Lindaland
  Astrology
  Arent Cancers supposed to be Motherly? (Page 1)

Post New Topic  Post A Reply
profile | register | preferences | faq

UBBFriend: Email This Page to Someone!
This topic is 3 pages long:   1  2  3 
next newest topic | next oldest topic
Author Topic:   Arent Cancers supposed to be Motherly?
Secret Garden
unregistered
posted December 30, 2004 04:41 AM           Edit/Delete Message   Reply w/Quote
Hi guys
Lately Ive noticed, and Ive been noticing this for a while now, that the Cancer women around me are not at all motherly. I really thought Cancer woman was supposed to be the symbol of femininity and motherhood? I know six married cancer women. Two of them abandoned their children at foster homes/with relatives.
One of them is going through a divorce and wnats 0 percent custody (she has very young children). She seems to resent them for some reason and says she does not want custody?
One is very abusive to her children and wags her *imaginary tail* after her husband all day long. Her children are growing up as angry teens who hate their mother
My grandmother was also a Cancer sun and could never connect affectionately with her children.
My first cousin refused to have children for fourteen years. She finally got pregnant, had an abortion, then got pregnant again, had a child, then had to be separated from her child because she could not care for it properly.
Its all very weird to me, all astrology claims Cancer women to be very into motherhood?
Ive noticed that although Gemini women aren't supposed to be in motherhood they can be very dedicated mothers? Just a thought
About the Cancer thing, I was thinking about Princess Diana (late) who had loving bonds with her children but separated herself from them because of their father, and searched for fulfilling love relationships thenafter. Could it be true that a Cancer woman needs security first from her partner, and then she will provide security to her children...otherwise not?
What do you think?

IP: Logged

ladya
unregistered
posted December 30, 2004 04:51 AM           Edit/Delete Message   Reply w/Quote
Hello-

Well what are there aspects- there are many in one's indivual chart that might indicate a rejection of mothering role. No one is just there sun sign there are so many other things involved for an accurate chart reading.

IP: Logged

astro junkie
unregistered
posted December 30, 2004 02:16 PM           Edit/Delete Message   Reply w/Quote
Wow -

I cannot believe you know so many un-maternal Cancer women! That's really something. But you touched on an interesting point, in that, she needs to feel she has a stable foundation in order to "work" from. By george, I think you've got it!!!

As a Cancer Mooner, I find it impossible to accomplish any of my long-term (Saturn in Capricorn) goals unless there is a strong foundation for me. It's important for people with Cancer influences to feel secure, that they can trust someone or others to provide them much needed emotional support. We WANT to give and give, but sometimes we confuse it with being taken advantage of when we lose sight of our own "full cups" of love and joy.

Of course, the Aspects ARE important, and again, I look to their Saturns' Sign & Houses to get a better clue. Do you know them by any chance?

Thanks for sharing that.

IP: Logged

whiterabbit
Newflake

Posts: 2
From:
Registered: Sep 2009

posted December 30, 2004 04:20 PM     Click Here to See the Profile for whiterabbit     Edit/Delete Message   Reply w/Quote
secret garden, I think you are onto something.

My mother is a Cancer sun and ever since my father (Scorpio) passed away, her relationship with me and all of my siblings has not been the same- she has become very cold and detached. I never made the connection you did, I thought it was just due to the grief.

IP: Logged

Lauren Leigh
unregistered
posted December 30, 2004 04:28 PM           Edit/Delete Message   Reply w/Quote
I have a close friend who is a Cancer and she at times can be 'motherly' and at times quite the opposite. She can also be exceedingly arrogant (which is most likely due to her Leo Rising) which I find very uncancer like...

My aunt, who also is a Cancer, neglected her children (emotionally) but I don't have any idea what her moon or asc is...I suspect her moon might be a fire sign though, she gets jealous easily.

I think other influences in one's chart have a lot to do with how 'true' the person is to their sun sign.

IP: Logged

matty27
unregistered
posted December 30, 2004 04:31 PM           Edit/Delete Message   Reply w/Quote
hello newbie here, just had to answer this one, am Cancer ++,sun,moon jupiter, since losing husband nearly 2 yrs ago have become very detached and find I cant connect,have 2 children, 1 daughter very near,we seem to grow further apart not closer,and know its me,someone pulled the rug out from under me,am trying to get act together tho

IP: Logged

Secret Garden
unregistered
posted December 30, 2004 06:16 PM           Edit/Delete Message   Reply w/Quote
Hi guys, thanks for ur insight, and ur personal experiences as well;
Matty: Im really sorry to hear about that, and I hope that you can move on and discover the joys of life again (believe me there are so many that we just take for granted )
So far as the aspects, I am sure there must be some, but I was amazed by the fact that six women I personally knew, plus some other Cancer celebrities (like Princess Di) have been somewhat distant/unreceptive mothers. Not to say I am accusing the sun sign of being cold mothers, (not at all!) but rather an observation about how it starkly constrasted everything I had read about Cancer mothers.
Also, I was thinking about Courtney Love--no doubt has some hard aspects in her chart, but shes a Cancer sun and Cancer moon and also is considered a bad role model as a mother. She had to suffer her husband (Kurt Kobain's) death and a lot of the negative publicity with it. Would totally understand how it would be so difficult on her. Her daughter is constantly exposed to her temper tantrums and drug abuse and has been taken away from her custody many times because the court has ordained that she is not fit to be the caretaker.
Just a thought....keep me posted on what you guys think!

IP: Logged

Kat
unregistered
posted December 30, 2004 06:52 PM           Edit/Delete Message   Reply w/Quote
I'm a Cancer Leo rising and though I really love kids, I'm not a mother nor married. My father was pretty abusive as a child and for many years I felt I would be incompetent as a parent and pass on bad "habits. However, I think I would be a very good mother if I were to adopt children now - but I'm hesitant without a strong father figure for a Dad. I think Cancer women need to have a strong foundation and a stong man to go with being a good mother. My relationships with men have been poor but improving over the years.I think Secret Garden has touched on a topic I've thought about for years.
I have an Aunt on my father's side who is also a Cancer - she definitely did not exude a loving way about her when I was growing up. She was very cold and rational in her thinking. If you knew my Scorpio grandmother you'd understand where my father and Aunt came from -- no love there.

IP: Logged

passionfruit3000
unregistered
posted December 30, 2004 07:44 PM           Edit/Delete Message   Reply w/Quote
I am totally surprised that I'm not the only one that have noticed that not all Cancer women are maternal!(I'm an untypical Cancer myself). what's funny is, I found most of the descriptions of Cancer itself have been a little off for the majority of the Cancers that I know. i prsonally think that the best parents are Aries, Geminis, Libras and Aquarius because they are the most easy to talk with and are preety affectionate. Cancer parents can be cold, arrogant and overprotective with their kids- but I'm sure that deep down inside, they love their children and mean well.

IP: Logged

ineedlove
unregistered
posted December 30, 2004 08:40 PM           Edit/Delete Message   Reply w/Quote
I have a cancer rising and my friends always accuse me of being motherly. Sometimes they say "you sound like my mother".... etc

IP: Logged

Kat
unregistered
posted December 30, 2004 08:51 PM           Edit/Delete Message   Reply w/Quote
I hate to say this, but I used to teach long ago and unfortunately most people make "incompetent" parents no matter what sign. Parents tend to be young, inexperienced, project their problems onto their kids, continue with generational family problems, and the list can go on. I've met poor parents of all signs!

IP: Logged

Secret Garden
unregistered
posted December 30, 2004 09:45 PM           Edit/Delete Message   Reply w/Quote
wow Kat thats so true
Sometimes I feel so trapped, misunderstood, and dominated, by my mother, that I want to make a HUGE list of things not to do when I become a parent (if I become a parent).
Did you by any chance teach at a community college in California?
Just wondering because I had a teacher named Kat.

IP: Logged

moonlightmaiden
unregistered
posted January 10, 2005 08:33 PM           Edit/Delete Message   Reply w/Quote
I don't have children of my own.....but I love my neices and nephew with all my heart.....I would do anything for them and protect them with my life, I try to take the best care that I can of them. I am looking forward to having children but sometimes I just can't bear to bring a child in the world, I would just worry all the time about them, its just not a safe world. I'm not sure if this makes me motherly or not? I think I really would like to adopt and maybe have one child of my own though just to go through the amazing experience

------------------
Jennifer
Mt student
www.mtacc.net

IP: Logged

pidaua
Knowflake

Posts: 67
From: Back in AZ with Bear the Leo
Registered: Apr 2009

posted January 10, 2005 10:03 PM     Click Here to See the Profile for pidaua     Edit/Delete Message   Reply w/Quote
My Mother is a Cancer with a Cancer moon / scorp rising.

I have an Aries moon, my brother has a Scorp moon (harsh moon positions).

I also have Moon square Mercury which also opposes Uranus.

My mom was not ready to be a mom and was not happy with the fact that babies poop, pee, vomit and "need" their mother. In other words I grew up very fast and when my parents divorced, I become "mom" at 12 years old while my mom worked.

We are close now- but I really resented what she put me and my fellow Sag brother through. She has since apologized and I understand / empathize with her (my dad is a Cap /Cancer moon with venus in the 12th - he had many affairs. He attracted many women, with his charm and badge).

My brother still won't let go of the pain. For me, it taught me to be a heck of a lot more serious and determined - which is good for us notoriously "freedom" loving Centaurs.

Once we got into a fight and she yelled "You did it...you always said you would NEVER end up like me, depending on a man or being left with kids and no career". She resented the fact that I put myself through college and made my career number 1. I did that so that I would never end up like her. I figured if I got that out of the way, then I could concentrate on a relationship. I guess you could say that for a while I was her exact opposite.

NOW..I am in the middle

IP: Logged

seveneieghtorange
unregistered
posted January 11, 2005 03:43 AM           Edit/Delete Message   Reply w/Quote
I am a Cancer Sun, Aquarius Rising and Scorpio Moon.
I think the whole security-first-and-then-we'll-give-em-to-loved-ones, cos of trust is very right. We want to know that we can lean on ppl when times get hard but at the same time, not looked on as weak and defenseless.
The whole Cancerian motto is, as selfish as this may sound and maybe not ALL Cancerians would agree; to feel safe and protected FIRST along with family and friends and then give out love and affection.
My friends say I can be cold and detached, but I give out good advices and I find myself telling my friends to be safe on the road, and if they have their jacket with them whenever it's raining? I won't be sweet about it, though, I kind of lay it on them like a rule. Same goes to my brother and my co-workers...

IP: Logged

Secret Garden
unregistered
posted January 11, 2005 04:33 AM           Edit/Delete Message   Reply w/Quote
pidaua: glad to know u achieved balance... hehe i always see ppl who want to be opposite of their parents, and then i also see ppl who want to be exactly like their parents, I guess im none of the above, because as much as my mother drives me nuts with her despotic rule over my life she is still a very disciplined, strong woman who is extremely successful and popular...and I admire some things greatly about her hehe

seveneieghtorange: i didnt think of the point as selfish, but merely a commentary on how the cancer motherliness manifests itself and whether it even is what we think of it to be (all lovey dovey pure motherly feeling. The one thing we know about motherliness is that it is supposed to equate self sacrifice and total giving). However, I have yet to see one single Cancer like that (!). I wouldnt say at all that your claim is selfish, afterall, aren't all of us (or at least majority) selfish? I know I try to go against my natural selfishness, but hey everyone has their self esteem, self protection issues which is diff from selfishness. I think most of the motherliness thing is probably one of the ancient astro stereotypical myths, because I haven't seen motherly cancerians in any proportion that is different than the motherly-any-other-sign proportions.

IP: Logged

cancerrg
Newflake

Posts: 0
From:
Registered: Sep 2012

posted November 02, 2005 01:46 AM     Click Here to See the Profile for cancerrg     Edit/Delete Message   Reply w/Quote
a new facet of the cancers .

even i wasn't aware ? any experiences about cancer fathers , guys?


IP: Logged

XMelanieXy
unregistered
posted November 02, 2005 02:50 AM           Edit/Delete Message   Reply w/Quote
Some Cancers are eternal mothers and other are eternal children in need of mothering. Sometimes you can be both.

IP: Logged

LeylaLeFay
unregistered
posted November 02, 2005 03:23 AM           Edit/Delete Message   Reply w/Quote
A very interesting post. After much observation I have noticed something-

Women: seem to "take care of" their children only so much as the childrens father "takes care of" them.

Men: seem to love their children only so much as they love the childrens mother.

This explains so much, like why a man can abandon his wife and children, then fall in love with a woman and raise kids that aren't even his, while he doesn't bother to pay child support for his own flesh and blood.

It's even in the Bible, didn't Jacob favor Joseph, his son by Rachel, teaching him to read and write and do math, while the sons by all his other wives went uneducated?

And I've seen many women become disenchanted with their child the moment they become disenchanted with the childs father. Projecting all the fathers negative traits onto the poor kid.

IP: Logged

CancerianMoon
unregistered
posted November 02, 2005 05:20 AM           Edit/Delete Message   Reply w/Quote
Well here is a big confession for me..Cancer Sun, Gemini Moon, Aqua Rising.
6 children..too many relationships..and not the most wonderful mother..Am just becoming the mother i always dreamt of being and new i could be...My eldest is 13 my youngest is nearly 3..My eldest children have suffered through my relationships..my constant moving and my up and down states of mind(anxiety and depression in past few years..alsmost like breaking point)...I suffered young at the hands of and uncle(my mums brother) who sexually abused me from the age of 4 till i was about 13-14..killed himself when i was 23 because it was coming out in the open..my mum lives in state of denial about it..and was not affectionate towards me at all growing up..My dad left my mum when i was 5 because he was gay and wanted a life with men so i neve saw him again till i was 23(he abandoned me)...my step dad always treated me a little different and never with affection..i feel this affect on me(cancer sun especially) made it extremely difficult to be in a good frame of mind to be a strong mother..thou my heart wanted me to be..only now with councelling and healing(yes my strong base..feeling whole and a worthwhile human being not for what i do for others but because i am me!!not necessarily a mans support that makes me whole) is what im gaining now that will help me be a good mother that my kids deserve. So i would say that the effect of childhood on a Cancer Sun is also very significant with regards to them being a good parent..aswell as any sign i guess..but i feel more so for us Cancerians.

------------------
Some people weave burlap into the fabric of our lives, and some weave gold thread. Both contribute to make the whole picture beautiful and unique.

IP: Logged

Isolaede
Newflake

Posts: 18
From: Sunny CA
Registered: May 2009

posted November 02, 2005 06:02 PM     Click Here to See the Profile for Isolaede     Edit/Delete Message   Reply w/Quote
Whow lots of food for thought here. I’m a Cancer sun / Sag Ascendant so I’ll do my best to gather up my thoughts and try expressing things clearly here – hah - - bear with me if this ends up being a bit stream of consciousness.

First of all, I have to say I used to think the Cancer reputation for being motherly a bit overblown. I never wanted children through most of my youth. However, Cancer’s tend to pick their family I think. For example, I’ve always mothered my friends and boyfriends. The primary way I show my affection is by taking care of them. The thing that sours this for me is when I feel I’m being taken advantage of. If I feel used I tend to take a more reserved, tough love outlook which I think you might see in a lot of Cancer parents. For example: I had a boyfriend that was constantly experiencing odd, migrating, debilitating physical pain. I used to truly feel that his pain was legitimate so I was constantly going on drug store runs. After a while I started to doubt that his pain was legitimate. I suspected he was a hypochondriac, so I got much more reserved and a bit cold when he was in pain, I tried to help reason him out of his pain. I’m sure he interpreted this as me being cold and unsympathetic, but in truth he’d just exhausted the well of my empathy after years of the same weird issues. I still feel bad about that, because part of me still wonders if his pain wasn’t legitimate, but at the time I just felt used and a bit resentful and it transformed me from the nurturing “mother” type to something more distant and cold. I was still trying to “help” but my tactics changed to the “tough love” modal.

In the case of remote Cancer parents, I think there are a lot of Cancers that have a lot going on beneath the surface. Still waters run deep. Cancer parents that seem distant could be suffering from their own version of emotional trauma which makes them hide in their shell. This could be stress related, worry related, loss of a loved one, or even worse, feeling unloved by their partner. They could even withdraw so as to shelter their child from their own deep emotions. Cancers are SO emotional, it’s painful sometimes. When a Cancer pulls back into it’s shell it’s not a selective withdrawal, even the Cancer’s children would feel the effects of it. Inside that shell, the Cancer would feel nothing but love and adoration for their children, however their outward actions might not make that apparent. Children don’t just need a good parent that wants the best for them, they need affection. While the Cancer hiding in his or her shell might be a good parent that wants the best for their children, they will not give as much affection as their children need.

I also think it’s very very hard for Cancer’s to let go of children as they grow up. I think relinquishing control of their children’s lives is painful, because they want to be there to protect their children from everything. In having to let go I think some Cancer parents might feel they have to completely emotionally withdraw just so they don’t smother their children. I know I’ve done this in relationships before. When I felt a boyfriend resented me for being possessive, I’d withdraw and try not to feel possessive. In my case this withdrawal cut off ability to express other feelings too – all or nothing.

Of course there are always the Cancer parents that are abusive and just bad. I’d say these are crabs that have gotten so lost in their own shells and their own selfish needs that they can no longer tap into their own innate empathy and care. I can’t stress enough how dangerous the Cancer shell is. Never let any crab you know hide in that shell of theirs for too long. If a Cancer pulls back far enough in their shell they can stop feeling all together. And sometimes they can’t just flip that feeling / empathy switch back on. There was a time in my life when my seven year relationship was going south in a bad way that I couldn’t feel ANYTHING. Not happiness, not sorrow… nothing. I WANTED to be able to feel something but I just couldn’t. I was lost in my own shell. A Cancer lost in their own shell might see only their pain or the object of that pain and become totally focused on that to the exclusion of everything else. So a Cancer abandoned by a bad husband might even use her children to try to punish her husband. By making him take care of them, she might hope to make him realize how much he really needed her in his life. It’s twisted and wrong, but I could see it happening. Truly unhappy crabs can be so lost and selfish – it’s so very sad. This is definitely the ickier side of my sign and I really hate talking about it.

I do also think there is something to Cancers preferring to have a stable foundation for family, but I don’t think it’s essential. I know I never wanted children until I met my current boyfriend. He’s a Cancer as well, and he feels so safe and stable to me. For the first time in my life, I can actually picture having a family and it’s all thanks to him. However, as a 28 year old girl I’ve had to deal with the idea of unexpected pregnancies for years. If I’d ever ended up pregnant I would have raised my child even if it meant doing so on my own. I would never burden someone else with what was my responsibility. I’m not sure what kind of parent I would make, but I can’t picture having a child and not loving that child completely. Whether or not I would show it properly – while dealing with all the stress of being a single parent is another question.

Ok, so that is a LOT of information, but to sum up, I think MOST Cancer’s that don’t seem motherly are probably withdrawn into a shell. They care a great deal, but do not show it properly. Thanks for reading all of this! : ) Hopefully it helps give some insight.

IP: Logged

Aphrodite
unregistered
posted November 02, 2005 06:24 PM           Edit/Delete Message   Reply w/Quote
CancerianMoon, your story touched me. I was saddened to read what happened to you. You are so strong to communicate with such compassion and understanding for your kids. Lots of Love, Aphrodite

IP: Logged

nove731
Knowflake

Posts: 324
From: NYC
Registered: Jun 2009

posted November 02, 2005 09:42 PM     Click Here to See the Profile for nove731     Edit/Delete Message   Reply w/Quote
My best friend is a Cancer/Libra/Pisces, and she's one of the least motherly people I've ever met. She loves OTHER people's kids, but I don't think I could ever see her having one of her OWN. If she ever has kids, I'll bet she adopts...

IP: Logged

beebuddy
unregistered
posted November 02, 2005 09:44 PM           Edit/Delete Message   Reply w/Quote
The oddest thing I've noticed is that Cancer men are more motherly than Cancer women. That's just my little observation (don't wanna step on any Cancer momma's toes)

IP: Logged

iAmThat
Newflake

Posts: 0
From:
Registered: Aug 2014

posted November 02, 2005 09:45 PM     Click Here to See the Profile for iAmThat     Edit/Delete Message   Reply w/Quote
I think all these woman you described really lost faith on their love and hence the rest of the drama followed. Some I believe perceived bad vibes and hence went in to their shell. Its hard for cancers and other water signs to forget what happened to them. They are very feeling driven.

IP: Logged


This topic is 3 pages long:   1  2  3 

All times are Eastern Standard Time

next newest topic | next oldest topic

Administrative Options: Close Topic | Archive/Move | Delete Topic
Post New Topic  Post A Reply
Hop to:

Contact Us | Linda-Goodman.com

Copyright 2000-2022

Powered by Infopop www.infopop.com © 2000
Ultimate Bulletin Board 5.46a