Author
|
Topic: What sign is more likely to win an argument?
|
florence Knowflake Posts: 1137 From: Registered: Jun 2012
|
posted March 26, 2013 02:41 PM
quote: Originally posted by Jessica2407: Arguing over something doesn't necessarily have to be personal. My post was related to the fact that cancers often use the victim card when they feel they are losing an argument. The cancers I know will end up twisting the words and make it sound like you are insulting themthem.My mum is a great example and she does it so well.
yes, i kind of know what you mean. i'm more saying it's probably the same thing from two different points of view - they want you to care, from their perspective (i'm thinking) and from the others it's manipulation. i'm thinking it's possibly that way because the description of cancers being centered on feelings reminded me of an infp description .. that infp's care more about how they feel than who is right. as an infp, it really made me think how skewed my thinking can be in terms of if i argue it's because i think the other doesn't care about either me or the subject. (i do counter-balance it with uranus detachment too but between the two modes feel really de-centered sometimes). don't know who are good arguers but i like arguing with geminis and leos because they seem very fair to me, don't seem to resort to personal attacks & appear less ego invested. doesn't sound like leo i suppose but that's my experience with one, who just is an amazing mediator and at turning opponents into being their biggest advocate. IP: Logged |
Astro_Curious Knowflake Posts: 47 From: Washington, DC, USA Registered: Mar 2013
|
posted March 26, 2013 02:43 PM
Sorry, I don't know how to quote yet! I think it depends on what’s being debated. If we’re debating the best way to build something, then that’s one story. The things we’re discussing are more or less concrete and based on the generally known properties. I’m not going to argue that gravity isn’t real or that the Earth doesn’t rotate based on my or anyone’s emotions. If we’re debating why someone did, thought, or said something that’s a completely different story and I think discussing emotions and how they would give way to motives is relevant.
IP: Logged |
Jessica2407 Moderator Posts: 5151 From: Saturn Registered: Sep 2012
|
posted March 26, 2013 02:52 PM
quote: Originally posted by CherryVodka: Well, I WAS the underdog and still am in many ways. I was picked on in High School, and hold a contempt for anyone I see making others sad. I won't hesitate to ruin these people's lives who are causing it though. Weird because I am sensitive and easily hurt, but I will kill myself in a fight before I let them. The clash is because Mars says F that man! These people need a taste of their own medicine but Neptune has kindness for all mankind and believes we are all in effect to one another. I'm still very conflicted with this, do you feel this way or no?
No, I wasn't the underdog, not at school, not in college..nope. At school, I was the nerd that everybody didn't even notice. When I was in college,still a nerd lol..am still a nerd btw...now that I think of it, I was never picked at, or taunted or anything of that sort of thing.. Despite the fact that I'm a very dominant person,I won't use my power to oppress others.There is zero efficiency when people feel oppressed. I wouldn't want someone to oppress me so I won't do it to others.I'd rather use my powers to make others respect me enough to allow me to lead.There are honorable ways to do that. There is this saying by Theodore Roosevelt :''People ask the difference between a leader and a boss.The leader leads, and the boss drives.'' I really like that quote I use it everytime I get the chance with my boss  IP: Logged |
Jessica2407 Moderator Posts: 5151 From: Saturn Registered: Sep 2012
|
posted March 26, 2013 03:00 PM
quote: Originally posted by florence: yes, i kind of know what you mean. i'm more saying it's probably the same thing from two different points of view - they want you to care, from their perspective (i'm thinking) and from the others it's manipulation. i'm thinking it's possibly that way because the description of cancers being centered on feelings reminded me of an infp description .. that infp's care more about how they feel than who is right. as an infp, it really made me think how skewed my thinking can be in terms of if i argue it's because i think the other doesn't care about either me or the subject. (i do counter-balance it with uranus detachment too but between the two modes feel really de-centered sometimes). don't know who are good arguers but i like arguing with geminis and leos because they seem very fair to me, don't seem to resort to personal attacks & appear less ego invested. doesn't sound like leo i suppose but that's my experience with one, who just is an amazing mediator and at turning opponents into being their biggest advocate.
Exactly. Cancers think when you don't agree with their opinions,it means that you don't care about them. seriously, I fail to see how caring about them has anything to do with not sharing their opinions! That's the MAIN reason why I stay clear from any sort of argument with cancers. 
IP: Logged |
CherryVodka unregistered
|
posted March 26, 2013 03:17 PM
Well, in my life I'd tried to be reasonable a lot with people actually but they take advantage, so today I'm more eye for an eye type of person.I have zero sympathy for someone going around making other people feel bad, they don't deserve it. Everyone says that we all have to change and treat others how we want to be treated, well I'm sorry but look where it's gotten us, bullying is at an all time high right now in schools. Eh whatever, I'm getting a little upset with how indifferent everyone is with this stuff now a days. I feel like I'm the only person who sees things how they are. You can't have only politically correctness all the time, there needs to be a balance of realness and consideration. IP: Logged |
Astro_Curious Knowflake Posts: 47 From: Washington, DC, USA Registered: Mar 2013
|
posted March 26, 2013 03:33 PM
quote: Originally posted by CherryVodka: Well, in my life I'd tried to be reasonable a lot with people actually but they take advantage, so today I'm more eye for an eye type of person.I have zero sympathy for someone going around making other people feel bad, they don't deserve it. Everyone says that we all have to change and treat others how we want to be treated, well I'm sorry but look where it's gotten us, bullying is at an all time high right now in schools. Eh whatever, I'm getting a little upset with how indifferent everyone is with this stuff now a days. I feel like I'm the only person who sees things how they are. You can't have only politically correctness all the time, there needs to be a balance of realness and consideration.
I agree with you. Your sentiments are very Mars in Scorpio. Everything can't be roses and lollipops all the time, nor should they be ...
IP: Logged |
k e p h x i Knowflake Posts: 233 From: St. Paul, MN, USA Registered: Mar 2013
|
posted March 26, 2013 03:53 PM
Sharp-tongued Scorpios!  ------------------ Rising: Virgo Sun: _____ Moon: _____ IP: Logged |
Orange Knowflake Posts: 4618 From: Georgia Registered: May 2009
|
posted March 26, 2013 03:54 PM
@ Cherry and @ Jessi ( Jussy )yes, about that Mars/Neptune square, we talked about that before, Jess. I have that, too (Neptune also makes other squares in my chart) and I had always fought for the underdog. My Mars is in Leo square Saturn as well. I havent been picked on in my life, just the opposite actually - the abused kids in school would ask for me to help them because all boys ( usually the the bullies) respected me quite a bit, and i always came to their defense. My Venus is in Libra, so i do like social justice and balance. It probably conjuncts Cherry Vodka's Mars, too. and my Mars is proly on Jessica's Leo stellium. IP: Logged |
Moon_girl Knowflake Posts: 28 From: College Park, Md, U.S. Registered: Jan 2010
|
posted March 26, 2013 05:16 PM
quote: Originally posted by Jessica2407: Exactly.Cancers think when you don't agree with their opinions,it means that you don't care about them. seriously, I fail to see how caring about them has anything to do with not sharing their opinions! That's the MAIN reason why I stay clear from any sort of argument with cancers. 
If you're staying clear of arguments with Cancerians aren't they technically still winning (by default)? :-)
IP: Logged |
AcousticGod Knowflake Posts: 8743 From: Dublin, CA Registered: Apr 2009
|
posted March 26, 2013 05:48 PM
I'll accept Mars in Scorpio as I have that placement.If we're talking Suns...hmmm... Mutables collect information, that's their strength. Fixed wants to rule, but will attempt to bend things to fit what they believe. Cardinal is (can be) both stubborn and flexible, so it comes down to their command of the information or other placements. IP: Logged |
Jessica2407 Moderator Posts: 5151 From: Saturn Registered: Sep 2012
|
posted March 27, 2013 12:37 AM
quote: Originally posted by Moon_girl: If you're staying clear of arguments with Cancerians aren't they technically still winning (by default)? :-)
I let my mum 'win' by not even arguing with her. IP: Logged |
diamondbaby Knowflake Posts: 675 From: Registered: Jul 2012
|
posted May 22, 2016 10:40 PM
Aries Moon and/or Mercury Gemini Moon and/or Mercury Mercury/Mars conjunction/trine/sextileIP: Logged |
DualGem Knowflake Posts: 161 From: Canada Registered: Oct 2015
|
posted May 23, 2016 05:10 AM
All signs have a chance if they use there energies right.How They Win --------------- The Fixed Signs ( Leo, Aquarius, Scorpio, Taurus) = Can win by stamina, focus and not giving in. Cardinal Signs (Capricorn, Cancer, Aries, Libra) = Can win via working hard on researching how to win the argument, say case studies or the outcome of similar debates. Mutable Signs (Gemini, Sag, Virgo, Pisces) Can win by being flexible enough to see loop holes and ways around key points. How They Can Loose. ------------------- Fixed Signs are notoriously stubborn, so they could be defending an outdated view or idea, while everyone has moved on. For example Racism, Women and Gender isues and etc. This can cost them there argument if other people are brought in and they are sean as from the past. Cardinal Signs can end up becoming exhausted defending a hard case. Mutable signs can change and are unstable. With that any Sign can win if the particular energy is tailed for that argument/debate or case. ==================================== Gemini Sun, Capricorn Rising Aries Moon Gemini Mercury Venus Taurus Mars Cancer IP: Logged |
charlie Knowflake Posts: 3695 From: Registered: Jun 2012
|
posted May 23, 2016 06:05 AM
I'm pretty good at arguing and I give credit to my Virgo Mars conj Asc. I never forget what's been said, I see details in words said and I always find loopholes in "logic". Bad part is I can use it in not so very good ways. My Scorpio Mom is brutal (Sun, Moon and Mercury Scorpio sq. Leo Pluto) :-/. She'll shut a person DOWN with an axe right into heart and soul. My Aries husband will either: A: say whatever words he can come up with and it doesn't matter if they are out of context or B: walk off mid-sentence to prove some point or C: throw something My Cancer Moon, Asc step daughter will manipulate through crying or lie and say that she's in pain to get attention. Good arguers I know are dominant Libra and Gemini.
IP: Logged |
Sagical Knowflake Posts: 265 From: Glenbow, Canada Registered: Mar 2014
|
posted June 01, 2016 06:33 PM
A Leo Mercury and Mars would trump everything and throw in a Saturn in Gemini. He is a master expert in everything and he is always right. Things will be shots down faster than you say it and nobody has any opinion because he is the authority of the world and the world must bow down to him.... This is my narc ex. IP: Logged |