posted September 20, 2016 05:07 AM            

quote:

---

Originally posted by lisalisa:
So I follow Kelley Rosano's Forecasts on Youtube and she was talking about she's moving— then she stated out something which I do not understand but I hope one of you will (?) she said she had a different rising sign where she lived and now she'smoving she'll have her own rising sign back.. What does she mean ?

---

maybe if you choose her city as the one she's moving to now, with the same date and time of birth, if would give a different rising sign?

for instance a person born on may 10th 1991 at 11:24 AM in Russia, will have a different rising sign than one in the U.S

the difference in Ac will only happen when moving to another place with a very different longitude/latitude though

also, in calculating the solar arc, different places a person celebrates their birthday in a year, gives different ACs

posted September 23, 2016 02:13 PM            

Why don't you ask her?

Many astrologers subscribe to the notion that they need to relocate their birth chart to any place they move to. I do not.

The birth chart is imprinted upon you permanently no matter where you move or go. It is a matter of choice mediated through a very space-time specific inter-dimensional doorway saturated in complex relational/karmic matters, not mere geographic happenstance. Otherwise we'd all be changing our rising sign every day we travel and wake up in a place other than the location where we were born. I think anyone can see how silly that is.

I was born in Austin, TX, a 17° Virgo riser. I moved 7 years ago to Portland, OR and I am still a 17° Virgo riser -- not a 22° Virgo riser as the changed location would suggest.

These notions come from theoretical astrologers who seem to over-think things and have trouble observing their own charts accurately. Unfortunately this one has been promoted by astrologers as hefty as Robert Hand, who I respect tremendously for his monumental works like Planets in Transit. But natal chart relocation is just skewed astrology. It is natal for a reason.

Nativity: process or circumstances of being born. Moving later does not change those circumstances.