posted September 01, 2010 07:07 PM            

And there are plenty of people that share his beliefs without having Mercury in Pisces.

The most ridiculous arguments I've ever had were with people with Mercury in Aquarius (like myself).

posted September 01, 2010 07:24 PM            

She has Mercury in Pisces square Neptune.

She doesn't strike me as being like the guy that you told about.

She's a lightworker into Doreen Virtue stuff,angels,and spirit.

I have a friend who is born the day after her, and she's into spiritual things too.

Raymond

------------------
No..I am not a Virgo.

posted September 01, 2010 07:25 PM            

He meant it has been PROVEN that God does not exist! I replied by saying "who proved this because he sure and the hell isn't famous for it!"

I'm just saying I have noticed Mercury in Pisces don't have legitimate arguments although they think they do.

posted September 01, 2010 07:50 PM            

:edit: ^ I should add that - strangely - this includes the opinions/"conclusions" I argue for.. and even the ones I seem passionate about.
For instance, I am doing my PhD now and writing on three separate papers - I have to take a stance and build an argument to support that stance in each of these papers. I always do *this* - but it is almost like an "act", because I am never convinced.
Basically I can never *convince* myself.
People don't catch on though. Most people would think I do have these opinions :edit:

Pisces Merc here.

quote:

---

Mercury in Pisces don't have legitimate arguments although they think they do.

---

Well here you only posted the conclusion of his argument - not how he reached this conclusion, so I can't comment on the legitimacy of his argument.
But in any case, his "conclusion" - seems like a strange thing to assert, mainly since a very large percentage of the world's population has spiritual beliefs (in the western world these beliefs are often mono-theistic). This kind of comment - "it has been proven God does not exist" - is sure to arouse argument in any social circle..

I'm curious about the rest of his chart and the aspects he has to Mercury.

Is it possible at all that he was saying it to stir and get reactions out of people?

I find Pisces Mercury to be changeable. You could find him arguing the opposite - a week later.. and saying that we have good reasons to believe there is indeed a God.
I've noticed this going back and forth - sometimes.

posted September 01, 2010 08:01 PM            

I dont know what his planets are doing exactly, but we do have very strong relationship synastry from what I remember. My ASC is Opposite his Sun, My Mars on his Venus, My ASC on his SN...

posted September 02, 2010 03:10 AM            

For instance - if this guy was a scientist or studying something science-related and he wanted to have credibility in the social-circles he hangs around - and to be perceived a certain way - he may lie about his actual beliefs.

Things aren't always as they seem with any Pisces placement.
Sometimes the 'lying' is manipulative.. so he might pretend to be a hardcore scientist to gain their trust and then do a 180 - thus getting his "peers" to open up to more spiritual concepts.

rasberri - You have Pisces Mars if I remember correctly - Would you say people get the full picture when it comes to your actions, your motivations, your sexuality - and all things Mars related?

posted September 03, 2010 04:22 AM            

People don't believe in a Religion because it can be proven.

They do because they feel a need for that. A lot of humans need this but it's not really a scientific proof.

Religion does not need science to suggest the universe was created by God. People are still free to believe that no matter how the universe was created, and even if there was nothing before that, it was God that arranged this to happen..

So science can't prove whether or not there is a God. Or there is a reason we exist.

posted September 03, 2010 04:48 AM            

quote:

---

People are free to believe what they want. As long as they don't harm anyone..

---

SwirlKit - I agree to that ^

But the thread was about him asserting something which we can basically *know* to be incorrect.
I haven't seen anything on international news in the past week or so about conclusive scientific proof that there exists no God.
Maybe I missed it.

Clearly, his statement: "It has been scientifically proven that God does not exist."

- is incorrect.

posted September 03, 2010 05:12 PM            

quote:

---

I'm the opposite in the sense that I always say "nothing is certain" lol - ad nauseum.
Even opinion I have - I find "uncertain" ultimately - because I simply don't know. I'm only a little piece of a very large puzzle which I'm not privy to.

---

posted November 30, 2010 04:50 AM            

quote:

---

Mercury in Pisces + Leo Moon, now that's a motherf***er who thinks he knows everything (no offense to other people with this combo, ,I'd like to think I met the worst example)...
He was dating my friend, soooooo annoying, he wouldn't shut up either, he would just go on and on "explaining" to everybody how everything works...and he thought everyone was delighted to listen to him...plus, arrogance and "I am better than anybody" attitude wasn't helping either....
I am not the type of person to have strong repulsion towards many people (or almost any people, I either find them cool or I don't even notice them), but boy, did that a**hole get on my nerves constantly...
Luckily, my friend isn't with him anymore, she came to her senses.

---

I have a Aquarius ex who sooooo many people feel the same way about (ie they DO NOT like him and think he’s a know it all). In fact he’s in a situation right now all his friends from undergrad have stopped talking to him (he graduated in May). They were just dealing with him until he moved. Now he has tried to visit and stay the weekend in our Universities City and no one wants him to stay with them as they say he is a jerk. Keep in mind these are friends he has had for 5 years! And you know how Aqua’s are about their friends. He thinks he knows everything, pouts when people don't listen and criticizes EVERYTHING (a la his Virgo Moon). In fact we have had conversations on why he was wrong because he couldn't explain why something was the way it was...it just was lol. Or I’d offer an opinion and he’d immediately think we are arguing. Plus he was VAGUE as hell. I'd ask him if he wanted to be friends...he'd say yes. Then he wouldn't try and when I would question him he’d say it was awkward and then says we are incompatible as friends. But then say later I'm amazing.