Lindaland
  Soul Unions
  help! cancer man sending mixed signals

Post New Topic  Post A Reply
profile | register | preferences | faq | search

UBBFriend: Email This Page to Someone! next newest topic | next oldest topic
Author Topic:   help! cancer man sending mixed signals
cloudynight1017
Newflake

Posts: 7
From: appleton, wi, usa
Registered: May 2011

posted May 30, 2011 12:43 AM     Click Here to See the Profile for cloudynight1017     Edit/Delete Message   Reply w/Quote
First off I want to apologize in advance for how long this probably will be, I just wanna make sure I leave nothing out. Second before I even start my birthday is 10/17/84 libra and his is 7/1/85 cancer. So my story starts 12 years ago. Freshman year of high school. I was kinda crushing on this guy named max, I thought he was cute and there was something about him that I just couldn't put my finger on, mysterious almost, We weren't friends and the only words that were spoken between us were cocky remarks while we passed each other in the hall, you know the common teenage name calling, he would say "hi fat ***** ", and I would reply with "go fk yourself maxipad". It was nothing ever more than that. Well he switched schools and started his sophmore year at that school, so last day of freshman year was the last time I saw him. Not a big deal seeing as how we weren't friends or anything and he wasn't part of my life. Well a few years ago I came across the words "fat ***** " written in my year book, and I started to think about him. At first it was "I wonder what happened to him" but then it became more persistant. I tried looking for him several times on facebook and myspace but came out with nothing everytime. For some reason I felt like I needed to contact him. Don't ask me why but it drove me crazy for awhile there. Now I have to add in here that I was with my husband since I was 16. Ok so now april 1st my husband says he wants a divorce, things got really really bad between us. I was really upset. After trying everything I could possibly try he just gave up, and he was still cheating on me. So yeah I was really really depressed and just feeling simply hopless. Now on april 3rd I get a friend request from max, the guy from h.s. and he messaged me saying that in his yearbook I wrote that I owe him a beat down, and he thought it was about time to collect and that he was wondering if I wanna get together and hang out or something. I find this weird for 2 reasons. Reason 1, we never even hung out in school, I thought I was just someone who he liked to make fun of and that's it, and for 2 the timing, you have to admit the timing is a little strange. Anyway, the next day he calls me and we talk for a bit and I invited him out to eat with my son, my best friend, who also went to school with us, and myself. He said sure and that he was going to ask to come with anyway. Now because of certain things that have happened in my life I have grown to be a very shy and insecure person. I was so nervous and I didn't know what to say to him or anything, I felt like I made an ass out of myself. Later that night I texted him, apologizing for being weird and that I was really nervous. He asked why I was so nervous and so I told him cause I used to have a huge crush on him back in the day. He text back "wow, now that's some honesty". Now I'm going to quickly add in here that since that day we have al leasted texted each other everyday with the exception of one day. As far as texting goes its impossible to have a conversation with him, it always surface things, like how was your day, what's up, that sort of thing and generally his answers are short and simple. I'm almost always the first one to text him but he is always the one to call first. So, anyway, I first stayed the night at his house april 6th. It was really akward, I didn't know what to say and like I aid I became really shy. We ended up sleeping in the same bed but made sure we didn't touch each other. In the morning before I went home he rolls over and asks if I would be up for some casual sex, at first I was hesitant but then I figured what the hell, what do I got to lose plus I have wanted this since I was 15 so we ended up having sex. I have stayed at his house now a total of 12 times in less than 2 months time. Things are still akward at times between us but it has improved a lot. We do have sex everytime and there still hasn't been any cuddling. So about 3 weeks ago I told him that I was starting to like him and that I'm not sure I can keep emotional from physical and no matter what it is to him, I'm cool with whatever, but I needed to know if this was a strictly friends with benefits thing for him. He texted back "I go with the flow". And that's it, nothing else was said that night. So I continued on like I never said anything but he started asking me if I wanted to hang out instead of it always being me. About a week and a half ago we got drunk and he asked me to move in, but he emphasized just as roommates for financial reasons and that he liked me and all and thought I was cool but he didn't want a relationship and wants nothing more than a friends with benefits deal on occasion, he also said that he isn't saying it will never happen, and that in fact its likely it will but he doesn't want that right now. The next day I was really sad and hurt by that so I didn't text him and everytime I text him it seems that I bother him more than anything but he texts back to be nice. Surprisingly he texted me and asked if he did anything while he was drunk to upset me and that usually he has 8 texts from me by this time , and I didn't respond. He texted again saying that my silence must mean a yes. I said no, that I'm just really sad. He asked what I was sad about and I told him that I was sick of feeling alone, that I have nobody to hug me and tell me they love me, and that everything that I went through with my husband effects me a great deal. He said being alone sucks and that his offer of me moving in still stands. But since that night things have seemed to change. He is more talkitive, he actually calls me to talk to me about things that are bothering him. He likes to tease me about random things. He hates boy bands and just the other day I saw that backstreet boys and new kids on the block were touring, I texted him right away and told him that since he loves those bands so much we can go see them together. He said not a chance in hell. Later that night he called and I brought it up again and told him at the least he can go cause there will be tons of chicks there that he can hit on. He said no, he didn't want to make me mad. I told him I have no reason to get mad and that he is free to do what he wants. He was just like so you mean to tell me it wouldn't bother you? I said well yeah it would bother me but I can't stop you and I have no reason to get mad about it. He said no I don't wanna make you mad yet again. Then just last week when I stayed, he must of had like 4 beers and we were drawing on each other with sharpie. Well my friends called and I was laying on his couch talking to her. He came and sat next to me with his back on my stomach and held my hand, we must have sat there and held hands for like 5 minutes and he was joining in on my phone convo. then he started writing on my chest and neck with the marker again and when he was done he laughed and then leaned over and gave me a kiss, like a kiss you would when you are with someone. He pulled away and looked at me, I was still on the phone mind you, and I asked him if that was his way of apologizing for what he drew on me, he half smile the cutest smile and said yeah something like that and leaned over and kissed me again. I'm confused. His reasons for calling me are generally for dumb reasons, like to tell me about a video game or how his crazy neighbor is being crazy again. But like I said he has been calling a lot more lately since he asked me to move in. Yesterday he called me 4 times and we talked for 3 hours total and he told me that one of these nights we are going to have a harry potter marathon. I have never been in a friends with benefits thing before and I was with my husband for 11 years so I am clueless as to what I am doing. I really like him a lot and I guess I'm not sure if I'm reading into this too much or if this is turning into something more than what he says. Sex with him is awesome, lots and lots of making out, we still don't cuddle but lately he has been sleeping closer and I have woke up a few times in the middle of the night to find his head on my shoulder. Example of dumb excuses to call...yesterday he called to tell me the kitten I got for him chewed through his wii sensor cord and that he was mad at the cat and to tell me he pawned some stuff and that he got all the harry potters so we will have to do a harry potter marathon. Yeah like I said I don't know anything about a friends with benefits relationship so I don't know if he really does like me and this is his cancer way of doing things or what, thanks for listening to me ramble I just don't know what to do and I desperately need some insight before I drive myself crazy lol, thanks again

------------------
"Ask me how many times my
heart as been broken, and I
will tell you to look at the sky
and count the stars"

IP: Logged

Mysticknowflake
Knowflake

Posts: 176
From: PA
Registered: Mar 2010

posted May 30, 2011 03:53 AM     Click Here to See the Profile for Mysticknowflake     Edit/Delete Message   Reply w/Quote
Hi, I just wanted to let you know that i read your post and it left me kind of speechless, not in a bad way or anything. I wish I knew some great advice to give, but matters of the heart are very tricky and I don't quite know what to say. I am a very direct person, I have no problem asking the other person how they feel. It saves endless worry and time, also it helps put things in perspective. When we assume what the other person is thinking and feeling, sometimes we are so far off from what the truth is. It sounds as if he is getting close to you and may be a bit gun shy himself. Just be patient and as he says "go with the flow" for a bit. I've never been involved in a fwb relationship, as it just isn't me, sounds as if it isn't you either. Maybe things will work out and it will be a true, solid relationship with time.
I know this probably didn't help much. just wanted to let you know that you were heard. Good Luck and Blessed Be!


IP: Logged

bunnies
Knowflake

Posts: 418
From: u.k
Registered: Apr 2009

posted May 30, 2011 04:41 AM     Click Here to See the Profile for bunnies     Edit/Delete Message   Reply w/Quote
Yes I was a bit speechless.
Nothing like starting a relationship with the romantic phrase "f*** off maxipad"

Anyhow this is my twopence worth.

1.He likes you probably always has.

2.You read too much into everything. Sometimes people just say things.

3.You are way too intense for him and he will end up withdrawing back to occasional texting and FB.

4. The fact that you went along with the "casual sex" thing tells him all he needs to know. That's exactly what you will get. Casual sex and half the bills if you move in with him.
He will then look elsewhere for someone a little less challenging mentally, a little more challenging physically and leave you broken hearted...again, whilst chirruping the immortal phrase "I thought we were just friends"

5. Men do not like cuddling. They don't like the word and most certainly don't like talking about it. When a man has had sex all he wants to do is go to sleep because all the blood has drained from his brain. Biological fact.

6. You are not in any position to enter a relationship. You are vulnerable and still hurting and your self esteem is on the floor which is why you are acting like this. Needy and clingy and questioning. And you want to make him make you feel otherwise. He is not in this place at the moment. He wants fun.

If you want this guy THIS is what you do.
Tell him "You are not ready for anything"
Withdraw the sex, keep your texts light and breezy. watch a movie with him. If he touches you, smile sweetly and say
"Sorry, but like I said,I made a mistake I'm not ready"
Even throw in a "It's not you it's me"
Do this for a LONG time.

Convince him you are worth chasing instead of a whimpering love me, love me, cuddle me, I need this,bag of insecurity.


Have I covered anything? I'm off for a cup of tea and a lie down

IP: Logged

TrueTaurus
Knowflake

Posts: 139
From: California
Registered: Nov 2010

posted May 30, 2011 03:49 PM     Click Here to See the Profile for TrueTaurus     Edit/Delete Message   Reply w/Quote
Bunnies is right. It's not good if you're the first to initiate texts. Also, you mentioned he said by now you would've sent him about 8 texts. That should never happen. Always let him chase you, or else you'll end up feeling clueless like now. What's happening right now is that he does not want the responsibility of a real relationship but he likes the intimacy with you. He did straight out ask if you wanted casual sex. Seems like he likes you...if you withdraw now, most likely he will initiate a text/call and what not. Also, what I find most annoying is he hasn't asked you out on a real date. A man should, and would ask a woman out to dinner if he was serious...Show him he's going to need to work harder for you. If he's doesn't do anything more, then most likely, he is not taking you seriously because at your guy's age, dates should be more sophisticated, and he should know this. Or you guys are just hanging out as friends. The reality is, if he wants sex, he's going to need to do more for you.

Esther
Taurus/Scorpio/Cancer

IP: Logged

cloudynight1017
Newflake

Posts: 7
From: appleton, wi, usa
Registered: May 2011

posted May 30, 2011 05:38 PM     Click Here to See the Profile for cloudynight1017     Edit/Delete Message   Reply w/Quote
I thought cancers like to be the ones that are chased? He has asked me to a movie but the movie we wanted to see wasn't playing after all and he has asked me to do dinner with him but I already had made plans. Yes I may be the one that 99 percent of times that texts first but he ALWAYS the one to call first. He told me he isn't too fond of texting. I just make it a point to at least text him once a day just to ask how his day was, that's it. I guess the things that throw me off and make me think that there might be more than what he says is his comment of not wanting to make me mad by flirting with someone else and the fact that communication has doubled the past week. Like I said we were on the phone a total of 3 hours Saturday. He said he called me cause he knew I would be awake, I said thanks, good to know I'm your last resort, he said actually you were my first pick so you should feel special. Then that random kiss, do you really do that with a friends with benefits? Thursday night he called me and asked if I wanted to spend all day Friday with him for sober day? Why would he ask me and not one of his close friends? He remembers things about me like how I don't like spicy food which at that point I only said once but he won't remember something I said about someone else on 5 different occasions. Like I said before, lately he is the one that has been asking me to hang out. Everything I have read about a cancer male says that they are really indirect, coulid this be his way of testing the waters so to speak? He isn't very open at all about his feelings and would rather hide them and from them than deal with them. Saturday night when he called he asked that if he were to show up at my house right then would I pretend to not be there, I said of course not, and he proceeded to tell me he was going to come pick me up, but I had my son so I couldn't. I guess I just want to know if this is a guys version of a fwb or a cancers way of indirectly being interested in you

------------------
"Ask me how many times my
heart as been broken, and I
will tell you to look at the sky
and count the stars"

IP: Logged

TrueTaurus
Knowflake

Posts: 139
From: California
Registered: Nov 2010

posted May 30, 2011 10:52 PM     Click Here to See the Profile for TrueTaurus     Edit/Delete Message   Reply w/Quote
Regardless of his sign, he's male. He will chase you if he wants you. It's fine that he doesn't like to text, actually it's great that he calls. Honestly, from reading your response it sounds like the guy likes you. Only time will tell, in the mean time I suggest let him chase you and don't text him everyday.
The fact that he likes you (with your past, etc.), I think he may have Capricorn Moon.

IP: Logged

cloudynight1017
Newflake

Posts: 7
From: appleton, wi, usa
Registered: May 2011

posted May 30, 2011 11:17 PM     Click Here to See the Profile for cloudynight1017     Edit/Delete Message   Reply w/Quote
If I'm not mistaken I think his moon is sagittarius

------------------
"Ask me how many times my
heart as been broken, and I
will tell you to look at the sky
and count the stars"

IP: Logged

sassaqua
Newflake

Posts: 14
From: Australia
Registered: May 2011

posted May 31, 2011 02:34 AM     Click Here to See the Profile for sassaqua     Edit/Delete Message   Reply w/Quote

Hi there Libra girl,

Can you post some charts for us to take a look at maybe?

IP: Logged

bunnies
Knowflake

Posts: 418
From: u.k
Registered: Apr 2009

posted May 31, 2011 02:56 AM     Click Here to See the Profile for bunnies     Edit/Delete Message   Reply w/Quote
True Taurus
You are right...but she ain't listening!
You are also right about dating too.
Men should always take women out on a date. What's with this friends with benefits nonsense anyway?
That in my book should be called "How to have sex for free without making any bloody effort at all".
The only reason one gets asked on a sober day is because his male mates will have gone
"No beers? Er no thanks!"

I have read all these casual sex posts.
Oh we are just playing it cool, taking it easy, no pressure and they always turn into months later
"Why won't he commit?
" He's not as keen as he once was"
"He's gone off with someone else"

Deep down this is not what women want. They want trust, exclusivity,protection,commitment.

Look, you can all squawk all you like but there is an old German saying and never a truer word.

"Why buy the cow when you get the milk for free"

IP: Logged

cloudynight1017
Newflake

Posts: 7
From: appleton, wi, usa
Registered: May 2011

posted May 31, 2011 03:58 AM     Click Here to See the Profile for cloudynight1017     Edit/Delete Message   Reply w/Quote
Not sure really what you mean by charts but this is what I assume you meant
Me:
Sun: 24 libra
Rising: 1 cancer
Moon: 27 cancer
Mercury: 29 libra
Venus: 27 scorpio
Mars: 9 capricorn
Jupiter: 6 capricorn


Him
Sun: 9 cancer
Rising: 27 virgo
Moon: 29 sagittarius
Mercury: 2 leo
Venus: 25 taurus
Mars: 14 cancer
Jupiter: 15 aquarius


I get what you are saying about letting him chase me, I really do but some men want to be chased, you know, and to me it seems like he is the kind that would rather be the one who is chased compared to the chaser. But either way, it doesn't matter to me who chases who, what matters to me is if he is feeling more than what he let's me believe. I don't believe in your theory of the cow and milk. You commit to someone despite how it started because you never want to lose that person, because you love them and your life has more meaning when you wake up to their face every morning. Feelings are unexpected and come without warning most times. So how do you know that the way he sees me is as a free milk producing cow when love has no limits, no boundaries, and no specific guideline? From what I have read numerous times, cancer men take forever when it comes to love and commitment, let alone the idea of a relationship. Thay go about everything in the most indirect way possible. On top of everything he suffers from anxiety disorder and what he meant by sober day was a day without anxiety meds cause he was starting to over use them from the recent increase of stress in his life. I don't have a car and I would always have to find rides to and from his house in the begining, but the past month he offers to come get me and take me home. We don't have sex right away when I get there, its always when we lay down for bed with the exception of2 times and after sex we lay in his bed and talk and joke around, and watch a movie. Obviously something is changing between us, something is growing, but its hard to decipher sometimes due to the fact that his actions don't really match his words and I have never been in this type of relationship/friendship before.

------------------
"Ask me how many times my
heart as been broken, and I
will tell you to look at the sky
and count the stars"

IP: Logged

Mysticknowflake
Knowflake

Posts: 176
From: PA
Registered: Mar 2010

posted May 31, 2011 04:20 AM     Click Here to See the Profile for Mysticknowflake     Edit/Delete Message   Reply w/Quote
quote:
Originally posted by bunnies:

Deep down this is not what women want. They want trust, exclusivity,protection,commitment.

Look, you can all squawk all you like but there is an old German saying and never a truer word.

"Why buy the cow when you get the milk for free"


so true....

IP: Logged

Deux*Antares
Knowflake

Posts: 951
From: I am where I am and it's enough.
Registered: Apr 2009

posted May 31, 2011 07:18 AM     Click Here to See the Profile for Deux*Antares     Edit/Delete Message   Reply w/Quote
I apologize in advance for my bluntness. I'm a lot older than you, which means I've seen more and I'm only trying to impart to you whatever I've learned from my experiences and from the experiences of other women. First, I am not an advocate for FWB arrangements. All I know about this thing is that if you ever want to be in one make sure you are in it only for sex and nothing more. Once you expect more than that you start to be on the losing end. So if you want just sex, then hook up with someone you don't have feelings for.

Second... Honestly speaking, he is not sending mixed signals. You are the one who is creating the confusion you are in. When he asked you if you would like to have casual sex and you agreed, he was just being a guy who saw an opportunity for sex. From the beginning he was very clear about what he wanted and about the "rules".

My advice to you is: If you want to stop being in a confusing situation, you have to be honest with yourself and with him. Is it really alright with you if he hooks up with someone else?

You have to be clear about what you want in life, in love, in everything. The reason why you are getting mixed signals is because you are in a mixed up state yourself. What you are saying to him is not really what you mean. Truth is he is only reflecting to you what you are -- someone lacking clarity about who she is. So if you want to "unconfuse" the situation, start with being honest with yourself.

Men aren't good at mind reading. They are not gifted like women when it comes to hints and clues and similar stuff. So don't expect him to intuitively know what you want, to decipher that you really want a serious relationship despite your pretending that you are ok with an FWB arrangement.

Whatever happens, don't move in with him . . . unless you are a masochist. Can you imagine how you would feel if he sticks to the FWB thing and you move in, and then one day he meets someone he wants to be serious with? What will happen to you when he wants to bring her home?

I suggest you take a look at yourself and your situation. I know it's difficult for a Libra to not be in a relationship. But I don't think it is a wise decision to settle, to be with someone just so you won't be alone. You have to know what you want and accept nothing less.

Be honest with him and don't see him as someone giving you confusion. Be honest with yourself and take responsibility for your own happiness. You have to make up your mind and make a decision as to what you really want in a life partner. Then you look/wait for that man who will fit everything in your criteria. You don't just take anyone and try to fix him or mold him into what you want. That's a recipe for disaster.

Another recipe for disaster is when you let a man fix you or mold you into what they want. This is what he is doing to you. And he can do it because you are allowing him. So the only way you will come out happy from this setup is if you start claiming your power. Know what you want and stick to it. If you don't want a FWB setup then don't be in one. No one is forcing you to choose an unhappy path. You are making your own choices.

And don't make excuses for him or justify his actions or behavior. You have to always think about what is good for you and not what you believe relationships or love should be. Real life does not always mirror ideals (or fiction or fairy tale).

Íf you have a very strong feeling that he is very likely going to want to have a serious relationship with you, and you don't want to do the strategy given above (let him chase you thing), then I suggest you tell him that the present setup is good only for 2-3 months... that neither one of you can date other people, and that you two should decide at the end of that period if you want to "upgrade" the relationship. By telling him this, you are letting him know that you want something more if it turns out that you two are a good match... you are letting him know that you are not just, to borrow the expression above, "a cow from whom he can get free milk".

Hope I have been of help to you.

IP: Logged

bunnies
Knowflake

Posts: 418
From: u.k
Registered: Apr 2009

posted May 31, 2011 02:58 PM     Click Here to See the Profile for bunnies     Edit/Delete Message   Reply w/Quote
Dear Deux

Beautifully put and so so right.
I don't really understand why people ask for input and then argue vehemently against it.
What they are asking for is clarification for something they are going to do regardless.
Cloudy knows in her heart what she wants to do and that's fine.
Now she just needs to be brave enough to carry it through and trust her own judgement.
And if it goes pear shaped I am sure she will deal with it.
If only in life we were all brave enough to do what the heck we wanted and to hell with anyone's opinions.
So cloudy
I know this is difficult for a Libran but make a choice. You don't need anyone's opinions. You already know what you are going to do, you don't need to convince anyone else.
Have a brave heart

IP: Logged

bunnies
Knowflake

Posts: 418
From: u.k
Registered: Apr 2009

posted May 31, 2011 03:03 PM     Click Here to See the Profile for bunnies     Edit/Delete Message   Reply w/Quote
Aunty Deux, Aunty True Taurus and Aunty bunnies will be here if needed

IP: Logged

Randall
Webmaster

Posts: 8784
From: The Goober Galaxy
Registered: Apr 2009

posted May 31, 2011 07:06 PM     Click Here to See the Profile for Randall     Edit/Delete Message   Reply w/Quote
Welcome!

IP: Logged

TrueTaurus
Knowflake

Posts: 139
From: California
Registered: Nov 2010

posted June 01, 2011 01:34 PM     Click Here to See the Profile for TrueTaurus     Edit/Delete Message   Reply w/Quote
Bunnies...Lol She's probably an aunty to me age wise. I'm 23! But yes, we ladies are here for you if you need us.

IP: Logged

cloudynight1017
Newflake

Posts: 7
From: appleton, wi, usa
Registered: May 2011

posted June 01, 2011 01:47 PM     Click Here to See the Profile for cloudynight1017     Edit/Delete Message   Reply w/Quote
Lol, I'm only 26, my sister is 23

------------------
"Ask me how many times my
heart as been broken, and I
will tell you to look at the sky
and count the stars"

IP: Logged

TrueTaurus
Knowflake

Posts: 139
From: California
Registered: Nov 2010

posted June 03, 2011 02:52 PM     Click Here to See the Profile for TrueTaurus     Edit/Delete Message   Reply w/Quote
Hey cloudy, how goes it with this dude? Everything ok?

IP: Logged

cloudynight1017
Newflake

Posts: 7
From: appleton, wi, usa
Registered: May 2011

posted June 04, 2011 03:46 AM     Click Here to See the Profile for cloudynight1017     Edit/Delete Message   Reply w/Quote
Stayed the night at his house Tuesday and Thursday and both nights he scooted to my side of the bed and when I went to lay down he grabbed me and wrapped me in his arms and made me cuddle with him. Thursday night he was the one to ask me to hang out. He also called last night to hang out but I already had plans. This is the first time he asked to hang out 2 nights in a row and this time he called me when he was with his friends. I have cooled it on the texting and instead he calls at least once a day to every other day tops. I had a sun burn Thursday and it hurt bad so when I was over there he was just like take off your shirt....take a shower, I was like uuuhhh ok why, he was like do you trust me? Go take a shower. So I get to the bathroom and he takes off my shirt and I take off my pants and bra and he takes his shaving cream and put it all over from my neck to waist because it had alone in it. He did it in such a caring gentle way too, not the typical man roughness kinda way. He had me stand like that for 10 minutes and I am really self concious about my weight and body, I'm definatelt not skinny lol, I told him I felt uncomfortable standing there in just m underwear, cover in shaving cream with my tummy flap hanging out, I told him that it took a year to let my ex see me naked, he said well I'm max and I'm different and he pulls my underwear down and said he liks seeing me naked, we ended up taking a shower together together, so yeah that's the update for now lol

------------------
"Ask me how many times my
heart as been broken, and I
will tell you to look at the sky
and count the stars"

IP: Logged

All times are Eastern Standard Time

next newest topic | next oldest topic

Administrative Options: Close Topic | Archive/Move | Delete Topic
Post New Topic  Post A Reply
Hop to:

Contact Us | Linda-Goodman.com

Copyright © 2011

Powered by Infopop www.infopop.com © 2000
Ultimate Bulletin Board 5.46a