Lindaland
  Astrology
  Would a scorp daugh. hate her father?

Post New Topic  Post A Reply
profile | register | preferences | faq | search

UBBFriend: Email This Page to Someone! next newest topic | next oldest topic
Author Topic:   Would a scorp daugh. hate her father?
thirteen
unregistered
posted January 31, 2006 04:20 PM           Edit/Delete Message   Reply w/Quote
My 12 step daugh. is a scorp. Her father an Aries. He divored the mother right after she was born. She never had him around as a live in father. Her mother still doesn't speak to my husb. ( a little, but mostly they butt heads). My 12 year old step has become arrogant, mouthy and mean to her dad. He has never once broken the visitation arrangement or not paid child support. Not to mention that he is a very good person in general. If the mother is bad talking him would a scorp. girl turn to dislike him? She and her mother are very loyal.

IP: Logged

The Mutable Night Force
Knowflake

Posts: 122
From: England
Registered: Oct 2009

posted January 31, 2006 04:43 PM     Click Here to See the Profile for The Mutable Night Force     Edit/Delete Message   Reply w/Quote
Welll.... maybe... cos you know, Scorpios are Fixed people. Therefore if she's grown up with a strong impression implanted on her brain of her Dad being a bad person, next to nothing will change her mind. It's a hard task. Best not try to force her. Maybe if she's sees enough evidence and comes to her senses she will be able to 're-evaluate' her opinion on her Dad. She probably won't think she hates him, only that she is acting towards him how he deserves for upsetting her mother??
Not sure since I don't know her personally...
What's her Moon sign and his?

IP: Logged

Mystic Gemini
unregistered
posted January 31, 2006 06:19 PM           Edit/Delete Message   Reply w/Quote
The Scorpios I know are usually very family oriented.


------------------
Gemini sun, Cancer rising, mercury in Gemini, moon in Taurus *29, venus in Taurus, mars in Libra

*´¨)
¸.·´¸.·*´¨) ¸.·*¨)
(¸.·´ (¸.·´ * Lost in the peace of serenity
Blind my eyes I cannot see
Lost my soul but found my heart
Again a time, when I shall start

IP: Logged

Happy Dragon
unregistered
posted January 31, 2006 07:30 PM           Edit/Delete Message   Reply w/Quote
thirteen

.. re Scorpio (in general) ..

at the moment .. astrology wise .. there are some major planets affecting that sign ...

Saturn .. Neptune and Chiron .. are currently at a 'square' angle to Scorpio
Jupiter is currently 'in' the sign of Scorpio ..
Sun and Mercury .. are currently at a 'square' angle to Scorpio
Mars is currently 'opposite' the sign of Scorpio

those above transiting planets .. are themselves in Fixed signs ..
(((*MNF* good reminder about 'fixed' .. i often forget .. (( '''digs out old bee gee tape''' :-)))

not to mention .. Lillith .. who is about 1 degree into Virgo ...
i brought in Lillith .. as she is excellent at generating a bitter type of hatred and anger ..
so Liilth is only 1 degree off post-squaring Scorpio ....

note .. when i've mentioned Scorpio here .. i'm refering to the 30 degree span of a Sign ..

.. it would be helpful to see the birth chart .. so as to see what transiting planets etc
may be affecting her Sun placement ( for starters ) .. she could well be having a
Saturn transit to her Sun ( it's gotta happen sometime .. to all of us )

hd

IP: Logged

GemStar
unregistered
posted January 31, 2006 07:36 PM           Edit/Delete Message   Reply w/Quote
Hello thirteen...

Firstly, you are talking about a young girl here....forget about her being a Scorp for a moment.

A young pre-teen does not care about whether he has paid his child-support or been consistant with visitation. (Meaning- the focus is less on this part because it has not been an issue).
As a Scorp ASC, when my parents divorced, the resentment I had towards my father was immense. For many reasons....which I will not get into...but mostly because my Scorp Mom was so angry and upset. For years I heard the bad-mouthing...saw the crying....etc. It was not pretty.

When you are 12, you simply do not understand relationships very well. She hasn't had the experience or maturity to completely comprehend the WHYS exactly of what happened. That will come with time. Lots of time.

Really the best you can offer to your husband is this: Have him take the private time to have her discuss her feelings of anger with him. (Without you being present). This young girl needs to feel safe in discussing her disappointment, resentments, shame, rejection, abandonment etc....with her father. He needs to be prepared with answers that a 12yo can comprehend and believe.

One of the best things my father told me was that he left and married my step-mom because he wanted to show us an example of a happy and good marriage. (and he did!) At the time, all I could see was the fact that I had to toe the line for so many years...following each rule exactly, being punished when I was not perfect...and then POOF, my Dad blows it with a huge, gigantic mistake. What was that about??!! I thought-- Parents aren't allowed to make mistakes!! I felt ripped off!!

(Not to mention: Young girls are sorting out themselves and feelings/emotions....puberty etc....lots of emotional changes for a few years there!!)

In her case, there most likely is the abandonment issue....he left as she was just born...she may feel the rejection personally...and wonder why SHE wasn't good enough for her Dad to stick it out. That is the immaturity talking...the mind of a 12yo who does not yet understand what happens in a relationship/marriage that is not working anymore. She does not yet comprehend that children are not the reason for marriages breaking up. (This is most likely where her mother twists the truth and creates the idea that they were not 'good enough' or whatever for her father to stay with them as a family).

Her mother may have done her a disservice by pulling the loyalty card (boy, do I know that one!) yet all I can tell you is this....little girls grow up and gain a clearer understanding of what happened with experience and time. Your husband needs to continue to be consistant, not bad mouth her mother...you, as a step-mom, be a ready ear when needed (and the time will come).

Mostly, encourage her father to create a safe environment to discuss her issues and upsets. She needs to really believe that he KNOWS and CARES how she feels and despite all her pain-still LOVES HER. The divorce was not about HER....and at 12yo, everything still revolves around you. Relationships are still a difficult concept to grasp at that age.

Hopefully this small post will give you some possible insight and perhaps ideas to share with your husband. As a Scorp ASC, it took me a long time before I forgave-and it took a long time for me to realize it was the best thing that could have happened for us children in the long run!!

Good Luck!!

GemStar

IP: Logged

BlueTopaz124
Knowflake

Posts: 207
From: Portland, OR, USA
Registered: Apr 2009

posted January 31, 2006 07:54 PM     Click Here to See the Profile for BlueTopaz124     Edit/Delete Message   Reply w/Quote
Gemstar, amazing insight and advice, very well said.

Laura

IP: Logged

SparklingSag
Knowflake

Posts: 192
From:
Registered: May 2009

posted January 31, 2006 08:02 PM     Click Here to See the Profile for SparklingSag     Edit/Delete Message   Reply w/Quote
Wow Gemstar -
as a child of divorce parents aged 10 - I totally understand what this child is going through.
And, it has nothing to do with sun signs either...whatever sign the child will be affected. And can I say one thing? Well done to the Dad for sticking around and paying child support and being there. My dad didnt do those things and at 22 it took me a couple of years to work through my own guilt about the divorce etc.

So, this child needs patience, support and to know that her dad will always be there. It's a painful time being a teenager anyway,let alone with divorce. And it is also true that I now understand the complexities of relationships and have forgiven my mum and dad for not making it.

Sorry to rant a little but it's hit a nerve with me:-)
Sparkling


IP: Logged

GemStar
unregistered
posted January 31, 2006 08:16 PM           Edit/Delete Message   Reply w/Quote
BTW Happy Dragon....the BIG transit for me at that time was: Uranus conjuncting my ASC!!
Talk about changing your life and your identity!!

It was interesting to also go back and see the effects of the transits at that difficult time in my parent's charts!!

For this young girl, this time is probably when she is beginning to exercise her thoughts and personality more than ever...pushing boundaries as she enters into her teenage years. Fun time. (Hee-hee! YIKES!!)

Hey, it is all part of Life and the learning process!!

IP: Logged

Happy Dragon
unregistered
posted January 31, 2006 09:19 PM           Edit/Delete Message   Reply w/Quote
GemStar
{{{((( echoes of Topaz and Sparklz .S. )))}}}

IP: Logged

geminstone
unregistered
posted February 01, 2006 03:47 AM           Edit/Delete Message   Reply w/Quote
I wanted to respond to this string, sooo badly, when it first posted ( like SparklingSag, this kinda hits nerves ). GemStar covered most of what I was having difficulty trying to write earlier... the only point that I don't necessarily hold the same belief, that of dad taking her, to talk about her feelings, in absence of dad's wife. I guess I just don't understand who or, why moreso, this is seen to protect or, allow this kiddo to voice her feelings. If it is the desire of both parents to provide that safe, unfaultering foundation, from an already divided home, why then divide again? I guess too though, this would be, largly, dependent on the mental maturity of any and, all adults involved... I too come from divorce and, have Scorp Asc.. Even though it was, also, my Dad that pushed divorce, ( and my Mom tried every angle to change his mind.... but, for the wrong reason..i.e Bro and I ) I held niether of them in any more 'fault' then the other and, in fact, it came as a welcomed peace in my life.... and, my Mom still hurts even as she has been married a little over half of the years she has been divorced from my Dad. My Bro took it a lot different then I did and, he is older. He blamed my Dad but, he lived with him into his late 20's!! What's interesting now, is that Bro and, I are closer to Dad then Mom... well, then again, we always have been, me moreso...
Geez, sorry... kinda went on there...
The best I can give is just to remember that, this is a person trying to find understanding,... no matter age, sign or, otherwise... what she feels, is valid. It is my guess that, if ego's are the only thing absent, then strength should come as a bonus when the understanding has been discovered... but, only you know the bigger picture and, if it be better for you to sit it out.

~ geminstone

IP: Logged

GemStar
unregistered
posted February 01, 2006 04:49 AM           Edit/Delete Message   Reply w/Quote
The reason I suggested having the girl's father speak with her alone is because he is the primary relationship that needs repairing FIRST.
I do not feel it is productive or fair to have two adults sitting across from one young girl...it is too off-balance and intimidating (though certainly with good intentions on the step-mom's part to desire being present)....

Part of the reason is about preserving some privacy for the daughter, in hopes that she will feel comfortable enough to express her true and honest feelings without being judged by more than one adult. The abandonment pain is mostly between the father and daughter. Mend that tie and the rest will fall into place. For now, the step-mom is truly on the periphery on this one.

At a later time, more open discussion with all present will happen naturally. However, a 12 yo with pent up feelings and confusion is a situation which asks a parent to take extra care and sensitivity. Thus-just one of many things to consider when attempting to develop a better relationship between the two.

Certainly if the opportunity opens and the step-daughter wants to talk about the discussion with the step-mom...great! However, only after several solo attempts have been tried on her father's part.

Each young person is different certainly...and having been through a really nasty divorce with years of fighting and court dates between my parents...from my experience and sensitivity in this area, it would be the most logical step to take for the best chance of success!!

Not every divorce has to be ugly with the kids...I wish that the pain of such an event could be reduced as much as possible. Everyone will have ideas of what to do in every situation...however, for those of us who are perceptive and extremely sensitive, best to error on the side of careful respect for a sensitive and hurt young lady.

Once again...thirteen, feel free to ask any of the posters here questions. Those who have read this and felt the pangs of pain want to help...so many of us have been in your step-daughter's shoes in varying degrees. Again...time will heal the wounds and consistancy wins out in the long run!!

GemStar

PS-geministone...all four of us children ultimately are closer with our Dad as well!!

IP: Logged

thirteen
unregistered
posted February 01, 2006 08:46 AM           Edit/Delete Message   Reply w/Quote
Gemstar what you said hits deeply and i am grateful: I don't have a problem with her and her dad talking that out. They made an attempt when she was younger, possibly too young to understand. Oh and also, i only mentioned the child support to establish that my husband's character as it relates to responsibility. Here is more: the mother got pregnant after my husb told her he wanted to end the marriage. She even went to a fertility specialist without his knowlege and took fertility drugs to get pg. They had never conceived in 10 years. This is the kind of desperate woman my stepdaughter has for a mother so goodness knows what she tells her daughter about him.
Anyway: everything mentioned here is helping me get inside her head. I don't compete with her for her dads attention. I am virgo and she and i are friends. But.. i am very much involved in her care when she is in my house. Someone once said " its everyone's responsibility" to raise the children. I took that to heart. She treats me ok but I know its silently killing my husband. I keep telling him when she is older she will see that things are good. I love the explanation of the father wanting to show what a good marriage is about. This child would have grown up in an unhappy situation if he had not left. Maybe she'll grasp that when the time is right. Thank you everyone and keep posting if you have more ideas.

IP: Logged

proxieme
unregistered
posted February 01, 2006 08:53 AM           Edit/Delete Message   Reply w/Quote
Just purely astrologically (ignoring that she's a young girl...which really does make a big differene; crazy hormones, ya?) what the aspects like to her Sun and Moon?

IP: Logged

thirteen
unregistered
posted February 01, 2006 09:54 AM           Edit/Delete Message   Reply w/Quote
11-11-93
in the am. 10:30 Ish. EST
I think she may have a sag. ascendent

IP: Logged

GemStar
unregistered
posted February 01, 2006 10:04 AM           Edit/Delete Message   Reply w/Quote
You know what?? I think knowing what your step-daughter's Moon is would be a great idea!! It will show how she processes her emotions and would be a great leg up for your husband to approach her at a level she will 'instinctively' understand.

At 12yo, sometimes it is soooo difficult to put your feelings into words...especially if the majority of words you have heard about a situation are negative. You do not always know the best words to describe YOUR feelings...otherwise you take on the mother's feelings as your own without really understanding the difference between hers and yours. Does this make sense?

No doubt it is painful for your husband to endure this and he is lucky to have you by his side. I love my step-mom and she treats me better than my own egocentric mother. Just continue to be supportive and urge her father to have faith and believe that good will prevail in the end!! It usually does....the real truth gets sorted out years later and your step-daughter will make her own decisions at that time.

It may also be helpful if her father can open himself up as well and describe some of the painful feelings he felt (and feels now) about ending the relationship with her mother and having to move to a different home from her. How sad or upsetting it was for him to make a choice that ultimately was in the daughter's BEST interest.

Again, here she may not see the clear picture due to her age and preconceived ideas from her jaded mother but he should still attempt to share his sincere and 'real' feelings. There is something humbling about 'seeing' vulnerability in our parents...it somehow takes the edge off your personal hurt in some ways.

Have him share stories of things when she was little that he missed or wanted to see more of...the things he looks forward to sharing as she becomes a teenager...stories that illustrate and make a picture in her mind of what her daddy thinks and feels about her. How important she is to him. It is these images and the sounds of his voice that will help heal her wounds over time. Your supportive role as an additional caretaker and mother to her is wonderful! She is a lucky girl to have you in her life as well!!

Keep trying and being patient.

And finally, I eventually was able to look at my two families as a great thing...I simply had more people who loved me!!

Keep asking questions thirteen....no doubt lots of people may have additional ideas too!! Let us know the Moon sign as well!!

GemStar

IP: Logged

SavageScorpio
unregistered
posted February 01, 2006 05:49 PM           Edit/Delete Message   Reply w/Quote
I don't think she would hate her father, if anything she would want to try to amend things. My dad isn't around, but I'd love to get to know him.

IP: Logged

All times are Eastern Standard Time

next newest topic | next oldest topic

Administrative Options: Close Topic | Archive/Move | Delete Topic
Post New Topic  Post A Reply
Hop to:

Contact Us | Linda-Goodman.com

Copyright © 2011

Powered by Infopop www.infopop.com © 2000
Ultimate Bulletin Board 5.46a