Author
|
Topic: Silent treatment
|
I'm so cappy Knowflake Posts: 3966 From: Saturn (summer house on Chiron) Registered: Nov 2012
|
posted December 20, 2013 03:37 PM
What in a natal chart indicates the tendency to give silent treatments?------------------ I'm sooo happy! I mean, cappy. IP: Logged |
Ellynlvx Knowflake Posts: 2652 From: Mountain Gate Registered: Aug 2013
|
posted December 20, 2013 03:40 PM
Stationary Saturn Opposite Mercury in Cancer?Maybe something Stubborn and Taurean? IP: Logged |
Rosalind Knowflake Posts: 2635 From: Registered: Mar 2011
|
posted December 20, 2013 03:46 PM
I don't give silent treatments. When I'm done with someone... I'm DONE. Scorpio Rising conjunct Pluto.IP: Logged |
Newrise Knowflake Posts: 406 From: Los angeles Registered: Jul 2013
|
posted December 20, 2013 03:49 PM
I am actually bad at giving silent treatments. And yes when I am done, I am also done.But if I wanted to give a silent treatment out of an ulterior motive, I couldn't. It feels horrible to me. As far as mars goes, I have mars trine moon so that seems appropriate. IP: Logged |
olgatheo Knowflake Posts: 210 From: Pluto Registered: Nov 2012
|
posted December 20, 2013 03:52 PM
Pluto aspects esp. to Mercury or ASC! Speaking from personal exp. IP: Logged |
I'm so cappy Knowflake Posts: 3966 From: Saturn (summer house on Chiron) Registered: Nov 2012
|
posted December 20, 2013 03:56 PM
^Thanks! Especially for staying on topic ------------------ I'm sooo happy! I mean, cappy. IP: Logged |
Kerosene Knowflake Posts: 7703 From: Mercury Registered: Dec 2012
|
posted December 20, 2013 03:57 PM
It's a passive agressive way to display frustration with someone. so afflicted mars?IP: Logged |
PixieJane Moderator Posts: 3439 From: CA Registered: Oct 2010
|
posted December 20, 2013 07:00 PM
I'm also one of those people who doesn't give the silent treatment (I expect my Libra and Sag stellium see no point to it). Yet when I'm done with someone I am all the way done which may be that my sun, merc, and pluto are on the Scorpio ascendant (and Jupiter all the way in Scorpio). IP: Logged |
tgem Knowflake Posts: 596 From: Registered: Jan 2013
|
posted December 20, 2013 07:05 PM
I'm pretty good at this ( and no, I'm not boasting). It's one of my weaker aspects: Taurus sun, Aries mercury opposite Pluto.IP: Logged |
Faith Moderator Posts: 6322 From: Registered: Jul 2011
|
posted December 20, 2013 07:24 PM
I just shut down emotionally whenever something bothers me beyond a certain point, and can't talk because I don't trust what I'll say. Could be my Pisces moon (overly sensitive) square Gemini Mars (verbally aggressive). The moon gets hurt and Mars immediately wants to jump in and "defend" the moon...ugh, I've learned the hard way that this is a recipe for disaster. So I just have to chill out, think about everything, and then respond. In the meanwhile, that person won't hear from me. I also have 3H Pluto trine Mercury and Mars, sextile ASC. Since these planets are in air signs, however, I think they are what pull me OUT of a funk. Especially the Aquarius Mercury...it can't handle melodrama for too long. IP: Logged |
Ellynlvx Knowflake Posts: 2652 From: Mountain Gate Registered: Aug 2013
|
posted December 20, 2013 07:27 PM
Faith, are you and that friend still off again?IP: Logged |
Odette Knowflake Posts: 3083 From: Registered: May 2012
|
posted December 20, 2013 07:30 PM
I do this *hides* Everyone hates me for doing this. Pisces Mercury. IP: Logged |
Odette Knowflake Posts: 3083 From: Registered: May 2012
|
posted December 20, 2013 07:31 PM
quote: I just shut down emotionally whenever something bothers me beyond a certain point, and can't talk because I don't trust what I'll say.
This is exactly how I feel. IP: Logged |
tgem Knowflake Posts: 596 From: Registered: Jan 2013
|
posted December 20, 2013 07:37 PM
quote: Originally posted by Odette: This is exactly how I feel.
Same here.... IP: Logged |
LionFish Knowflake Posts: 1002 From: Registered: Aug 2012
|
posted December 20, 2013 08:24 PM
quote: Originally posted by Faith: I just shut down emotionally whenever something bothers me beyond a certain point, and can't talk because I don't trust what I'll say. Could be my Pisces moon (overly sensitive) square Gemini Mars (verbally aggressive). The moon gets hurt and Mars immediately wants to jump in and "defend" the moon...ugh, I've learned the hard way that this is a recipe for disaster. So I just have to chill out, think about everything, and then respond. In the meanwhile, that person won't hear from me.
I have some kind of weird formation with my Sun/Merc, Moon and Mars/Uranus. A sextile (Moon to Sun/Merc) Mars/Urans square Sun/Merc, and Mars/Uranus inconjunct Moon. I feel the same as Faith. I don't consider it a "silent treatment," but for the benefit of the relationship between myself and the other person. Because if I'm truly hurt (Moon) my Mars/Uranus square Mercury comes out and I can say some pretty horrible, hurtful things. So instead I too, shutdown and choose not to speak if I'm really upset. It's VERY hard for me to do, but people know when I'm not speaking to them, they messed up big time. I don't like saying things I don't mean, so I've learned to just keep my mouth shut until I calm down. That doesn't always work though, sometimes just talking (Merc) brings up my emotions (Moon) full force (Mars) again. I can be a bit volatile if I don't stfu :/ IP: Logged |
I'm so cappy Knowflake Posts: 3966 From: Saturn (summer house on Chiron) Registered: Nov 2012
|
posted December 20, 2013 08:37 PM
Thanks for sharing.------------------ I'm sooo happy! I mean, cappy. IP: Logged |
PixieJane Moderator Posts: 3439 From: CA Registered: Oct 2010
|
posted December 20, 2013 08:44 PM
quote: Originally posted by Faith: I just shut down emotionally whenever something bothers me beyond a certain point, and can't talk because I don't trust what I'll say. Could be my Pisces moon (overly sensitive) square Gemini Mars (verbally aggressive). The moon gets hurt and Mars immediately wants to jump in and "defend" the moon...ugh, I've learned the hard way that this is a recipe for disaster. So I just have to chill out, think about everything, and then respond. In the meanwhile, that person won't hear from me
I find this admirable. And I also don't consider this the silent treatment. To me the silent treatment is intended to punish and make a person stew and/or a barb of "you don't really matter" (as opposed to being done which means "we're both better off apart") but what you're doing is the opposite of that. It's self-control. I've done this at times myself when I recognized I was really angry in time to catch myself and go to cool off or otherwise work it out, but that's not to punish or belittle, that's to keep from punishing & belittling. When someone tells me they need a little time to cool off I back off for them as well. I don't hold how people feel (or their immediate impulses) against them as feelings aren't always rational or something we can control and they tend to change like the weather anyway. It's how they act on it that counts. Likewise, I'm glad you can recognize that because something comes off a certain way doesn't mean that was how it's intended. One of the most tiresome things I find on the net is how it seems the majority of people automatically assume the worst possible "tone of voice" to a post and then immediately react to their own paranoid imagination rather than what was actually said or implied. (OTOH, it's interesting to this heavy Libra/Sag with Scorpio influences as it's making me reassess my belief that teens are more prone to care about peer pressure due to evolutionary factors when instead it could be that as they get older they're better able to pick up on social cues better which can't be done on the net so on the net "revert back to hypersensitive teens" believing the entire world is judging them harshly when it's not reverting but rather the default settings of the typical human brain and the "tribal circuits" that subconsciously fear shunning/exile as death and thus evoking anger as a response which then make flame wars on the net inevitable. I was more hypersensitive as a teen but there could be other factors than I suppose that made me less so as I got older.) IP: Logged |
summerlite Knowflake Posts: 327 From: Registered: Nov 2013
|
posted December 20, 2013 09:13 PM
Moon sq Mercury?IP: Logged |
Kerosene Knowflake Posts: 7703 From: Mercury Registered: Dec 2012
|
posted December 20, 2013 10:41 PM
It's also quite easy to avoid paranoid response if one can construct a post without it sounding completely condescending.IP: Logged |
PixieJane Moderator Posts: 3439 From: CA Registered: Oct 2010
|
posted December 21, 2013 12:29 AM
quote: Originally posted by Kerosene: It's also quite easy to avoid paranoid response if one can construct a post without it sounding completely condescending.
Sounding that way to you. I bet I wouldn't find many of the posts you consider condescending that way because I'd imagine a "different tone of voice" for it (more casual than condescending) as I read it. More than once I've asked for clarification of what someone meant when I wasn't sure about what they meant and/or how they meant it (and some people even complain of me doing that as if I was interrogating them rather than trying to better understand them), and for some reason I usually don't get paranoid. In contrast others will be paranoid no matter how much you try to avoid giving offense, no matter how much you explain your motives they will still assume the worst. Sometimes even sugar coating something can come off as condescending to those prone to see attack where there isn't one. And of course it's not just me that the worst is assumed over. People tend to assume the worst tone of about everyone (at least outside their clique) and thus the many flame wars (especially when it's mutual paranoia/hypersensitivity), including on LL.
IP: Logged |
DeepFreeze Knowflake Posts: 560 From: Pluto Registered: Nov 2013
|
posted December 21, 2013 12:52 AM
Yes, I do. Very often I will simply just be done with them - completely. If I do silent treatment, it's not a punishment, it's a warning. It's much much less likely with a significant other. Pluto conjunct Asc Moon square Mars Moon sqaure Mercury Possibly other relevant stuff relating to Mars/Mercury IP: Logged |
DialecticLady Knowflake Posts: 368 From: Registered: Sep 2013
|
posted December 21, 2013 02:46 PM
quote: Originally posted by DeepFreeze: Yes, I do. Very often I will simply just be done with them - completely. If I do silent treatment, it's not a punishment, it's a warning. It's much much less likely with a significant other. Pluto conjunct Asc Moon square Mars Moon sqaure Mercury Possibly other relevant stuff relating to Mars/Mercury
This ^^. I think this could be for different reasons. I've seen people doing this as punishment, to cool down and don't say wrong words while one is hurt and as a warnig too. I can do all this But it's because I hate to argue and fight and feel ashamed if I lose control like this, so I prefer give the silent treatment. I guess the aspects could be: -many aqua/11th house/strong uranus: don't know how to handle emotional things and shut down. -proeminent scorpio/pluto placements: use silent treatment as way of control. -strong capricorn/saturn aspects:they get cold if you hurt them and use it like punishment because they never will say you affected them in this way (don't like to show vulnerability). -strong cancer/pisces/moon/neptune/12h house/4th house: passive agressive people, they often don't say what upset them, you must guess lol. Just my experience! IP: Logged |
DeepFreeze Knowflake Posts: 560 From: Pluto Registered: Nov 2013
|
posted December 21, 2013 03:00 PM
^ I have all of those except Saturn! HahahaIP: Logged |