Lindaland
  Horary And Event Astrology
  * * * Discussing the Houses * * * (Page 1)

Post New Topic  Post A Reply
profile | register | preferences | faq

UBBFriend: Email This Page to Someone!
This topic is 7 pages long:   1  2  3  4  5  6  7 
next newest topic | next oldest topic
Author Topic:   * * * Discussing the Houses * * *
appleberry
Moderator

Posts: 2987
From: Venusian
Registered: Jun 2011

posted February 01, 2015 11:08 PM     Click Here to See the Profile for appleberry     Edit/Delete Message   Reply w/Quote
You should never start reading a chart until you know which houses to use.

Many of us often seem to have difficultly knowing which houses are the correct houses to choose for certain questions, so let's dedicate this one to figuring things out.

If you're confused about which houses to choose, bring it here to discuss.

HORARY AND HOUSES:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Horary_astrology

HOW TO 'TURN A CHART':
http://www.skyscript.co.uk/horary1ea.html

HOUSES:

http://www.auxmaillesgodefroy.com/houses_for_horary

http://www.moonvalleyastrologer.com/the-houses-in-mundane-astrology/


COMPREHENSIVE LIST OF HOUSES:
(Link is to 1st house, look to right side of page for following houses)
http://www.auxmaillesgodefroy.com/house_one_things

HORARY & HOUSES (Lehman):
http://leephd.blogspot.ca/2006/07/encyclopedia-entry-on-horary-astrology.html

HOUSES (Lilly):
http://www.skyscript.co.uk/lilly_houses.html

HORARY & HOUSES (Wikipedia):
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Horary_astrology

HORARY & HOUSES (Tripod/Mithras):
http://mithras93.tripod.com/lessons/lesson2/lesson2.html

HORARY & HOUSES (Serena):
http://www.serenapowers.com/horary.html

HOUSES, with HORARY APPLICATIONS:
http://www.skyscript.co.uk/temples/h1.html

BODY PARTS BY HOUSE:
http://www.auxmaillesgodefroy.com/body_parts_by_house


***DISCUSSIONS BELOW INCLUDE***:

- 5 vs 7
- their role in our life vs how we feel about them
- Soulmates discussion link


IP: Logged

appleberry
Moderator

Posts: 2987
From: Venusian
Registered: Jun 2011

posted February 01, 2015 11:41 PM     Click Here to See the Profile for appleberry     Edit/Delete Message   Reply w/Quote
Index
[Copied from: ]http://www.skyscript.co.uk/temples/index_list.html]

This list represents the common assignation of house rulerships over specific concerns.

The rulerships offered are based on general principles, but these may need to be amended according to the specific context of the chart. For example, 'criminals' are generally listed as falling under the rulership of the 12th house because of the damaging and covert nature of their activities, but in some charts the criminal may be more appropriately signified by the 7th house, which deals with matters concerning those who attack us and oppose us directly, and is thus the house traditionally said to represent 'the thief'.

The list should therefore not be considered as authoritative or applicable in all situations. When combined with common sense it will provide a good starting point for consideration.

[THE FOLLOWING ARE ALL RADIX POSITIONS, NOT TURNED]

Acclaim: 10th
Accomplishment: 10th
Advancement: 10th
Adversity: 12th
Advice: 9th
Advisors: 9th
Affliction: 6th, 12th
Aged: 4th
Agents: 5th
Agriculture: 4th, 6th
Airlines: 9th
Allies of the nation: 11th
Allies: 2nd
Ambassadors: 5th
Ambition: 11th
Ancestral wealth: 4th
Anguish of mind: 8th
Animals: 6th (large: 12th)
Ankles: 11th
Anxieties: 12th
Appearance: 1st
Archivists: 6th
Arguments: 3rd (afflicted)
Armed forces: 6th
Arms: 3rd
Arts: 5th
Aspirations: 10th
Assets: 2nd
Astrologer: 7th
Astrology: 9th
Asylums: 12th
Aunts: 6th
Au-pairs: 6th
Authority: 10th
Back of shoulders: 5th
Back: 5th
Bail: 12th
Banished persons: 12th
Banks: 2nd
Banquets: 5th
Beginnings and endings: 4th
Beliefs: 9th
Benefactors: 11th
Betting on sport: 5th
Black: 7th
Bladder: 7th, 8th
Body, defects: 6th
Body, shape & form of: 1st
Bondage: l2th Books: 9th
Breasts: 4th
Brothers: 3rd
Buildings: 4th
Burials: 4th
Buried emotions: 4th
Buried treasure: 4th
Business partnerships: 7th
Buttocks: 7th, 9th
Buyer: 1st
Calves: 10th
Captivity: 12th
Career: 10th
Caretakers: 6th
Cars: 3rd
Cattle, large: 12th
Cattle: 6th
Character: 1st
Children: (ancient): 10th, 11th
Children: 5th
Chores: 6th
Church: 9th
Civil service: 6th
Clergy: 9th
Clothes: 5th
Coal: 4th
Collector of taxes: 8th
Colour of appearance: 1st
Comfort and relief: 11th
Commanders: 10th
Common people: 1st
Communication: 3rd
Communications: 3rd
Complexion: 1st
Computers: 3rd
Concentration camps: 12th
Conception: 5th
Conclusions: 4th
Confidence: 11th
Confinement 12th
Conscience: 9th
Contentions: 7th
Contracts: 3rd
Correspondence: 3rd
Councillors: 11th
Councils: 11th
Counsellors: 9th
Countries: 10th
County councils: 11th
Courts: 10th
Cousins: 3rd
Criminals: 7th, 12th
Crisis: 8th
Crops: 6th
Cure for an illness: 10th
Dancing: 5th
Danger 12th
Dark Colours: 6th, 7th
Darkness: 4th, 6th, 8th
Death Duties: 8th
Death rate 8th
Death: 8th, (ancient: 4th, 7th)
Debates: 3rd
Debt: 8th, 12th
Decay: 8th
Decline: 8th
Deeds: 3rd
Defendant In Lawsuit: 7th
Dentists: 6th
Destination, journey: 7th
Destiny: 9th
Dictators: 10th
Dignity: 10th
Diplomats: 5th
Disability allowances: 6th
Disease: 6th, 12th
Disposition: 1st
Distinction: 10th
Divination: 9th
Doctor treating illness: 7th
Doctors (generally): 6th
Documents: 3rd
Dreams: 9th
Drink: 5th
Drowning: 4th
Drudgery: 6th
Dukedoms: 10th
Dukes: 10th
Earls: 10th
Early childhood experiences: 4th
Earnings: 2nd
East: 1st
East-north-east: 2nd
East-south-east: 12th
Education system: 3rd
Elephants: 12th
Emails: 3rd
Empires: 10th
Employees: 6th
Employers: 10th
Enemies: 7th
Enemies, unknown: 12th
Enjoyment: 5th
Enmity: 12th
Entertainment: 5th
Epidemics: 6th
Exchequer 2nd
Exile: 12th
Explorers: 9th
Exports: 2nd
Expression, manner: 1st
Face: 1st
Factories: 6th
Fame: 10th
Family property: 4th
Farmers: 6th
Farming 4th, 6th
Fate: 9th
Fathers: 4th
Father's kin: 6th
Father's money: 5th
Faxes: 3rd
Fear: 6th, 8th
Feasts: 5th
Feet: 12th
Fertility: 5th
Financial matters: 2nd
Financial obligations: 8th
Fineries: 5th
Fines: 12th
Fingers: 3rd
First impressions: 1st
Food: 5th
Foreign countries: 9th
Foreign lands: 9th
Foreign office: 9th
Foreigners: 9th
Form, shape of body: 1st
Foundations: 4th
Freedom: 11th
Friends: 11th
Friendship: 11th
Fugitives: 7th
Funerals: 4th
Gain: 2nd
Gall-stones: 8th
Gambling: 5th
Gardens: 4th
Gems: 4th
Gifts: 5th
Glory: 10th
Goals: 11th
Goats: 6th
Good fortune: 11th
Gossips: 3rd
Government: 10th
Grandchildren: 9th
Grandparents: 4th
Graves: 4th
Green: 2nd, 12th
Green and white: 9th
Grief: 8th
Groin: 8th
Ground, quality of: 4th
Guidance: 9th
Guilty secrets: 12th
Guts: 6th
Gymnasiums: 5th
Haemorrhoids: 8th
Ham labour: 12th
Hams: 10th
Hands: 3rd
Head: 1st
Heads of State: 10th
Health of children: 5th
Health: 1st
Heir to deceased: 8th
Hidden matters: 8th
Hidden things: 4th
Hidden treasure: 4th
Hidden vices: 12th
Hips: 9th
History: 4th
Hobbies: 5th
Hogs: 6th
Home team: 1st
Home: 4th
Homeless people: 12th
Honey-colour: 5th
Hope: 11th
Hopes of the nation: 11th
Horse-racing: 5th
Horses: 12th
Hospitals: 12th
House of Commons: 11th
Houses: 4th
Illness: 6th
Immorality: 5th (affflicted)
Imprisonment: 12th
Income: 2nd
Increase in hope: 2nd
Increase of money/assets: 2nd
Infamy: 10th
Infirmity: 6th
Inheritance: 8th
Inhibition: 12th
Initiator of event: 1st
Inland transit: 3rd
Inns: 5th
Inspiration: 9th
Inspired thoughts: 9th
Intellect: 1st
Internal communications: 3rd
International communications: 9th
International law: 9th
Internet: 3rd
Invisibility: 12th
Isolation: 12th
Journeys, long: 9th
Journeys, short or regular: 3rd
Joy: 5th
Judgement: 10th
Judges: 10th
Justice, dispensing of: 10th
Kidneys: 6th
Kin: 3rd
Kingdoms: 10th
Kings: 10th
Knees: 10th
Knowledge, higher: 9th
Knowledge, mundane: 3rd
Labour: 12th
Labour party: 6th
Labourers: 6th
Land: 4th
Language: 3rd
Law Society: 9th
Law, dispensing of: 10th
Law, practitioners of: 9th
Lawsuits: 7th
Lawyers: 9th
Learning: 9th
Lease agreements: 4th
Legacies: 8th
Legs: 11th
Leisure industry: 5th
Letters: 3rd
Libraries: 6th
Lies: 3rd (afflicted)
Life: 1st
Literature: 3rd
Livelihood: 2nd
Liver: 5th
Loans: 8th
Lodgers: 6th
Long journeys: 9th
Loss: 8th
Lotteries: 5th
Love affairs: 5th
Lovemaking: 5th
Lovers: 7th
Lower belly: 6th
Lower intestines: 7th
Luck, bad: 12th
Luck, good: 11th
Lungs: 4th
Magazines: 3rd
Magistrates: 10th
Maids: 6th
Malicious hauntings: 12th
Manners: 1st
Marriage/divorce rate: 7th
Marriage: 7th
Material comforts: 2nd
Material possessions: 2nd
Menial tasks: 6th
Merriment: 5th
Messages: 3rd
Messengers: 3rd
Metals, mining of: 4th
Mind: 1st
Minerals: 4th
Mines: 4th
Mining: 4th
Misery: 12th
Monasteries: 12th
Money lent: 2nd
Money markets: 2nd
Money of partner: 8th
Money owed: 8th
Monks: 9th, 12th
Moral ideas: 9th
Mothers: 10th
Motivation: 11th
Mourning: 8th
Moveable goods: 2nd
Murder: 8th
Music: 5th
Mysticism: 9th
Nation's assets: 2nd
Nation's food reserves: 6th
National art galleries: 5th
National birth rate: 5th
National debt: 8th
National reputation: 10th
Nationalism: 4th
Natural resources of earth: 4th
Navel: 7th
Neck, down to shoulders: 2nd
Neighbourhood: 3rd
Neighbours: 3rd
Neighbouring nations: 3rd
Newspapers: 3rd
Nobility: 10th
North: 4th
North-north-east: 3rd
North-north-west: 5th
Notoriety: 10th
Nuns: 9th, 12th
Nurses: 6th
Occult groups: 12th
Oil: 4th
Old age: 4th
Opponent: 7th
Orangy-yellow: 3rd
Outer image: 1st
Outlaws: 7th
Overseas: 9th
Overwork: 6th
Oxen: 12th
Parents: 4th
Parks: 5th
Parliament: 11th
Parties: 5th
Partner's money: 8th
Partners: 7th
Partnerships: 7th
Paternity: 4th
Patrimony: 4th
Patriotism: 4th
Periodicals: 3rd
Persecution: 12th
Personal fears: 12th
Personal belongings: 2nd
Personal strength: 1st
Personality: 1st
Pets: 6th
Philosophy: 9th
Physical appearance: 1st
Piles: 8th
Pilgrims: 9th
Places of comfort and relief: 11th
Plays: 5th
Pleasant things: 5th
Pleasure: 5th
Poison: 8th
Police as law enforcers: 10th
Police as public servants: 6th
Political ideals: 11th
Popular favour: 10th
Position: 10th
Post office: 3rd
Postal service: 3rd
Power: 10th
Praise: 11th
Pregnancy: 5th
Pregnant women: 5th
Premature states: 12th
Press: 3rd
Prestige: 10th
Price, of transaction: 10th
Prime officers: 10th
Princes: 10th
Prison system: 12th
Prison: 12th
Prisoners: 12th
Private life: 4th
Private places: 12th
Privy council: 8th
Profession: 10th
Professional pursuits: 10th
Professors: 9th
Profit: 2nd
Profit or loss: 2nd
Promiscuity: 5th (afflicted)
Propaganda: 3rd
Property for sale: 4th
Property market: 4th
Prosecution in a lawsuit: 1st
Public acknowledgement: 10th
Public employees: 6th
Public enemies to the nation: 7th
Public eye: 10th
Public mortality: 8th
Public opinion: 3rd
Public records: 6th
Publications: 3rd
Publishing industry: 9th
Pubs: 5th
Querent: 1st
Rabbits: 6th
Railways: 3rd
Recreation: 5th
Red and white: 10th
Red: 4th
Reformatories: 12th
Release: 11th
Religion: 9th
Reports: 3rd
Reproductive organs: 7th
Reputation: 10th
Resorts: 5th
Resources: 2nd
Restriction: 12th
Restraint: 12th
Return to the source: 4th
Revelations: 9th
Revenue: 2nd
Rich, luxurious things: 5th
Road/river traffic: 3rd
Romance: 5th
Royalty: 10th
Rulership: 10th
Ruling in law court: 10th
Rumours: 3rd
Run-aways: 7th
Rusty colours: 3rd
Saboteurs: 12th
Sad events: 12th
Saffron: 11th
Scandals: 12th
Scholars: 9th
Scholarships: 9th
School life: 3rd
School system: 5th
Scientific institutions: 9th
Sea traffic: 9th
Secret enemies: 12th
Secret societies: 12th
Secrets: 12th
Seclusion: 12th
Self-undoing: 12th
Servants: 6th
Sex: 5th
Sex of unborn child: 5th
Sex organs: 5th, 8th
Sexual inhibition: 5th
Shame: 12th
Shared aims: 11th
Sheep: 6th
Shepherds: 6th
Shins: 10th
Shipping: 9th
Shoulders: 3rd
Sickness: 6th
Sides of body: 5th
Sisters: 3rd
Slavery: 12th
Slaves: 12th
Small animals: 6th
Smaller intestine: 6th
Social issues re. children: 5th
Social occasions: 5th
Social security services: 6th
Social standing: 10th
Society's views on sex: 5th
Solicitors: 9th
Soothsaying: 9th
Sorrow: 6th, 8th, 12th
South: 10th
South-south-east: 11th
South-south-west: 9th
Speech: 1st, 3rd
Speeches: 3rd
Spies: 12th
Spiritual matters: 9th
Sport: 5th
Sporting arenas: 5th
Spouse: 7th
State of the nation: 1st
Stature: 1st
Stock exchange: 2nd
Stomach: 5th
Strangury: 8th
Strength: 10th
Students: 9th
Subordinates: 6th
Substance: 2nd
Success: 10th
Support, assistance: 2nd
Supporters of ruling power: 11th
Supporters: 11th
Tavern: 5th
Taxes: 8th
Telephones: 3rd
Television: 3rd
Tenants: 6th
Tenements: 4th
Theatres: 5th
Thief/thieves: 7th
Thighs: 9th
Throat: 2nd
Toil: 6th, 12th
Tombs: 4th
Towns: 4th
Trade unions: 6th
Trade: 10th
Tradition: 4th
Traitors: 12th
Transport system: 3rd
Travel, long: 9th
Travel, short: 3rd
Travellers: 3rd
Treasure, hidden: 4th
Treasury: 2nd
Trust: 11th
Underground groups: 12th
Underground systems: 4th
Underground tranport: 3rd, 4th
Underworld: 4th
Unemployment insurance: 6th
United Nations: 9th
Universities: 9th
Unknown matters: 12th
Victims: 8th
Visions: 9th
Visitors: 3rd
Vitality: 1st
Vitality, lack of: 6th
Voyages: 9th
Vulnerability: 8th
Water supplies: 4th
Weakness: 4th, 6th, 8th, 12th
Wealth from hidden sources: 4th
Wealth, manner of attaining: 2nd
Wealth: 2nd
Wells: 4th
Welfare state: 12th
West: 7th
West-north-west: 6th
West-south-west: 8th
White / pale colours: 1st
Widespread diseases: 6th
Wills: 8th
Wisdom: 9th
Witchcraft: 12th
Witches: 12th
Witnesses for the defence: 8th
Witnesses for the prosecution: 2nd
Womb: 7th
Working classes: 6th
Writing: 3rd

IP: Logged

babybull82
Knowflake

Posts: 963
From:
Registered: Aug 2013

posted February 02, 2015 02:28 AM     Click Here to See the Profile for babybull82     Edit/Delete Message   Reply w/Quote
Hi!!!

Yes I'd like to know once and for all if 5th should be used for new/potential romantic interest or the 7th?

There is a lot of conflicting information out there lol

IP: Logged

hannaramaa
unregistered
posted February 02, 2015 11:54 AM           Edit/Delete Message   Reply w/Quote
Do we use houses based on the title given to the two parties (when asking about another person) or based on how we feel about them instead?

Considering my inquiry about someone coming over to my house, would the house get its own significator?

IP: Logged

appleberry
Moderator

Posts: 2987
From: Venusian
Registered: Jun 2011

posted February 02, 2015 11:34 PM     Click Here to See the Profile for appleberry     Edit/Delete Message   Reply w/Quote
quote:
Originally posted by babybull82:
Hi!!!

Yes I'd like to know once and for all if 5th should be used for new/potential romantic interest or the 7th?

There is a lot of conflicting information out there lol


I think the biggest problem is that things aren't black and white and will vary from question to question. It's not about 'use this for this and that for that'... you have to start thinking about the kind of energy that each house represents... Ultimately, the 5th house is about pleasure and creation, and the 7th house is about union vs opposition...

When you are asking a question about a kind of relationship, think about the energy of the question- is the basis of the relationship question about the pleasure you will find by being with someone, or the security and stability of a union. Is it about the excitement of the new beginning and exploring each other as people, or finding some kind of commitment?

Hope that makes sense...

IP: Logged

babybull82
Knowflake

Posts: 963
From:
Registered: Aug 2013

posted February 03, 2015 12:44 AM     Click Here to See the Profile for babybull82     Edit/Delete Message   Reply w/Quote
quote:
Originally posted by appleberry:
I think the biggest problem is that things aren't black and white and will vary from question to question. It's not about 'use this for this and that for that'... you have to start thinking about the kind of energy that each house represents... Ultimately, the 5th house is about pleasure and creation, and the 7th house is about union vs opposition...

When you are asking a question about a kind of relationship, think about the energy of the question- is the basis of the relationship question about the pleasure you will find by being with someone, or the security and stability of a union. Is it about the excitement of the new beginning and exploring each other as people, or finding some kind of commitment?

Hope that makes sense...


It does actually when you put it that way. Thank you!

IP: Logged

appleberry
Moderator

Posts: 2987
From: Venusian
Registered: Jun 2011

posted February 07, 2015 05:28 PM     Click Here to See the Profile for appleberry     Edit/Delete Message   Reply w/Quote
quote:
Originally posted by hannaramaa:
Do we use houses based on the title given to the two parties (when asking about another person) or based on how we feel about them instead?

Considering my inquiry about someone coming over to my house, would the house get its own significator?


Good question. Not sure I could give a definitive answer, but I would say go with titles. If you're interested in your boss romantically, you would likely still use the house of the boss to represent him.

You might have never met your father, but you would use the house of the father rather than the 7th (of all other people who have no other house to represent them), because he's still your father. Or, he might be your best friend as well, but you wouldn't use the 11th.

I've never read anything specifically about this problem, but I'm going to say go with their title role in your life, rather than how you feel about them.

Please, add more on this topic if anyone knows more.

IP: Logged

appleberry
Moderator

Posts: 2987
From: Venusian
Registered: Jun 2011

posted March 29, 2015 05:09 PM     Click Here to See the Profile for appleberry     Edit/Delete Message   Reply w/Quote
Link on a discussion about which houses to use for Soul-mates:
http://www.linda-goodman.com/ubb/Forum36/HTML/000709.html

IP: Logged

appleberry
Moderator

Posts: 2987
From: Venusian
Registered: Jun 2011

posted March 29, 2015 05:14 PM     Click Here to See the Profile for appleberry     Edit/Delete Message   Reply w/Quote
<moved>

IP: Logged

appleberry
Moderator

Posts: 2987
From: Venusian
Registered: Jun 2011

posted March 29, 2015 05:19 PM     Click Here to See the Profile for appleberry     Edit/Delete Message   Reply w/Quote
THE SAME PLANET IS THE MAIN SIGNIFICATOR OF BOTH HOUSES:
(Example: Querent is Aries and Quesited is Scorpio, both look to Mars as a Lord)

Two methods:
1. Use the Moon for the Quesited.
(Example would use Mars and Moon)
or
2. Use the following sign of the zodiac (of the quesited's house).
(Example would use Mars and Sagittarius)


METHOD TWO EXPLAINED:
"Sometimes the same planet rules both the querent and the quesited (the one asking the question and the thing asked about). In that case only, when it is required, then you can use the next sign in the zodiac to signify the quested.

A question "Will I get this job?"- Virgo is on the ascendant with Mercury representing the querent. Gemini is on the 10th house, so also has Mercury as its ruler. If required, use the ruler of the next sign in zodiac order. This would be Cancer, with the Moon as ruler.

If the question does not require making an aspect between significators of the querent and the quesited, you may not need to define Lord 10.

If you are just seeking information about the quesited, then give the shared ruler to signify the quesited. (This would work in questions about lost things.)

Another technique to use ONLY when the planet ruling the sign is unavailable is to use a planet that is very near the cusp of the house and IN THE SAME ZODIAC SIGN as the cusp.
Planets in the house can give useful information, but they are not the RULER.

The last choice is to use the Almuten. The Almuten is the "strongest planet" associated with the house cusp. There are varied techniques of calculating the almuten, See Strength Of Significators.

Outer planets, Uranus, Neptune or Pluto should not be used as significators or only under very special circumstances (electronics could be Uranus, but better to use Mercury for electricity and communication or Mars for the hardware itself). Often you will find that the placement of these planets "confirms" findings using traditional planets. "


Copied from: http://www.auxmaillesgodefroy.com/assigning_significators

IP: Logged

appleberry
Moderator

Posts: 2987
From: Venusian
Registered: Jun 2011

posted April 19, 2015 05:38 PM     Click Here to See the Profile for appleberry     Edit/Delete Message   Reply w/Quote
<bump>

IP: Logged

EmGem
Knowflake

Posts: 2619
From:
Registered: Jan 2015

posted April 19, 2015 08:11 PM     Click Here to See the Profile for EmGem     Edit/Delete Message   Reply w/Quote
quote:
Originally posted by appleberry:
I think the biggest problem is that things aren't black and white and will vary from question to question. It's not about 'use this for this and that for that'... you have to start thinking about the kind of energy that each house represents... Ultimately, the 5th house is about pleasure and creation, and the 7th house is about union vs opposition...

When you are asking a question about a kind of relationship, think about the energy of the question- is the basis of the relationship question about the pleasure you will find by being with someone, or the security and stability of a union. Is it about the excitement of the new beginning and exploring each other as people, or finding some kind of commitment?

Hope that makes sense...


If you don't seek commitment but are asking about a potential casual romantic type of situation would that be 5th or 7th? I just read somewhere that said you should always use 7th if it concerns a person of romantic interest. Others say 5th..

IP: Logged

appleberry
Moderator

Posts: 2987
From: Venusian
Registered: Jun 2011

posted April 19, 2015 09:36 PM     Click Here to See the Profile for appleberry     Edit/Delete Message   Reply w/Quote
quote:
Originally posted by EmGem:
If you don't seek commitment but are asking about a potential casual romantic type of situation would that be 5th or 7th? I just read somewhere that said you should always use 7th if it concerns a person of romantic interest. Others say 5th..

It's not clear-cut, that's why choosing the houses can be one of the most difficult parts. In your case, it is hard because you say that you are 'physical' but not sexual, but friends... so it sounds like "FWB but no sex'...

It's not a platonic friendship if there are benefits, but there has been no actual union... so I guess 5th. But, in your case it seems like there might be cultural or sub-cultural differences that I don't fully understand, so I'm still not completely sure. I have to go by what is said.

The best I can make of the differences:

11th house = Strictly platonic interest for the Querent, not interested romantically in the Quesited, regardless of how the Quesited feels.

5th house = Querent is interested romantically in the Quesited, in a dynamic relationship heading towards some sort of union, even if it's just sexually oriented.

7th house = Querent is somehow in a union (whether positive such as a significant other, or negative such as an ex). Or, some sort of 'union' has already occurred, even if purely sexual.

IP: Logged

ail221
Moderator

Posts: 7119
From: Hanging Gardens of Babylon
Registered: Feb 2012

posted April 20, 2015 11:12 PM     Click Here to See the Profile for ail221     Edit/Delete Message   Reply w/Quote
Would you use the 7th house for the partner of a ex or would you use the 5th house for the 7th house?

IP: Logged

mollywu
Knowflake

Posts: 459
From: Chengdu, China
Registered: Jul 2014

posted April 20, 2015 11:18 PM     Click Here to See the Profile for mollywu     Edit/Delete Message   Reply w/Quote
quote:
Originally posted by ail221:
Would you use the 7th house for the partner of a ex or would you use the 5th house for the 7th house?

Good question, I want to know too.

IP: Logged

appleberry
Moderator

Posts: 2987
From: Venusian
Registered: Jun 2011

posted April 21, 2015 03:31 PM     Click Here to See the Profile for appleberry     Edit/Delete Message   Reply w/Quote
"In general"...

7th is your ex, their partner is the turned 7th, someone they're interested in is the turned 5th... if it's your partner (also 7th), turned 5th is a mistress/other woman/an affair...

Everything depends on the context of the question.

IP: Logged

ail221
Moderator

Posts: 7119
From: Hanging Gardens of Babylon
Registered: Feb 2012

posted April 21, 2015 05:10 PM     Click Here to See the Profile for ail221     Edit/Delete Message   Reply w/Quote
If their 7th is turned then the querent would use the moon as their significator?

IP: Logged

appleberry
Moderator

Posts: 2987
From: Venusian
Registered: Jun 2011

posted April 21, 2015 08:21 PM     Click Here to See the Profile for appleberry     Edit/Delete Message   Reply w/Quote
I've been trying to find a quote on this because I think I remember reading in complicated situations like this, where there is a relevant question about exes and each other's new partner... Well, it goes like this IF I remember correctly (and I'm really not sure, because I haven't done any of my own charts on a topic like this):

You/Querent: House 1
Your Ex: House 7
Your new partner: House 2
Your Ex's new Partner: House 8

I don't know how I feel about that... it kind of treats the new partners of each like "possessions", but there is some validity in that as well when you look at it from an "us vs them" perspective. We should find some charts of known answers and give it a look, I guess.

ETA: Another way of telling other partners is seeing the main significator of the Querent or Quesited in CLOSE conjunction with another planet (generally within the same house and sign).

IP: Logged

ikja
unregistered
posted April 22, 2015 01:36 PM           Edit/Delete Message   Reply w/Quote
Your second post is so beautiful!
Love that list!

IP: Logged

ikja
unregistered
posted April 22, 2015 01:37 PM           Edit/Delete Message   Reply w/Quote
quote:
Originally posted by appleberry:
I've been trying to find a quote on this because I think I remember reading in complicated situations like this, where there is a relevant question about exes and each other's new partner... Well, it goes like this IF I remember correctly (and I'm really not sure, because I haven't done any of my own charts on a topic like this):

You/Querent: House 1
Your Ex: House 7
Your new partner: House 2
Your Ex's new Partner: House 8

I don't know how I feel about that... it kind of treats the new partners of each like "possessions", but there is some validity in that as well when you look at it from an "us vs them" perspective. We should find some charts of known answers and give it a look, I guess.

ETA: Another way of telling other partners is seeing the main significator of the Querent or Quesited in CLOSE conjunction with another planet (generally within the same house and sign).


You say 'You Ex's New Partner', is that 8th house turned?

IP: Logged

appleberry
Moderator

Posts: 2987
From: Venusian
Registered: Jun 2011

posted April 22, 2015 01:59 PM     Click Here to See the Profile for appleberry     Edit/Delete Message   Reply w/Quote
^Those are all used as radical positions. (But again, I can't confirm those... it's another person's method that I haven't tested).

IP: Logged

appleberry
Moderator

Posts: 2987
From: Venusian
Registered: Jun 2011

posted May 01, 2015 01:29 AM     Click Here to See the Profile for appleberry     Edit/Delete Message   Reply w/Quote
<bump>

IP: Logged

appleberry
Moderator

Posts: 2987
From: Venusian
Registered: Jun 2011

posted May 01, 2015 01:30 AM     Click Here to See the Profile for appleberry     Edit/Delete Message   Reply w/Quote
<bump>

IP: Logged

appleberry
Moderator

Posts: 2987
From: Venusian
Registered: Jun 2011

posted May 01, 2015 01:34 AM     Click Here to See the Profile for appleberry     Edit/Delete Message   Reply w/Quote
<bump>

IP: Logged

appleberry
Moderator

Posts: 2987
From: Venusian
Registered: Jun 2011

posted June 05, 2015 12:49 PM     Click Here to See the Profile for appleberry     Edit/Delete Message   Reply w/Quote
< bump >

IP: Logged


This topic is 7 pages long:   1  2  3  4  5  6  7 

All times are Eastern Standard Time

next newest topic | next oldest topic

Administrative Options: Close Topic | Archive/Move | Delete Topic
Post New Topic  Post A Reply
Hop to:

Contact Us | Linda-Goodman.com

Copyright 2000-2023

Powered by Infopop www.infopop.com © 2000
Ultimate Bulletin Board 5.46a