Lol, interesting question. Whomever X is, boy or girl, (s)he holds you in high esteem/respects you - X is in your exaltation and triplicity.
So, let's do a little score sheet, shall we?
Essential dignity: You are peregrine, (s)he is in detriment. You're slightly better off, but not by much.
Accidental dignity: You're cadent in the 9th, he's succeedent in the 8th. Usually succeedent trumps cadent but not in the 8th. I would say you are slightly better off again, but not by much (again).
Support from a benefic: you don't have any (sq from Jup is not support), (s)he has an applying conjunction from Venus. X wins this round by quite a bit.
Affliction from a malefic: you don't have any, he applies to sq/oppose Uranus and Pluto (I don't count outers in events but I would here). You win this match.
Neither are in Via Combusta.
Aspects to POF - you didn't include it (pls do from now on, it's important and saves me some time from calculating it), but it's at 18 Scorpio. Does not aspect X but conjuncts you, so you win this and you win big.
Moon's last aspect - sextile to you. You get this round also, not to mention you disposite Moon too.
I don't know what's the deal between you and X, especially since he/she doesn't seem to carry as much rivalry for you as you do for them (not in this chart's reception.. maybe if it were a night chart and X received you only by exaltation, but triplicity cancels any ill-intention in my opinion).
We could look at your success houses too - but I would need to know what kind of success you had in mind (fame, money, career, marriage), because different people see success differently. But even without those, I think you have better chances, so that would be my interpretation. What you do with those chances though.. that's up to you.
Good luck and let us know.
------------------
~the raving one dancing in the nude~