Author
|
Topic: Conservative/Liberal natal chart
|
FatedCinderella Knowflake Posts: 462 From: Registered: Mar 2016
|
posted September 12, 2017 09:39 PM
What do you think about it?I have a strong cardinal energy on my chart and I'm probably 80% conservative,a little more or less I don't know (I'm not really into labels) but lets say I give a lot of value to family and morals and some expressions of ART ain't ART for me...more like an insult/apology etc What about you?How is your chart?
IP: Logged |
Ami Anne Moderator Posts: 72053 From: Pluto/house next to NickiG Registered: Sep 2010
|
posted September 12, 2017 10:25 PM
Conservative----Cardinal ASC and Moon.GREAT Thread!------------------ Want to Read Simple, Fun,Sexy Articles on Astrology? Check Me Out, DUDE. http://www.mychristianpsychic.com/
IP: Logged |
SimplyLuna Newflake Posts: 18 From: California Registered: Jul 2017
|
posted September 12, 2017 10:40 PM
This is an interesting topic. I once grew up very conservative and lived under a strict, traditional and religious household. I never questioned about it until I moved out for college.I am mainly mutable dominate even though my Asc, Sun and Moon are cardinal signs. My mindset changed a lot. Where does your planets all fall into? IP: Logged |
PixieJane Moderator Posts: 9098 From: CA Registered: Oct 2010
|
posted September 12, 2017 10:49 PM
I have strong cardinal energy (and also a powerful Saturn in Libra stellium with sun which should give me conservative traits) and don't see myself as particularly conservative, and I'll exceed many who identify as liberals for social liberalism. I'm into morals, but more from an ethical perspective, while it sounds to me like you mean morals in terms of sexual behavior (which is only incidental to ethics for me). And if by "family" you mean as a code phrase for "heterosexual only" then that's another way we strongly differ (though otherwise it's important to me as well). I can be cynical to the art world and do think some artists just don't give a crap, but I don't see it as the government's place to decide what is art and what isn't...OTOH, I'm not particularly passionate about funding the arts in the first place, though I'm not particularly opposed to it. (And there was one art piece that I thought was just cheap porn trying to be edgy by incorporating some religious stuff and calling it art, but after I read the explanation I could see the point of it, the symbolic expression of the human condition and society. Though as that was funded by private grants rather than government, it's not an issue here, unless you think the government should be BANNING art, in which case I'm strongly opposed to that.) Generally speaking I can be described as a fiscal conservative, though out of step with most others who call themselves fiscal conservatives as I'm not "just fund the police and military and use social darwinism on everyone else." And I'm more about getting rid of welfare for the rich (from corporate bailouts to buying new homes for the wealthy who keep building their homes where hurricanes keep wiping them out at taxpayer expense while most everyone else who loses a home in a safer place are SOL) than from those benefiting from the safety net, and that's another major difference between me and most who call themselves social conservatives who have the baffling tendency to not care anywhere as much about the rich getting welfare than say someone stuck in a wheelchair unable to support himself (and tend to suspect cynical reasons on why this is so). Though it's not so simple as "cut this, fund that." A lot of things could be done besides that, but it won't be, because a corrupt system serves those in charge. As a US citizen, I'm for "shall issue" gun carrying permits (with no trickery like "must pay with Master Card" in an an attempt to keep the permits in the hands of certain people, which Texas does the last time I checked), but also with genuine background checks which can deny permits or even ownership to people based on objective reasons which can be challenged in court (waiting periods also don't bother me, though I can see how that could be bad for certain people in extraordinary circumstances), and I think the NRA is a fear mongering embarrassment to the 90%+ gun owners (such as myself) who are not a member. I could go on, but I think I contrasted you enough despite my cardinal and Saturnian placements, and that I don't fit neatly into any label. I think my Saturnian placement does want a certain decorum in politics, which has been sadly missing for a long time, and gets worse (more Jerry Springer) every election cycle. It's difficult to explain because too many people only allow for 2 categories (some will expand that to a 4 point axis), and the definitions and standards change with location and specific ideology/party. I've gotten where I don't even like using political terms because they're so compromised with double speak and loaded for or against that get the rank and file to see them very differently from everyone else, which makes it very difficult to communicate in a general sense...it's as frustrating to me as trying to communicate with people in a cult who have their own definitions for everything, and how they demonize those who don't share their peculiar definitions (only this would be like multiple cults, each with their own arbitrary definitions that they treat as official rather than made up to fit their ideology, and I know posting this is likely to trigger more than one such ideological cultist). This applies to about anyone who identifies too strongly with a specific party or movement, and not limited to the United States by any means.
I generally don't see astrology as doing much here directly. Of course if someone's chart promotes the defense of traditions raised with then that depends on the actual traditions, so if raised in a conservative family and area then that person will likely have conservative values, but different values in a different family and area. Complicating it further, many will change in life. I've actually run into more people who were conservative in their youth who became liberal, or even socialist (*a word I hate to use with US citizens as it has been far too warped by political propaganda with very few Americans actually knowing anything about it), than the other way around. Even Winston Churchill was a conservative in his youth who later became a liberal, despite the quote falsely attributed to him about liberals and conservatives (related to age). IP: Logged |
DannyCappy Knowflake Posts: 718 From: Registered: Jan 2016
|
posted September 12, 2017 10:50 PM
I think I'm half.One quick example. I have nothing agains't homossexuals.I'm religious but if is sin or not is not my problem, I have my own sins to take care.I don't care if they marry,kiss in public but I'm not into the idea of unisex bathrooms."If you feel like a woman you gonna use a women's bathroom kind of thing" I'm absolutely agains't it. Another point: I think society should help the ones who can't help themselves BUT that means extremelly poor people,I mean the ones who have absolutely no opportunity (Ps:not picking them based on their color).That is not equality to me! Plus giving them opportunity to grow.TEACHING THEM HOW TO FISH so to speak,so they can have a better life in the future. Most of my chart is cardinal too. Capricorn sun Aries moon Mars in cancer IP: Logged |
hypatia238 Moderator Posts: 7523 From: Mercury novile and parallel Pluto, Pluto septile Southnode Registered: Sep 2014
|
posted September 12, 2017 11:44 PM
I am libertarian, not republican or a liberal.. Jupiter conjunct uranus exact in the 1H.
IP: Logged |
XzaultaX Knowflake Posts: 217 From: Your mind Registered: Feb 2016
|
posted September 12, 2017 11:51 PM
I would say conservatives have Saturn in their charts, while liberals have Uranus.I would call myself more conservative. -7 of my planets are in fixed signs -Scorpio and 1st house stellium -Scorpio ASC and Sun, Taurus Moon IP: Logged |
StubbornVirgo Knowflake Posts: 2157 From: Welcome to Mercury Registered: Jul 2015
|
posted September 13, 2017 12:17 AM
Half and half. I see issues with both sides. Mostly I take issue with hypocrisy with any view point, which you can probably blame on my Pluto in 9th house.- Fixed ASC. - Strong cardinal energy (stellium in Capricorn, another stellium in 7th house, Moon in 4th house). - Mercury dominant, followed by Saturn dominant IP: Logged |
kewf1988 Knowflake Posts: 133 From: Registered: Dec 2015
|
posted September 13, 2017 12:31 AM
It's not that simple.Alan Lin's theory is the best at finding political ideology that I've seen so far. Astrology is way more complex than "feminine signs are conservative, masculine signs are liberal". For example, one of my neighbors has Sun, Mercury, and Venus in Capricorn, Mars in Pisces, and Moon in Taurus (likely a feminine ascendant as well as he's very quiet and has penetrating eyes like Scorpio rising. He also has Pluto in Virgo), yet is quite liberal. With Lin's theory, he has strong left wing indicators economically and socially. All the earth in his chart does make him extremely introverted and good with tools. Feminine signs have more conservative characters, but that's different than being politically conservative. IP: Logged |
hypatia238 Moderator Posts: 7523 From: Mercury novile and parallel Pluto, Pluto septile Southnode Registered: Sep 2014
|
posted September 13, 2017 12:35 AM
Nope uranus is rebellious and you find rebels on both side of the spectrum, uranus can be alt-left or alt-right...My partner is an anarcho capitalist so very conservative and he is a libra sun conjunct saturn with moon in cancer but he also has uranus conjunct mars right on his DC angle hence he is NOT a republican but an anarcho capitalist. IP: Logged |
Sulkyarcher Knowflake Posts: 1407 From: Registered: Dec 2013
|
posted September 13, 2017 12:35 AM
I have a lot of fire, but I also have a strong Saturn signature in my chart.So maybe the Saturn is what makes me lean towards conservatism a bit more. IP: Logged |
MoonMystic Knowflake Posts: 790 From: ♤ Ethereal Umbra ♤ Registered: Nov 2016
|
posted September 13, 2017 12:42 AM
Cardinal energies are: Mars, Chiron, Uranus, Mercury, MC. Then my Fixed energy is tied with 5, Mutable 4.IP: Logged |
teasel Knowflake Posts: 10775 From: Registered: Apr 2009
|
posted September 13, 2017 02:11 AM
There isn't an alt-left. the alt-right coined that term for themselves, and their men's rights activists (misogynists), and then there are the nazis. They're off in their own dark corner, trying to mainstream. I'm conservative in ways. I don't do drugs, or sleep around, for example. I barely drink alcohol. I'm strongly liberal politically. I think I'm slightly more mutable than anything, but I'm pretty balanced between the three. Uranus also aspects a lot of my chart. I was a Nader fan in the past, and a Bernie fan last year - but very happy to vote for Hillary. IP: Logged |
teasel Knowflake Posts: 10775 From: Registered: Apr 2009
|
posted September 13, 2017 02:19 AM
quote: Originally posted by StubbornVirgo: Half and half. I see issues with both sides. Mostly I take issue with hypocrisy with any view point, which you can probably blame on my Pluto in 9th house.- Fixed ASC. - Strong cardinal energy (stellium in Capricorn, another stellium in 7th house, Moon in 4th house). - Mercury dominant, followed by Saturn dominant
Saturn in the 9th house, and this is why I was a Nader fan in the past. Hypocrisy on both sides. His Uranus is on my Ceres/Chiron/Sun, and widely conjunct my Mercury. In the 6th house.
IP: Logged |
Gemini30 Knowflake Posts: 727 From: Los Angeles Registered: Sep 2014
|
posted September 13, 2017 03:29 AM
quote: Originally posted by teasel: There isn't an alt-left. the alt-right coined that term for themselves, and their men's rights activists (misogynists), and then there are the nazis. They're off in their own dark corner, trying to mainstream. I'm conservative in ways. I don't do drugs, or sleep around, for example. I barely drink alcohol. I'm strongly liberal politically. I think I'm slightly more mutable than anything, but I'm pretty balanced between the three. Uranus also aspects a lot of my chart. I was a Nader fan in the past, and a Bernie fan last year - but very happy to vote for Hillary.
MRA'S are not misogynists. They believe in equal rights. IP: Logged |
teasel Knowflake Posts: 10775 From: Registered: Apr 2009
|
posted September 13, 2017 04:06 AM
quote: Originally posted by Gemini30: MRA'S are not misogynists. They believe in equal rights.
Hardly. I've had plenty of talks with them over the last seven years at least. I know what they are. IP: Logged |
Kannon McAfee Moderator Posts: 2777 From: Portland, OR - USA Registered: Oct 2011
|
posted September 13, 2017 02:05 PM
I don't make any astrological correlations to how politically conservative or liberal someone's views are. There may be indicators of personal caution or more wide open self-expression, but those still do not correlate directly to personal politics.I'm a great example. I started out politically far right conservative because of my family upbringing and very narrow exposure to ideas. Now my political views fall in the bottom left corner of the political grid (as given at politicalcompass.org). The birth chart tendencies are a starting place. Family upbringing, social position, region, etc has more influence on your politics. The question is, are you open to growth by learning and listening to others who may be more informed than you? ------------------ The Declinations Guy > Expert birth chart rectification > Rising Sign Descriptions ♈ ♉ ♊ ♋ ♌ ♍ ♎ ♏ ♐ ♑ ♒ ♓ IP: Logged |
hypatia238 Moderator Posts: 7523 From: Mercury novile and parallel Pluto, Pluto septile Southnode Registered: Sep 2014
|
posted September 13, 2017 02:10 PM
quote: Originally posted by Kannon McAfee:
The question is, are you open to growth by learning and listening to others who may be more informed than you?
I am indeed that is how I ended up being a conservative. I use to be liberal because of the emotional appeal of it and republicans irritate to me in some ways so I was never swayed in that direction but the logical appeal of libertarians definitely got my attention and I was open minded enough to listen and hence went from liberal to libertarian. In this process many people tried to sway me to be republican and it was not going to happen but libertarianism truly is a great fit for me. I do want small government and more freedom, makes perfect sense given I have Jupiter conjunct Uranus exacty in the 1H (my strongest aspect). Uranus makes me question laws and the status quo.
IP: Logged |
Electro DGX Moderator Posts: 1938 From: Plutanus Registered: Jul 2015
|
posted September 13, 2017 02:37 PM
Prepare to hear ******** since people care more about their views than anything. You'll never get the truth when discussing politics. IP: Logged |
FatedCinderella Knowflake Posts: 462 From: Registered: Mar 2016
|
posted September 13, 2017 07:12 PM
Urg I had no acess to internet today. Thanks everyone! Pretty cool insights.IP: Logged |
Selenite Knowflake Posts: 1492 From: Lyra Registered: Aug 2013
|
posted September 13, 2017 08:03 PM
I don't really like labels either. Mostly because I don't think there is a perfect answer to the questions of our time, so i'm not 100% into the ideologies behind any labels. But I place little to no value on any specific moral system and am very into expression of art.. I strongly dislike fascist thinking in the simplest sense, 'everyone should __ , everyone must __ ' (be a certain way, strive for the same things, etc.). Mostly mutable energy and mostly fire. Mutable Sun and cardinal Moon. IP: Logged |
Sagical Knowflake Posts: 388 From: Glenbow, Canada Registered: Mar 2014
|
posted September 13, 2017 10:38 PM
Hmmmmmm.....it's a mystery really. I have two friends..... one born three days before me and another one born two days after me. They have conservative views.... and then there is me.... I thought I was liberal type but after Trudeau got in it seems like I am kw in the middle... maybe I might like some conservative ideals....i don't know.... maybe I'm right in the middle and wanting to be independent. I grew up in a strictly conservative ruled province for a few decades and I always found myself opposite to what that is.... and now since my party got in I'm really disliking it and want the conservatives back because of many things..... I have four cardinal planets in all elements, I have a lot of mutable planets and two fixed planets....I have a lot of earth placements in my chart planets and houses....
IP: Logged |
DualGemV2 Knowflake Posts: 374 From: Toronto, Ontario Registered: Aug 2016
|
posted September 13, 2017 11:39 PM
I have an almost balanced chart so I'm generally a centrist. Grew up in a Liberal society, but I've seen extreme liberals push there ideals which are unrealistic. For example third wave or radical feminists. They have absolutely have no idea what women in the 60's and 70's went thought and use feminist as an excuse for there own convenience and are not interested in equality. Similarly, I've seen some extreme conservatives that push there racial ideas. So I'm very much a centrist. But I'm moving more right as I notice people in Canada are forgetting how the world is a Darwinian Process and some improvement is required in order to compete in the world. quote: Originally posted by Sagical: but after Trudeau got in it seems like I am kw in the middle... maybe I might like some conservative ideals....i don't know.... maybe I'm right in the middle and wanting to be independent. I grew up in a strictly conservative ruled province for a few decades and I always found myself opposite to what that is.... and now since my party got in I'm really disliking it and want the conservatives back because of many things.....
I'm moving more to the right as well. Liberal ideas were good for Canada for a time. But lets be honest some people have gotten too comfortable. I know its not perfect, but most Canadians have there basic needs satisfied. Where else can you receive universal healthcare. Plus I'm so glad I don't live in Ottawa on a permanent basis anymore. Living here you'll realize French-Canadians are a majority here and they use liberal polices for there own convenience ie Bilingualism. Many would have liked to have learned Quebecois French but might not have had the means or access too. How is that fair to everyone else? It then only benefits them and excludes other people. The impression most people have is Albertans are wannabe "Oil" Texans. ..and Torontonian's are smug wannabe New Yorkers. My Planets ========================================= ☉‘ ♊, ☽ ♈, ASC ♑, ☿ ♊, ¡÷ ♉, ¡ö ♋ , ♃ ♒, ♄ ♏, ♅ ♐, ♆ ♑ IP: Logged |
Sagical Knowflake Posts: 388 From: Glenbow, Canada Registered: Mar 2014
|
posted September 13, 2017 11:53 PM
quote: Originally posted by DualGemV2: I have an almost balanced chart so I'm generally a centrist. Grew up in a Liberal society, but I've seen extreme liberals push there ideals which are unrealistic. For example third wave or radical feminists. They have absolutely have no idea what women in the 60's and 70's went thought and use feminist as an excuse for there own convenience and are not interested in equality. Similarly, I've seen some extreme conservatives that push there racial ideas. So I'm very much a centrist. But I'm moving more right as I notice people in Canada are forgetting how the world is a Darwinian Process and some improvement is required in order to compete in the world. I'm moving more to the right as well. Liberal ideas were good for Canada for a time. But lets be honest some people have gotten too comfortable. I know its not perfect, but most Canadians have there needs satisfied. Where else can you receive universal healthcare. Plus I'm so glad I don't live in Ottawa on a permanent basis anymore. Living here you'll realize French-Canadians are a majority here and they use liberal polices for there convenience ie Bilingualism. Many would have liked to have learned Quebecois French but might not have had the means or access too. How is that fair to everyone else? Sorry about my comments earlier. The impression here is Albertans are wannabe Texans.
I've gotten the vibe from many Albertan's that Torontonian's are wannabe New Yorkers. My Planets ========================================= ☉‘ ♊, ☽ ♈, ASC ♑, ☿ ♊, ¡÷ ♉, ¡ö ♋ , ♃ ♒, ♄ ♏, ♅ ♐, ♆ ♑
Born and raised in Calgary, Alberta. Very conservative people there. I feel very uncomfortable there. I have been to only seven provinces and I can make any comments on Ontario or Québec because I have not visited these provinces to get a feel for them really. Though I'm in Saskatoon now and it's been good. The mayor seems to be a Liberal type and the province is run by conservatives.... Growing up in school, elementary school, to be precise is we had to take French from grade four to six. The grades higher up it was an option if one wanted to go further. (I ended up taking German in High school for three years and two and the German Canadian club). Now I need to go Google Centrist now..... sounds intriguing. IP: Logged |
DualGemV2 Knowflake Posts: 374 From: Toronto, Ontario Registered: Aug 2016
|
posted September 14, 2017 12:08 AM
quote: Originally posted by Sagical: Born and raised in Calgary, Alberta. Very conservative people there. I feel very uncomfortable there. I have been to only seven provinces and I can make any comments on Ontario or Québec because I have not visited these provinces to get a feel for them really.Though I'm in Saskatoon now and it's been good. The mayor seems to be a Liberal type and the province is run by conservatives.... Growing up in school, elementary school, to be precise is we had to take French from grade four to six. The grades higher up it was an option if one wanted to go further. (I ended up taking German in High school for three years and two and the German Canadian club). Now I need to go Google Centrist now..... sounds intriguing.
I actually like Saskatoon and Saskatchewan its has seen some recent economic improvement, but in a more humble way. I think of former Dragons Den, Brett Wilson when I think of Saskatchewan. He is very humble, smart, mathematically gifted and hasn't forgotten his routes. He also gave the most money. He really didn't care if he made any money on any of the deals since he already made enough money. Its mandatory here to take French up to First Year of High School (Gr. 9). So, I guess I can say I received more French school then you did, but I still think its inadequate. I can hold basic conversations, but thats it. Places were a French policy holds only French-Canadians bennift. My Planets ========================================= ☉‘ ♊, ☽ ♈, ASC ♑, ☿ ♊, ¡÷ ♉, ¡ö ♋ , ♃ ♒, ♄ ♏, ♅ ♐, ♆ ♑
IP: Logged | |