Author
|
Topic: God: The Failed Hypothesis, or The God Delusion
|
neptune5 Knowflake Posts: 1609 From: Paradise in Pisces or The Black Moon Registered: Jul 2006
|
posted March 01, 2007 08:02 PM
has anyone read the book (i haven't yet) God: The failed Hypothesis (why science proves god doesn't exist), or The God Delusion?hers part of the information page from 'the god delusion' book
quote: From Our Editors Evolutionary theorist Richard Dawkins is not an atheist who sits quietly in the pews. The scientist Discover dubbed "Darwin's Rottweiler" refuses to regard religion as mere harmless nonsense; he views it instead as one of humanity's most pernicious creations. In The God Delusion, he attacks arguments for the existence of God; accuses religions of fomenting divisiveness, war, and bigotry and castigates believers in intelligent design. From the Publisher Discover magazine recently called Richard Dawkins "darwin's Rottweiler" for his fierce and effective defense of evolution. Prospect magazine voted him among the top three public intellectuals in the world (along with Umberto Eco and Noam Chomsky). Now Dawkins turns his considerable intellect on religion, denouncing its faulty logic and the suffering it causes. He critiques God in all his forms, from the sex-obsessed tyrant of the Old Testament to the more benign (but still illogical) Celestial Watchmaker favored by some Enlightenment thinkers. He eviscerates the major arguments for religion and demonstrates the supreme improbability of a supreme being. He shows how religion fuels war, foments bigotry, and abuses children, buttressing his points with historical and contemporary evidence. In so doing, he makes a compelling case that belief in God is not just irrational, but potentially deadly. Dawkins has fashioned an impassioned, rigorous rebuttal to religion, to be embraced by anyone who sputters at the inconsistencies and cruelties that riddle the Bible, bristles at the inanity of "intelligent design," or agonizes over fundamentalism in the Middle East-or Middle America.
from just this information alone it seems like the books is making some really valid points, and i've always questioned chrisitan/islamic/judiac religion - because it never made sense to me, it just didn't, and i've always believed that religion holds you back from your true potentials, and i'm seriously thinking, its like, personally, i'm never going to be totally athiest without something to believe in, but i'm not going to stay with the church all my life, anyway, i really don't know what to do with myself, but i'll keep you updtated, heres my question, bceause i'm confused about this, i'm taking a college biology course and right now were talking about cell theory, and it basically states cells can only come from pre-existing cells, so since (or if) God doesn't exist, then what was the pre-existing cell that formed the universe? and, since i can ask a question like that, doesn't the cell theory mean that the big bang never happened? (so sometimes, doesn't science cancel itself out?) (some answers to my questions would be great for discussion, and for me to know, lol)
------------------ Virgo Rising 8'57, Sagittarius Sun/4thH 3'26, Pisces Moon/6thH 8'22 "Our passions are not too strong, they are too weak. We are far too easily pleased." - C.S. Lewis "Beauty is eternity gazing at itself in a mirror." - Kahlil Gibran IP: Logged |
lotusheartone Knowflake Posts: 9394 From: piopolis, quebec canada Registered: Jul 2005
|
posted March 01, 2007 08:36 PM
a cell is just protoplasm, unless it has the spark of Life electric energy, desire...to create, spark! The Spark of Life is GOD... force and energy... if science does not tie the soul to Us, they will never figure it out. ... My 2 cents  IP: Logged |
OzMeg222 Knowflake Posts: 628 From: Registered: Jul 2006
|
posted March 01, 2007 08:59 PM
I have faith in a higher power. Not sure what/who that is tho.I have HUGE issues with organised religion in any way, shape or form. Religion is warped by man and the furthest thing away from spirituality you can get. Just look at the problems in the world today and down thru thousands of years of history. Man has done some horrible things in the name of their god. I don't believe any higher power could condone any of that. I read the entire bible 2 years ago out of curiousity. I went to catholic schools most of my life so I'd had it shoved down my throat, but it was interesting to read as an objective adult. I actually laughed that so many people take it as the be all and end all, its contradictory and in so many parts (especially the old testament) more unbelievable than most of the sci-fi/fantasy novels I own. I believe Jesus was a man, a very good, gentle, peaceful, man but not the son of god. If I believed that then I'd believe Anikin skywalker is the son of the 'force'. The higher power is something everyone must believe in to some extent, it can never be proven or disproven. I don't know why people even both to try. Religion on the other hand..... IP: Logged |
lotusheartone Knowflake Posts: 9394 From: piopolis, quebec canada Registered: Jul 2005
|
posted March 01, 2007 09:06 PM
 we are all God's Children created equally...by the Force we turned our back on God MOther and Father, we fell we then, on each continent created religion=laws veiling the Truth of Our un-doing, and changing the Truth... some remains, some is hidden it was all about power and ego same as today... have we learned nothing? God is within, no where else and no One else can connect you, but you... Mind to OverSoul=GOD... . IP: Logged |
Johnny Knowflake Posts: 1791 From: Colorado, USA Registered: Nov 2004
|
posted March 02, 2007 12:25 AM
quote: Dawkins turns his considerable intellect on religion, denouncing its faulty logic and the suffering it causes.
I Richard Dawkins. Still haven't read his book, though. IP: Logged |
BlueRoamer Knowflake Posts: 2140 From: Calm Blue Ocean, Calm Blue Ocean Registered: Jun 2003
|
posted March 02, 2007 06:11 PM
Not to say that religion hasn't accomplished much good in this world, but I do tend to agree with this hypothesis. I really believe that we're moving into an era where we will take the power back to humanity, and away from some deity in a cloud. Remember that pisces is about sublimation, giving up power, whereas aquarius is all about the individual and how they are unique. We are already seeing the new "religion" emerge, look for buzzwords like "the universe," "karma," "manifesting," "synchronicity," "meant to be." People will slowly realize that they contain this "god" energy, that they are god in a way, and therefore have the power to take control and do good on earth. Which is not to say its sometimes nice to "lay down your burdens" on the lord, or some such thing, but I believe people can definitely have more accountability in thie world. IP: Logged |
Mirandee Knowflake Posts: 2085 From: South of the Thumb Taurus, Pisces, Cancer Registered: Sep 2004
|
posted March 03, 2007 01:00 AM
I think there is a lot of truth to the saying that "there are no atheists in fox holes." Because when a person is backed up against a wall, when a person has lost everything and has no where to turn or their life hangs in the balance, who do they always call on for help? It is certainly everyones choice to believe or not in God. There are billions of people who inhabit this planet and there are billions of people who profess some kind of religion and the belief in God. Guess we will all find out in the next life who was right and who was wrong won't we?  IP: Logged |
Johnny Knowflake Posts: 1791 From: Colorado, USA Registered: Nov 2004
|
posted March 03, 2007 04:32 AM
quote: Guess we will all find out in the next life who was right and who was wrong won't we?
Well, if it turns out there is a God, I'm going to have a thing or two to say to Him/Her about this system!  (For the record, I'm not an atheist.)
IP: Logged |
juniperb Knowflake Posts: 6233 From: Blue Star Kachina Registered: Mar 2002
|
posted March 03, 2007 11:07 AM
Mirandee, When I read your post a verse of the Epistle of Barnabas popped into my mind. Barnabas 10:3 Accordingly he mentioned the swine with this intent. Thou shalt not cleave, saith he, to such men who are like unto swine; that is, when they are in luxury they forget the Lord, but when they are in want they recognize the Lord, just as the swine when it eateth knoweth not his lord, but when it is hungry it crieth out, and when it has received food again it is silent. A second century reference to "foxholes" ?   ------------------ ~ What we do for ourselves dies with us. What we do for others and the world is immortal"~ - George Eliot IP: Logged |
Mannu Knowflake Posts: 741 From: Registered: Mar 2006
|
posted March 03, 2007 02:11 PM
Well said Juniperb.So neptune, unless you are in pain you will not know. It is really not about God. Its about us. Heh BlueRoamer. Well said wise one 
IP: Logged |
neptune5 Knowflake Posts: 1609 From: Paradise in Pisces or The Black Moon Registered: Jul 2006
|
posted March 03, 2007 07:37 PM
i've been considering 'the Q'ballah' (i probably didn't spell it right, but i don't know, i'll keep you posted on my new ideas.IP: Logged |
BlueRoamer Knowflake Posts: 2140 From: Calm Blue Ocean, Calm Blue Ocean Registered: Jun 2003
|
posted March 03, 2007 07:41 PM
Nice post Juniperb.I'm not quite sure I understand the meaning of "foxhole," is that like being between a rock and a hard place? I like that passage, how true it is. IP: Logged |
neptune5 Knowflake Posts: 1609 From: Paradise in Pisces or The Black Moon Registered: Jul 2006
|
posted March 03, 2007 07:55 PM
this fits me to a tee quote: In the history of science, alchemy (Arabic: الخيمياء, al-khimia) refers to both an early form of the investigation of nature and an early philosophical and spiritual discipline, both combining elements of chemistry, metallurgy, physics, medicine, astrology, semiotics, mysticism, spiritualism, and art all as parts of one greater force.
would it be called alchemism? yea i think so IP: Logged |
BlueRoamer Knowflake Posts: 2140 From: Calm Blue Ocean, Calm Blue Ocean Registered: Jun 2003
|
posted March 03, 2007 09:54 PM
Alchemy is interesting.....I've seen it defined in different ways.The classic definition I believe is the process of turning another element into gold, the methods of which can vary from magical to scientific. If anyone has read the book, "the alchemist," they'll know that this book definise alchemy as something very different. Alchemy here is a spiritual science in which the person channels god to accomplish their goals. Alchemy is about a spiritual journey, of transforming one's life into what one wants to be. Regardless, I believe that alchemy does imply some sort of a transformation. IP: Logged |
neptune5 Knowflake Posts: 1609 From: Paradise in Pisces or The Black Moon Registered: Jul 2006
|
posted March 03, 2007 10:33 PM
yes, i'm taking on alchemy, an alchemist, it fits me SO well. its like the perfect faith for me, (and it also incorporates astrology too, well what i read of it)IP: Logged |
OzMeg222 Knowflake Posts: 628 From: Registered: Jul 2006
|
posted March 04, 2007 02:40 AM
I hope nobody thinks I don't believe in god/higher power cos I do, very much so.I just don't believe in religion. God/higher power may save me down that foxhole, but how can religion??? IP: Logged |
neptune5 Knowflake Posts: 1609 From: Paradise in Pisces or The Black Moon Registered: Jul 2006
|
posted March 04, 2007 08:52 PM
quote: I hope nobody thinks I don't believe in god/higher power cos I do, very much so. I just don't believe in religion. God/higher power may save me down that foxhole, but how can religion???
very good point OZMeg, religion is usually what is holding people back.
------------------ Virgo Rising 8'57, Sagittarius Sun/4thH 3'26, Pisces Moon/6thH 8'22 "Our passions are not too strong, they are too weak. We are far too easily pleased." - C.S. Lewis "Beauty is eternity gazing at itself in a mirror." - Kahlil Gibran IP: Logged |
Aen Knowflake Posts: 698 From: Registered: Nov 2002
|
posted March 05, 2007 03:12 AM
Johnny quote: Well, if it turns out there is a God, I'm going to have a thing or two to say to Him/Her about this system!
Which system?? Organized religion? But that is humans created mess. System of God's Law? Do we know anymore what it is?
------------------ No hesitation. No regret. No looking back. IP: Logged |
Mannu Knowflake Posts: 741 From: Registered: Mar 2006
|
posted March 05, 2007 03:22 AM
Religion was required in the evolutionary path of Humans. It is indeed a mess now and I believe people can live without that mess But I believe everything's personal choice. We can't force people. Sometimes I wonder if I'm glad to be in America. People may disagree, but people are heard. Which other country can boast of such a freedom. On the downside, is our freedom our greatest weakness? Not when people have evolved and they do not look back. Science will always be there. We have invented airplanes by observing the birds. Theres no denying. It is not alchemy, but science. We learn from nature. All gods, visitors to earth, humans , etc are witnessing God in my opinion. And because we cannot see does not mean they don't exist. The empty space around us is considered to be simple and zero energy vacuum. But it is something which sciene is still baffled with.
Anyways my 2 cents. Cheers.
IP: Logged |
Mannu Knowflake Posts: 741 From: Registered: Mar 2006
|
posted March 05, 2007 03:39 AM
Talking of Alchemy...Does any one watch full metal alchemist on the cartoon network? I used to watch it often from my hotel room. http://www.fullmetal-alchemist.com/game.php
IP: Logged |
Mirandee Knowflake Posts: 2085 From: South of the Thumb Taurus, Pisces, Cancer Registered: Sep 2004
|
posted March 06, 2007 02:31 AM
BR, A "foxhole" is a name given to the trenches that soldiers dug for themselves as protection during WWII. Probably WWI too though I don't know that for a fact. I don't know if soldiers still dig foxholes these days either. I guess the saying came from war when a soldier feared for his life under attack and while the bombs are flying. Yes, juni, that verse is the equivalent to a modern day "foxhole." Well chosen verse.  Religion is a tool like everything else one uses on their spiritual path. It is not the end. It's the means to the end which is God. Mostly religion is how one worships or pays homage to God. Worshipping or paying homage to God has been going on all through human history in one form or another. Many people find worship and the places of worship to be very spiritual. Others find nature to be very spiritual. Some people, like myself, find both nature and places of worship uplifting and spiritual. It is all God and it is taking time aside from the world to pay homage to God wherever you prefer to do it. Even at home in a quiet room. Every place and every organization that has large memberships has to apply some rules and structure. We even have rules here at LL. Otherwise chaos would prevail. That aspect of worship or religion is indeed man made but not meant to control people as much as to have an orderly environment for worship. Each religion has it's own form of worship and the members all share the same beliefs. The doctrines of all religions are meant for the same reason. So that all the people of any chosen religion share the same beliefs. Guess that is why we call it "organized" huh? What works very well for some people in finding their way back to the Source may not work for someone else. Such is life and such is the nature of humankind. No matter. God knows how to reach each and every one of us. Just my thoughts and it's probably all redundant. IP: Logged | |