Lindaland
  Astrology 2.0
  Saturn = Scapegoat?

Post New Topic  Post A Reply
profile | register | preferences | faq

UBBFriend: Email This Page to Someone! next newest topic | next oldest topic
Author Topic:   Saturn = Scapegoat?
downtomars
Knowflake

Posts: 424
From: NY
Registered: Apr 2009

posted August 28, 2009 07:25 PM     Click Here to See the Profile for downtomars     Edit/Delete Message
Unintentional pun…

It seems that a lot of people here have lots of bad and scary things to say about Saturn, especially Saturn in the 7th, but…why? Is everyone afraid of responsibility? Fearful of limitations? Lacking concentration? Not willing to put in any effort?

No offense to anyone, I just used a few Saturn keywords to make a point. Here are a few more keywords:

* Contraction
* Discipline
* Restriction
* Teacher
* Father
* Seriousness
* Stability
* Caution
* Mature
* Endurance
* Persistence

Seriously, think about the Capricorns and Capricorn risings you know…they are RULED by Saturn! Are they awful people? Do they have relationships? Do they have fun?

Personally, I also happen to love, love, love Capricorns. My mom is a double Cap with Saturn in Cap in the first house (!!!) and while she did have a few struggles, she is way on top now! After she divorced my father she had boyfriends, got educated, worked hard and stayed beautiful throughout! I dated a few Capricorns and sure they were always busy and usually tired but – they managed to see me or call nightly, they were really funny and I never had to open my wallet for anything! I wonder where their Saturns were? Had to be in some house and that is another thing:

Saturn is in everyone’s chart! We all have Saturn someplace. Plus to all of you synastry and reading-charts-just-for-romantic-purposes people out there, everything in the chart affects relationships, not just the seventh house!!! Hello! I mean, do you just live your day to day life through one house? I’m at work, let me put my 6th or 10th house cap on – forget my first house and who I am, my 12th house fears, my 8th house sexual needs, screw the 4th house right now because I have a job to do! We should focus on the chart as a whole and work on our squares and oppositions. I wanted to say this in the other thread but I figured I’d do it here: The only way someone will stay single forever is if they FEEL BAD ABOUT THEMSELVES!!! Why someone feels bad can be shown in houses 1 through 12, not just 5, 7 and 8!

It is not healthy to take one questionable planet or aspect and run with it. I can’t say bad planets/aspects because no planet or aspect is really bad – they all come out in different ways! Big, small…For example, I have Saturn in the 8th house. Someone on an astrology forum (not this one) told me that this means that anything I inherit either won’t be much or will be a “yoke around the neck”. I thought about it, and I know that when my mother dies I will “inherit” care of my younger, developmentally disabled brother. I got highly offended! Sure – it will be a “responsibility” but the doom and gloom in that phrase “yoke around the neck” – sheesh! You would have thought that I might be next in line to inherit the company formerly known as Enron or a colony of lepers or a football team full of ne’re-do-wells that I have to coach to victory! Ridiculous!

If anything Saturn teaches you to be more responsible wherever it is, what is wrong with that? Especially in the 7th house - who doesn’t want stability, maturity and endurance in a marriage partner? Everyone wants Venus there but Venus is fickle as hell! But Saturn means “learning a lesson”… Life is one huge lesson, live and learn….

I’m sorry, I am all over the place here…Name something good (of a few good things) about your Saturn, please!

IP: Logged

katatonic
Knowflake

Posts: 1448
From:
Registered: Apr 2009

posted August 28, 2009 07:43 PM     Click Here to See the Profile for katatonic     Edit/Delete Message
with you 100% DTM. i'm another leo fan of cappies! and the women especially seem to stay beautiful FOREVER...

the younger MEN, especially, can be a bit mercenary but i think that is just out of social awkwardness. the older ones seem unfailingly KIND and accepting that life sometimes throws stones at you, so they just get on with it, often very gracefully too.

i think some people, especially young ones, and especially some signs, have a hard time accepting reality and structure, so yeah, saturn can bring it on (depression, scarcity, all the above...) but with a certain amount of experience under your belt that fades in significance.

to me saturn is the great manifestor, bringing things down to earth where we can work with and enjoy them!

IP: Logged

downtomars
Knowflake

Posts: 424
From: NY
Registered: Apr 2009

posted August 28, 2009 08:12 PM     Click Here to See the Profile for downtomars     Edit/Delete Message
quote:
the older ones seem unfailingly KIND and accepting that life sometimes throws stones at you, so they just get on with it, often very gracefully too

Kat, that is something I didn't think about…As PEOPLE, our looks change over the years – pregnancy, weight gain, weight loss, balding and we can become ill – with chronic or acute illnesses. Wouldn’t you want someone stable, responsible and supportive there for those life changes? Or wouldn’t you want to be supportive as well? By the time this thread is done, I hope everyone will wish their Saturn was in the 7th house! (I am an equal houser, but in Placidus my Saturn is in the 7th!)

I notice people have another problem with Saturn in the 7th – the “don’t get married until after your Saturn Return, ages 29-31” thing. I don’t see what the big deal is about waiting. There is a possibility that if you have this placement you were meant to experience other things before marriage. I have seen it in the charts of lots of “independent” type women. Imagine getting married at 24 and during your Return you discover that you’d like to take a year and travel by yourself or that you’d like to not try and have a baby, but you feel that you should take time off from work and write “the great American novel” instead. Not every spouse would be psyched to hear this or eager to participate. Saturn in the 7th can help prevent those “disasters”!

Here is another gripe:

It has to do with ~scary aspect interpretations~ - I have Saturn square Neptune (cue the Wilhelm scream) and some crazy things have been written about it. The one interpretation I remember clearly is this “may wind up in a mental institution”, lol. Hold up – so you are saying that my high school graduating class (and the class below mine – Saturn in Virgo was 2 years, Neptune in Sag for 14 years) will all eventually reunite in the psych center?! LOL – I hate fatalistic interpretations but they are funny!

IP: Logged

starkiss1
Knowflake

Posts: 89
From:
Registered: Jul 2009

posted August 28, 2009 08:20 PM     Click Here to See the Profile for starkiss1     Edit/Delete Message
Thank you,DTM and Katatonic, this is exactly the point i am try to make! Saturn is all about b....y lessons! Some people take long time...

Good thing about my saturn - i live with the Cap and thank God for that, cause i need some stability and maturity and order in my life and i need a lot of it! So, thank you, saturn! Can't wait till you get the hell out of my solar house thou...

IP: Logged

Cheshire Kat
Knowflake

Posts: 328
From: Wonderland
Registered: Apr 2009

posted August 28, 2009 08:32 PM     Click Here to See the Profile for Cheshire Kat     Edit/Delete Message
I don't really perse like my Capricorn Rising or Saturn sitting retrograde in my first house..=S

It makes me feel old, stuffy, awkward and self conscious..and all around..a grandma at 18.

But..yes there is a but..

I always tried to be self sufficient and worked hard at everything, maybe even twice as hard because I never felt good enough.

I feel Saturn in the 7th house would be easier to deal with then Saturn in the 1st, atleast for me.

IP: Logged

triplecancer
Knowflake

Posts: 19
From:
Registered: Apr 2009

posted August 28, 2009 09:30 PM     Click Here to See the Profile for triplecancer     Edit/Delete Message
Thank you DTM! I needed that. I can't understand why people don't like saturn. I actually envy people with strong saturn placements. Sure, it can bring delays and some difficulties, but it's about efforts, discipline, responsabilities, construction and with all that triumphs in the end. I don't think saturn in the 7th is terrible, just means that the person is responsible with relationships and cautious, so this can bring delays, but delays doesn't mean it's never gonna happen.
I agree that people who stay single is because they feel bad about themselves. I've had many difficulties in relationships due to low self esteem. I think it's because saturn is in the 2nd square venus, and capricorn in the 7th, BUT I don't blame it all on saturn. It's part of the lesson I have to learn (as you said about saturn), to love myself.

IP: Logged

Lucia23
Knowflake

Posts: 1055
From:
Registered: Apr 2009

posted August 28, 2009 11:14 PM     Click Here to See the Profile for Lucia23     Edit/Delete Message
Well, I'm a Cap Rising with Saturn in my 7th, conjunct my Moon. (I am also, though, an 8th house Leo Sun-Mercury, and it SHOWS.)

I do take romantic hurts really, really hard, while I am more Leonine in other areas of my life.

BUT I am funny and fun-loving. I like hot young men and adventures. I'm not very conventional or stodgy, and--while I can be tender and intense--I'm not SERIOUS ala the Saturn stereotype.

It is true that I ended my long term relationship after my Saturn Return, but so what? That doesn't mean the relationship wasn't fun, sexy, mind-expanding, close, meaningful, etc...just that it wasn't right FOREVER. As an un-conservative person, I think relationships that touch your life for a weekend can be as meaningful and transformational as relationships that last 37 years...just in a different way.

A lot of the old lore on Saturn is based on very very conventional ideas that we can happily move beyond.

All the threads recently about "Saturn in the 7th=ALONE FOREVER TO MISERABLY DIE ALONE" (not really, but you know what I mean) remind me of a study I read....a bunch of kids, all of whom had the same IQ, were divided into two groups. The group that was told they were high-IQ geniuses started completely excelling at school, including standardized tests. The group told that they were low-IQ started failing at school and getting low test scores.

Similarly, the placebo effect: fake medicine works just as well as real in most human bodies, as long as the people believe it is real.

So please start giving us Saturn in the 7th different messages. As a Leo Sun, here are some of my suggestions:

-Saturn in the 7th people are unusually beautiful, with lean, sexy bodies and intelligent faces

-Saturn in the 7th people have nice hair

-Saturn in the 7th people are extra creative

-Saturn in the 7th people have strong immune systems

-Saturn in the 7th people have more fun

Thank you.

IP: Logged

Lucia23
Knowflake

Posts: 1055
From:
Registered: Apr 2009

posted August 28, 2009 11:14 PM     Click Here to See the Profile for Lucia23     Edit/Delete Message
DP

IP: Logged

bopbop
Knowflake

Posts: 211
From: USA
Registered: Jun 2009

posted August 29, 2009 12:55 AM     Click Here to See the Profile for bopbop     Edit/Delete Message
I thought obsessing over things was Pluto's job.

IP: Logged

MsCandeh
Knowflake

Posts: 172
From: Australia
Registered: Jul 2009

posted August 29, 2009 01:55 AM     Click Here to See the Profile for MsCandeh     Edit/Delete Message
I am totally down with what you're saying DTM! I love Caps too They are usually people I joke around and have fun with. Some are good with responsibilities, others aren't, it's a bit of a mixed bag really. I'd say for the most part there is a sense of responsibility with them but they do let their hair down and often!

Saturn is in the 9th house in Scorpio for me. I read somewhere that Saturn in Scorpio gives us a strong desire nature and rather than Saturn dampening Scorpio's nature rather this placement gives Saturn desire and Martian energies. Control over emotions, desire and lust though it doesn't get rid of these feelings, I feel it gives me better judgment over these feelings and to act accordingly at the time. My 9th is ruled by Libra so this helps too.
In fact it's probably lucky I DO have Saturn in the 9th in Scorpio as I also have Mars and Pluto in Scorpio too (more destructive, intense and passionate in this sign!) so I would hate to think what I'd be like without Saturn here keeping an eye on things XP

IP: Logged

katatonic
Knowflake

Posts: 1448
From:
Registered: Apr 2009

posted August 29, 2009 02:06 AM     Click Here to See the Profile for katatonic     Edit/Delete Message
cheshire, linda was not the only astrologer to point out that ESPECIALLY cappy women seem to get younger after 40..the further past 40 the more vibrantly beautiful they become.

i think it is a hard sign to major in when you're young. because the young tend to kick up their heels and cappy is left in the dust wondering who is going to help clean the house!

i have saturn in the 7th and i agree with DTM, i wouldn't trade it...and i have yet to meet that "older" man! i have been prone to younger ones most of my adult life!

IP: Logged

vertiver
Knowflake

Posts: 327
From: Formerly Missneptune
Registered: May 2009

posted August 29, 2009 02:34 AM     Click Here to See the Profile for vertiver     Edit/Delete Message
I recently have also been revisiting the significance of good old saturn as well. Like Chesire Kat, I have Saturn located in my first house and retrograde in Sagittarius, not only is it retrograde, but its conjunct Sag. RX Uranus.

My Venus is in Gemini, so Saturn and Uranus are both opposite my Venus. Which is similar to having Saturn in the 7th more or less. I've read so many interpretations for Venus in the 7th and I have Libra MC, so social things for the most part go smoothly.

I still haven't really been in a long term relationship, well I suppose I just started one, but its been stable for the most part, because this other person was born 3 weeks exactly after me, so his Stationary Sag. Saturn opposes my Venus, and his Saturn is contacting my Venus, so Saturn - Venus contacts are beneficial.

I've heard that Venus-Saturn make a great team of reaping external rewards, such as money!

IP: Logged

GeminiFront
Knowflake

Posts: 14
From:
Registered: Jun 2009

posted August 29, 2009 03:10 PM     Click Here to See the Profile for GeminiFront     Edit/Delete Message
Every sign and planet has its good and not so good qualities. When Saturn works, it works wonderfully. When it's not on best behavior, I royally hate it. The challenge is to achieve the right balance.

I'm Saturn square Sun. I'm the most responsible person I know in my circle of family and friends. It helps me achieve all my life so far: top of the class throughout my school career, got into good companies, make good money. People can depend on me. Saturn keeps me from going astray. On the other hand, I could be too cautious, reserved, slow on making decisions and miss out on greater opportunities. The challenge for me all my life is to put Saturn at the right balance. I learn this lesson by looking at my dad. He's Capricorn moon. Responsible but also emotionally cold and analysis paralysis. He rare shows any kinds of loving feelings towards me or anyone for that matter, and this is not good for me and my mom who both have Cancer moon. He analyzes everything and does nothing because he fears more of what could go wrong than what could be achieved. Seriously, my mom is the bread provider in the family. My ex is Capricorn 7th house. She's paralyzed when it comes to relationships. So afraid of making a wrong decision and never tried at all. She focuses on making money, on friends and doesn't invest in relationship because "what if it doesn't work out I would lose a lot." It became self-fulfilling prophecy.

Anyways, I guess I rant... Learn to balance the good and the bad of Saturn!

IP: Logged

popcorn
Knowflake

Posts: 147
From:
Registered: Aug 2009

posted August 29, 2009 03:47 PM     Click Here to See the Profile for popcorn     Edit/Delete Message
I hate my feelings sometimes. My saturn square my moon;nessus conj. I dont cry but im feel depressed and struggle with my feelings. I will always develop something. My feeling show the way.

I was poor ones a time but now im rich. I have saturn trine venus,nod,mars

IP: Logged

Deliverance
Knowflake

Posts: 81
From: The real world
Registered: Apr 2009

posted August 29, 2009 09:05 PM     Click Here to See the Profile for Deliverance     Edit/Delete Message
I'm a Capricorn & have Saturn opposite Venus,(im quite fond of this aspect),square Jupiter & Uranus. I would gladly dissect my Jupiter for an extra dose Saturn. I look forward to Saturn & Pluto transits since they give me focus, clarity and a sense of realism. a very sobering time. When transiting Saturn opposed Mercury, I shut my self off from people and was fully dedicated to the work at hand, it was a time when I achieved a lot in a relatively short space of time.

Transiting Saturn opposite Venus was when I pruned my friendships, no arguments or bad feelings, just ceased communication. The relationships were no-longer productive for myself of the aforementioned friends. Saturn Conjunct Jupiter was a time when I knuckled down with University work & realised that it wasn't a big party. Also changed my diet which resulted in weight loss.
Jupiter & Neptune transits are overrated, not to keen on Venus either. The worst transit I've experienced was Neptune over Venus.

IP: Logged

bopbop
Knowflake

Posts: 211
From: USA
Registered: Jun 2009

posted August 29, 2009 09:47 PM     Click Here to See the Profile for bopbop     Edit/Delete Message
I don't think any transit is overrated/underrated. If you have 10th house/Capricorn emphasis then there is more affinity with Saturn, I would expect. Although Saturn in transit and Saturn in natal aspect can point to very different expressions of the energy.

IP: Logged

enchantress299
Knowflake

Posts: 50
From:
Registered: May 2009

posted August 30, 2009 08:20 PM     Click Here to See the Profile for enchantress299     Edit/Delete Message
I'm in agreement about Saturn being overrated as THE WORST PLANET EVER OMG! Uranus and Pluto usually do some pretty good damage too.

I kid, I kid... However, I actually really like the positive aspects of Saturn. Did you know, Saturn has been transiting my 10th house for the last couple of years, and when it first went in, it SUCKED. I couldn't find a job for 8 months, and even then it was only because I buckled down and took something I was way overqualified for. However, being fresh out of college, I actually learned a lot from that job, and I ended up with another job within 3 months. This one I didn't really enjoy, and I was also overqualified for, but I've taken what experience I can from it and applied it.

NOW, Saturn is on it's way out of my 10th house (though it'll still be a little while before it gets there), and I've gotten several job offers within three weeks. One is a potential promotion. One is FINALLY a job that I'm actually qualified for and want to do (though they don't get the grant for it until January, so I won't start it until then), and another has always been a hobby of mine and it's something I've always enjoyed, but will be on the side. I just have to take the opportunity and go over there and sell myself and my abilities.

So, as you see, though all of my effort and discipline, I'm FINALLY getting what I deserve. This is exactly what Saturn does for us. It makes victory so much sweeter when you've worked hard for something and you finally achieve it. You actually APPRECIATE it because you put so much effort into it. Everyone these days wants instant gratification- The "I should get something just because I'm ME" way of thinking. Life doesn't work that way, and unfortunately, when something comes to you with little or no effort, you don't appreciate it and all you want is MORE, which you then also don't appreciate.

I can say, as one of those people who is single and has lots of problems with relationships, it's crappy what Saturn can do, but you know what? Once I find the right person to have a positive relationship with (one that will be BUILT instead of instantaneous) I know that I will appreciate and value it so much more because I did the work to actually DESERVE a great relationship.

That's my take on the positive side of Saturn. It's not usually a cakewalk, but if you can use the Saturn transits or natal tendencies correctly then you can come out a stronger person.

IP: Logged

All times are Eastern Standard Time

next newest topic | next oldest topic

Administrative Options: Close Topic | Archive/Move | Delete Topic
Post New Topic  Post A Reply
Hop to:

Contact Us | Linda-Goodman.com

Copyright © 2008

Powered by Infopop www.infopop.com © 2000
Ultimate Bulletin Board 5.46a