Author
|
Topic: Is it possible a soulmate doesn't love you back?
|
PrettyPisces Knowflake Posts: 162 From: Cambria heights,NY Registered: Jun 2011
|
posted March 27, 2015 05:54 PM
For a few years I've been asking advice on a certain cancerian man . I would say love the pass two years we've have grown closer due to him and I reconnecting . Mostly because me being away in college ( my undergrad years) and leaving our hometown. I would receive things from him always stating he missed me , he felt our " friendship" should go elsewhere , things of that nature. Two different occasions he asked to be with me but I didn't say yes because at that age I was scared to have a relationship with a close friend/ and i felt i would deprived myself the whole college experience thing because of being in a long distance relationship. Two years ago we reconnected and we began speaking almost everyday, it was as if we left off where him and I started. Him and I became an emotional outlet for each other, ( support system, business planners, great conversation , same personality ) HOWEVER: I began to relieve communicating was great but also was suffocating. If I didn't answer his calls from being in the clock he would call me excessively , or have someone call me 2.) If I told him no or If he asked me something and I said I wasn't comfortable talking about it he would get upset stating I was always hiding things . 3.) Even though he would always call me and ask who I was in the car with when I said I was driving during an argument he would say things like " you're not my gf". 4.) He would send me really nostalgic text messages like:Vibing with you is making a better person, for my interactions with you allows me to pratice ways of goodness.I wish we could have realized how great we each are many years ago!! I gain much comfort knowing, with whatever little you will need from me that you shall make it over the horizon and walk with me into the valley of our future! Be at peace with Life's burdens we will make it! Because of the suffocating behavior/ arguments we don't get along. Its been over two months since we spoke , my bday just passed and he didn't reach because of a fallen out. I've been doing well most day however i miss him but i don't know if i was in an unrequited love situation however after this disagreement him and I had he said he wasn't calling me anymore and i just hung up. I don't know if I was in love but I really think he is my soulmate , its really hard to put into words IP: Logged |
sugarflapjacks Knowflake Posts: 151 From: southeasternseaboard Registered: Sep 2013
|
posted March 27, 2015 06:27 PM
I don't really know that much about soulmates, and I may be reading this wrong, but it sounded like you wanted him as a friend and he wanted to be more than friends. You were not in love with him. You just really liked him alot as a Friend. You miss the friendship, you don't want romance from him. At least that's what I think. IP: Logged |
PrettyPisces Knowflake Posts: 162 From: Cambria heights,NY Registered: Jun 2011
|
posted March 27, 2015 07:03 PM
That's funny lol because I thought it was the over way around . And I think I may have been in love . What made you say he wanted more than friends ?IP: Logged |
sugarflapjacks Knowflake Posts: 151 From: southeasternseaboard Registered: Sep 2013
|
posted March 27, 2015 09:36 PM
Yikes, I guess I did read it wrong. It didn't seem to me that you wanted a committed relationship (his behavior was suffocating). How about some Real Talk? Based on your history together, the two of you can get to the bottom of what each of you want out of this relationship. Otherwise, it seems ya'll are headed for a lot of needless drama. IP: Logged |
PrettyPisces Knowflake Posts: 162 From: Cambria heights,NY Registered: Jun 2011
|
posted March 28, 2015 02:09 AM
I love him , however when things are good they're great . But u guess old habits die hard ! Sometimes he can be combative about things no related to me however he ptIP: Logged |
PrettyPisces Knowflake Posts: 162 From: Cambria heights,NY Registered: Jun 2011
|
posted March 28, 2015 02:11 AM
I love him , however when things are good they're great . But u guess old habits die hard ! Sometimes he can be combative about things no related to me however he projects that behavior onto me by always asking where I am , who I'm with , making something out of nothing which results In arguments IP: Logged |
Healing Mystic Melody Moderator Posts: 28 From: Illinios Registered: Jan 2015
|
posted March 28, 2015 06:43 AM
Is he a Scorpio? When he asks about what you are doing and who you are with and then adds to the end of his questioning... "but you're not my girlfriend" he is saying that he knows he hasn't got the right to question you. I think he would love you to be his girlfriend. Maybe he cannot get over feeling rejected when you went away to college. Make a grand gesture, do something crazy romantic. Declare your love for him. Stop wasting your precious life waiting. IP: Logged |
LexusVirgo Knowflake Posts: 347 From: Registered: Feb 2015
|
posted March 28, 2015 08:26 AM
Yes I think he likes you back.IP: Logged |
PrettyPisces Knowflake Posts: 162 From: Cambria heights,NY Registered: Jun 2011
|
posted March 28, 2015 02:24 PM
He's a cancer / I'm a pisces Some things in our charts pointed out , when him and I were on good terms he was always intrigued by astrology lol so I know his birthdate / natal chart In composite some of the things that stood out is Sun in 3rd house Moon in 7th house Venus in 1st house Jupiter in 5th house Mars in 12th house ( this placement scares me) lol In synastry His son goes into my 7th house My moon goes into 1st house / his moon goes into my 12th house . He has venus in gemini 12th house yikes lol Also I noticed four of my planets go into his 8th house ( I'm not really familiar with 8th house) To answer your question Healing he says you're not my girlfriend during disagreements and most of the times when he says it it doesn't even call for it like one time I was in the car with my girls and he called me back after having a disagreement and he still wanted to talk about it, I said can you call me back because I had him on speaker phone and he flipped out saying what's the big secret I'm not your boyfriend , when all I was trying to do was keep my friends from knowing what's up because they will sure have an opinion
IP: Logged |
PixieJane Moderator Posts: 6311 From: CA Registered: Oct 2010
|
posted March 28, 2015 06:08 PM
quote: Originally posted by PrettyPisces: he called me back after having a disagreement and he still wanted to talk about it, I said can you call me back because I had him on speaker phone and he flipped out saying what's the big secret I'm not your boyfriend , when all I was trying to do was keep my friends from knowing what's up because they will sure have an opinion
He definitely has some growing up to do. And if he flipped out over your saying that then he was NOT wanting to talk about it, he was looking for a way to vent at you and since you wouldn't talk about whatever it was he had to grab at something else like that (which doesn't even make sense, but he wasn't wanting to clear the air, only to rant because he was angry at you and/or to be emotionally manipulative). IP: Logged |
Healing Mystic Melody Moderator Posts: 28 From: Illinios Registered: Jan 2015
|
posted March 28, 2015 06:19 PM
His moon (emotions) in your 12th house means that his feelings for you (which are obvious to everyone else) are hidden from you. You are oblivious to his love for you. You HAVE to go to him. Cancer will not go after you in a straightforward manner like an Aries etc. Write him a letter telling him how deeply you feel for him and how attracted you are (etc)... whatever is true for you. Bare your feelings and tell him you aren't sure if he feels the same but he has always been there for you and you trust him and believe in him and his friendship and you hope it can be more. Would he like that too? Then step back and wait for him to approach and be very positive and receptive to any steps he takes to get closer to you. IP: Logged |
PrettyPisces Knowflake Posts: 162 From: Cambria heights,NY Registered: Jun 2011
|
posted March 29, 2015 06:38 PM
PixieJane: he was being emotionally manipulative . I honestly felt he tried to make him self believe he didn't have those feelings for me.Healing : I read that about the moon 12th house synastry . I don't think it's me bring oblivious . I do have feelings for him and I felt he liked me the same . However I am confused by it all because he always said during an disagreement / or he would ask about girls...total ******* , but was always possessive . On the flip side it's really hard to say anything to him . We both have not reach out to each other , he didn't call and tell me happy birthday , plus he's been seeing people . But I spoke to his bf of 20 years , we are only 25 . And he said y'all need to make things right with each other IP: Logged |
Randall Webmaster Posts: 52371 From: Saturn next to Charmaine Registered: Apr 2009
|
posted March 30, 2015 12:36 PM
quote: Originally posted by Healing Mystic Melody: His moon (emotions) in your 12th house means that his feelings for you (which are obvious to everyone else) are hidden from you. You are oblivious to his love for you. You HAVE to go to him. Cancer will not go after you in a straightforward manner like an Aries etc. Write him a letter telling him how deeply you feel for him and how attracted you are (etc)... whatever is true for you. Bare your feelings and tell him you aren't sure if he feels the same but he has always been there for you and you trust him and believe in him and his friendship and you hope it can be more. Would he like that too? Then step back and wait for him to approach and be very positive and receptive to any steps he takes to get closer to you.
IP: Logged |
Odette Moderator Posts: 5266 From: Registered: May 2012
|
posted March 30, 2015 06:11 PM
Cancer people can at times get hurt and angry in a relatively minor argument - and then allow that argument to kill their entire relationship with the person in question. I've seen this happen... because Cancers are very sensitive and they replay the argument back in their minds over and over again - and convince themselves everything is horrible... and they shouldn't go back to the person.I have a Cancer friend who stopped talking to her Cancerian father for years, over a silly argument. Neither of them will make the first step in reconnecting because they are both Cancers *facepalm* I agree with Mystic Melody that you should contact him first and open up about your feelings. IP: Logged |
PrettyPisces Knowflake Posts: 162 From: Cambria heights,NY Registered: Jun 2011
|
posted March 31, 2015 10:27 PM
I have to be honest . I hate that I have to be the one to reach out when the reason him and I aren't speaking is because of his wrong doing . However I do miss him in my life , it's scary because me missing him is overpowering or perhaps overlooking the things he has done . His bestfriend called me today and told me I should reach out to him . Today I found out some news I'm moving back to our hometown to take a job .Side note: Does anyone read charts ? IP: Logged |
Jo B Knowflake Posts: 603 From: London, UK Registered: Feb 2014
|
posted April 01, 2015 09:29 AM
quote: Originally posted by PrettyPisces: when I said I was driving during an argument he would say things like " you're not my gf".4.) He would send me really nostalgic text messages like:Vibing with you is making a better person, for my interactions with you allows me to pratice ways of goodness.I wish we could have realized how great we each are many years ago!! I gain much comfort knowing, with whatever little you will need from me that you shall make it over the horizon and walk with me into the valley of our future! Be at peace with Life's burdens we will make it!
These are really contradictory messages from him and I can see why it gets you confused. One the one hand he is saying (in the heat of the moment no doubt) that you are not his gf, then the next he's saying how great you were in the past and suggests there is a future for you both together. "Make up your bloody mind buddy!" is what I'd say in return. I had a sort of similar situation with a Cancer guy recently. On the one hand he was (and still is) all over me and obviously hasn't seemed to have moved on, and on the other hand he said he wasn't looking for a relationship with me (or anyone else apparently). To rub salt into the wound he said he was also concerned about our rather large age difference (I'm older) and was speculating about the distant future when I'm old and grey and he'd have to take care of me when he would still be a relatively young man. I was sooo insulted about that, particularly as I'm pretty fit for my age, look years younger and have always been in very good health. I dropped contact with him without a qualm on my side. He then contacted me recently said he'd been very ill with something close to pneumonia and has to do regular walks to keep his fitness level up (he's an avid gamer) - and he's only 25! It got me wondering who would be looking after who in our later years. Anyway good riddance to such wet fish! IP: Logged |
PrettyPisces Knowflake Posts: 162 From: Cambria heights,NY Registered: Jun 2011
|
posted April 02, 2015 04:04 PM
I agree Jo B it's hard sometimes to decipher what he means because it often comes off as something that can be interpret either way like a guy talking to his bestfriend or his girlfriend . Sidenote : I can recall though a friend of mine told me to be careful because he comes off as liking you and everybody sees it yet he doesn't want to and does now or he didn't in the beginning and now he does but he's trying to convince himself overwise , she said he'll hurt me . I didn't understand back then but now her point is valid . He's an avid gamer too, he's 24 Jo B I'm going to take the advice from the forum users and my loved ones , and let him know how I feel . That way I'll know hopefully he's honest and let's me know how he really feels . On another note if this is an unrequited love , I can really do my part by healing myself and move on . IP: Logged |
sugarflapjacks Knowflake Posts: 151 From: southeasternseaboard Registered: Sep 2013
|
posted April 17, 2015 12:10 AM
quote: Originally posted by PrettyPisces: I agree Jo B it's hard sometimes to decipher what he means because it often comes off as something that can be interpret either way like a guy talking to his bestfriend or his girlfriend . Sidenote : I can recall though a friend of mine told me to be careful because he comes off as liking you and everybody sees it yet he doesn't want to and does now or he didn't in the beginning and now he does but he's trying to convince himself overwise , she said he'll hurt me . I didn't understand back then but now her point is valid . He's an avid gamer too, he's 24 Jo B I'm going to take the advice from the forum users and my loved ones , and let him know how I feel . That way I'll know hopefully he's honest and let's me know how he really feels . On another note if this is an unrequited love , I can really do my part by healing myself and move on .
Personally, I wouldn't expose my heart to him. He hasn't EARNED it. Are you going to have to baby him all the time? Let him be. If he wants you, he will have to convince you. My goodness, you are WORTH it.IP: Logged |
PrettyPisces Knowflake Posts: 162 From: Cambria heights,NY Registered: Jun 2011
|
posted April 23, 2015 11:26 PM
So the weirdest unexpected thing occurred tonight . His bestfriend ( which is also I friend of mine ) and he's a big advocate for wanting me and his bestfriend to be together . He knows what transpired between him and I and he told him he was going to tell him about hisself . What ever he said to him must of resonated or he must of knew what was best because he called me tonight ( I haven't heard from him est January ) and he apologized for how he treated me . I humbly accepted his apology . However Idk if I want him in my life right now , I really was hurt by what happened I'll keep you all updated ❤️ IP: Logged |