Author
|
Topic: Paper im writing for school!
|
VirgoRising Knowflake Posts: 37 From: Usa Registered: Jan 2010
|
posted February 22, 2010 10:11 AM
Hey guys, i need your help!! For my psychology class i must come up with my own psychological theory about anything i want. I must write a two page paper about it. And i was thinking about "The psychological impact of astrology on the human psyche." But i just don't know where to start!! lol I know that Carl Jung has done much with astrology and psychology.. by casting charts for his patients only to find that the charts described the patients to a T. Since then, people have looked down on Jung, dismissing his research in Astrology. I somehow want to make this theory come alive again. Not just in my paper, but after i get my degree as well. So i am asking if anyone has any ideas, or references.. or any advice at all on this matter! Thanks so much.IP: Logged |
Taurean_Scorpion Knowflake Posts: 123 From: Santa Monica, CA Registered: Apr 2009
|
posted February 22, 2010 11:29 AM
I had one psych professor who told me there was research done on astrology charts where people were given charts that were not their own, and they believed that chart represented them when it wasn't theirs. So be careful. The psychological impact astrology has on the human psyche is being more aware of yourself. Exposing yourself to the knowledge of your subconscious and/or collective unconscious. I don't think astrology has a direct impact on the human psyche, so to speak...not sure how to explain that better. Good luck though!IP: Logged |
raspberri Knowflake Posts: 549 From: venus Registered: Jan 2010
|
posted February 22, 2010 12:09 PM
"The psychological impact of astrology on the human psyche." Do it on that; your teacher will be impressed.
Do you know alot about astrology tho? IP: Logged |
leapinglemur14 Knowflake Posts: 438 From: Registered: Apr 2009
|
posted February 22, 2010 01:21 PM
.IP: Logged |
Aya_and_baby Knowflake Posts: 340 From: Space (and sometimes Antwerp) Registered: Apr 2009
|
posted February 22, 2010 01:58 PM
I might be nitpicking here, but when I see "the psychological impact of Astrology on the human psyche", I think more of the eternal discussion about self-fulfilling prophecies, Barnum-effects and the likes, even though I think you meant the effect that your natal chart has on your psyche. No?Especially since you mention Carl Jung, and his studies were more about the validity of Astrology from a psychological point of view rather than the effect of Astrological "predictions" on our behaviour and minds. If you're more interested in discussing whether or not Astrology has some sort of influence - or rather, the position of celestial bodies in an Astrological nature, to be precise - on us, you could do a bit about Jung's theory on Archetypes. That fits very well with the study of Astrology The ironic thing is that I don't exactly believe in his archetypes, but I do believe in Astrology. Jesus, it does show that I have a Virgo MC (and mercury conjunct rising) sometimes, doesn't it? "To be precise", "nitpicky", ... ------------------ Official Conor's Feeding Machine! IP: Logged |
VirgoRising Knowflake Posts: 37 From: Usa Registered: Jan 2010
|
posted February 22, 2010 10:46 PM
TaureanScorpion you pose a very feasible argument. Thanks so much for you warning, I really think that because of that i might just rebuke the idea all together. And that would be my Virgo perfectionism.Aya and baby, thank youuu. I totally agree with you there, i tend to forget how closed minded the world of science can be. I could write my paper on Jung's theory on Archetypes, but the problem is i have to come up with my OWN theory. If you guys have any other ideas or feedback, id appreciate it. Thanks so much. IP: Logged |
Nine Knowflake Posts: 507 From: The Cusp of Love Registered: May 2009
|
posted February 22, 2010 11:08 PM
Simple. You could write a paper on why astrology works. Or the lure of astrology. What drew you in, and what has been consistently true.Men are from Mars, Women from Venus even when both are the same gender...offer an astrological interpretation on what the attracting element between romantic couples is. Or, the moon's position (sign) at birth and it's effect on sharing a living space with other people. Perhaps you can draw psychological parallels. IP: Logged |
raspberri Knowflake Posts: 549 From: venus Registered: Jan 2010
|
posted February 23, 2010 12:08 AM
^^^^That would be fascinating for your classmates! If you had to give a presentation that is... IP: Logged |
lotion Knowflake Posts: 111 From: Registered: Jun 2009
|
posted February 23, 2010 03:50 AM
hmm... what kind of research have you done so far? whatever paper it is, to come up with your own theory requires you to really delve into it both in depth and breadth. But because of the length of the paper (2, you said) I am assuming it is very difficult to construct and come up with a completely NEW THEORY THAT IS YOUR OWN. Do you mean just applying an existing psychological theory to a worldly phenomenon? My advice is to scale down and look at the mundane things of everyday life. "The psychological impact of astrology on the human psyche." is way too broad for a 2-pager. The words "psychological impact", "astrology", and "human psyche" all require volumes and volumes just to define! lol maybe with tangible, definable, and concrete things you can actually observe. home decor... maybe look at celebrity homes and make some kind of link to their sun signs and how general spatial design of a space affects people and their psychological state. maybe you can zoom in and observe one planet. maybe the moon and its links to the mother figure and how the influence of the mother affects emotional development of the child. relating to the whole archetype thing, maybe you can look at consumer psychology and the many layers of symbols and archetypes embedded in advertising and marketing today. (semiotics - Roland Barthes) for example, how gender is portrayed in advertising. women: venus/moon- perfect figures, make up, all about attractiveness, and men: mars- rugged, manly, fear of domestication... many car commercials appeals to speed, freedom etc etc.. so yeah... start SMALL and you can expand and develop your theory around it good luck! sounds exciting
IP: Logged |
Diablo Knowflake Posts: 433 From: Melbourne, Australia Registered: May 2009
|
posted February 23, 2010 05:06 AM
I study psych, have been for 7yrs..I reckon you could write your essay on "Astrology and the phenomenon of self-fulfilling prophecy" or look at the stats that support planetary placements and personality aspects. It all depends which way your argument is leaning and if your gonna be supporting what is considered a psuedo-science by the scientific academic community then you gotta have some good evidence to back you up lol. Unfortunately empirical science hasn't been able to prove astrology works 100% through research so it'll never gain the credit it commands. IP: Logged |
Aya_and_baby Knowflake Posts: 340 From: Space (and sometimes Antwerp) Registered: Apr 2009
|
posted February 23, 2010 06:39 AM
To be honest, I have heard about that study where people were given astrological readings that weren't of their own charts and I don't dispute the results.However, I do dispute the concusion that therefore Astrology must be false. I think the reason for the results have more to do with how someone wants to be vs. how they really are. Who's going to argue when you say they're honest, intelligent, kind, etc... Right? Maybe you could do your paper on that: make-belief vs. actuality in the human behaviour and how that undermines the accuracy of Astrology. Just throwing something out there ------------------ Official Conor's Feeding Machine! IP: Logged |
Ami Ann Knowflake Posts: 1628 From: US Registered: Dec 2009
|
posted February 23, 2010 06:46 AM
editIP: Logged |
mermaid26 Knowflake Posts: 446 From: just visiting you know Registered: Jun 2009
|
posted February 23, 2010 11:52 AM
How about medical astrology as an approach to total healing of mind, body, spirit. Wisdom of the ancients meet modern... The outer planets in the cross generation conjunctions of Pluto, Neptune, & Uranus should be making some quantum leaps forward in healing by this grand design. Just a thought from a Virgo rising.IP: Logged |