergers nor Autistics are disordered.
I had severe Dyslexia,Dyspraxia in early childhood to the point that I was misplaced in a special education class with the mentally retarded in 1st grade. If it wasn't for auditory therapy,speech therapy,phonics,and motor skills therapy, I'd still be autistic-like. I don't see myself as defective nor do many other neurodivergents. That's why we believe in the concept of neurodiversity.
There are other ways to treat ADHD in regards to its weaknesses
Nutrition is a big one
Physiological Risk Factores of ADHD with Authors of Published Articles
from the book, ADD and ADHD Complementary Medicine Solutions by Charles Gant MD, PhD
1. Food and Additive Allergies and Sensitivities
2. Heavy and Toxic Metal Toxicity
3. Low-Protein,High-Carbohydrate Diet
4. Mineral Imbalances
5. Essential Fatty Acid and Phospholid Deficiencies
6. Amino Acid Deficiencies
7. Thyroid Disorders
8. B Vitamin Deficiencies
Better nutrition can help decrease ADHD weaknesses..especially. Omega 3 fatty acids can be used like Cod liver oil/fish oil, and Essential Fatty acids is listed.
I take a multivitamin with strong Vitamin B complex and cod liver/fish oil. Cutting down on sugar can decrease ADHD weaknesses. Sugar is a carbohydrates,and high carbohydrates and low protein is listed. I cut down on sugar quite a bit,and I dropped junkfood/sweets,sodas. The result of all those things help me be less hypersensitive with a less hyperactive mind.
Creativity/Artistic outlet,Sports/Physical Activity can be good outlet for ADHD.
Meditation can be good for ADHD as it helps calm the hyperactive mind. http://abclocal.go.com/kfsn/story?section=news/health&id=4104956
Biofeedback,Neurofeedback has helped with ADHD. http://www.eeginfo.com/neurofeedback-videos-media.htm
I have a biofeedback game called Journey to Wild Divine http://www.wilddivine.com/biofeedback-meditation-products.html
audo-visual stimulator machines can be good too. I have one called The Proteus. http://www.mindmodulations.com/prodprot.html
even music can be good. I cut down listening to techno and other fast tempo type music. I listen mainly to New Age,meditation,classical music...in the morning and at night.
There are herbs that have been used for ADHD too:
Ginkgo Biloba, Scuttelaria (also known as Skullcap), German Chamomile, Gotu Kola, Avena Sativa (Oatstraw), Rooibos, Lemon Balm, Valerian, Lobelia, and Hawthorn. http://www.herbalremediesinfo.com/ADHD.html
Discipline and structure are of course ways to deal with ADHD too.
Ronald D. Davis,writer of GIFT OF DYSLEXIA and founder of international Davis Dyslexia Organization. He has a drug free approach to treat ADHD issues and he recognizes ADHD strengths http://davisdyslexia.com/add-adhd.html
So there are many ways to deal with ADHD....how effective they are really depends on the person. ADHDers can have other things that make their ADHD more complexed like other neurodivergences like Dyslexia,Dyspraxia,Aspergers,Autism as well as mental illness like Bipolar,Depression,and Anxiety.
I wish neurotypical people would stop seeing us neurodivergent people as disordered,defective,and need to be fixed because that's not us. Homosexuals used to be thought of as disordered,defective,and need to be fixed. Homosexuality was listed as a disorder in the Diagnostic Statistical Manuals at one time,and it's not listed in the DSM now. Homosexuality is not a disorder. It's variation of the human condition. I believe the same about neurodivergence. I am starting to feel that way about sex hormonal divergence. I am sex hormonal divergent myself in that I have high levels of estrogen and lower levels of testosterone. It's prenatal forI have the very feminine finger ratios of index fingers longer than ring fingers. For awhile,I thought it was something wrong. Now I realized that it's not. My strong feminine traits are a plus in that I feel that it helps me relate and get along with females,very sensitive,and believe in gender equality and women's rights,and be a feminist. Because I have been mistaken for gay and giving a hard time like being called gay slurs, it help me believe in sexual orientation equality and gay rights.
Also research studies show that many male scientists actually have long index fingers high estrogen levels which lead to strong visual spatial skills can can be used for science.
http://www.eurekalert.org/pub_releases/2004-10/bis-aft102004.php
any ways.....I don't believe that ADHD nor any other of the other neurodivergent conditions are disorders. I will be glad that society will believe that too. That's why I am a neurodiversity advocate.
I even believe that my Dyslexia,Dyspraxia,ADHD strengths are strongly linked to my overall gifts in Astrology,massage, swimming,running,poetry,creative writing,and dancing as well as psychology,mythology. Special education therapies gave me the tools to help develop my gifts. My special education experiences taught me humility,to believe in equality/diversity,and most of all treat others like I want to be treated - a fellow human being with a soul.
I have an uncle named Eddie,and he is 11 years older than me. He's 48 years old. My stepgrandmother told me that he was recommended to put him on medication because of his hyperactivity. She refused because she didn't want the drugs to mess up his brain. She said that she's hyperactive,and so was my grandfather. Therefore,she didn't believe that he should be medicated. My uncle is an accountant.
The medications have side effects. There is news release about hallucinations can be connected to ADHD medications http://news.yahoo.com/s/hsn/20090127/hl_hsn/hallucinationsareraresideeffectsofadh dmedications
Raymond