Author
|
Topic: Mercury-Saturn aspects...how does it affect communication?
|
cthonicstar Knowflake Posts: 80 From: Registered: Sep 2019
|
posted September 22, 2019 12:15 AM
What are some of the trends you've noticed in people who have Mercury-Saturn aspects? To me they always seem careful with speaking. It's as if they are mentally reviewing everything they're about to say to make sure it passes their internal filter. Or they come across as very quiet people. IP: Logged |
Aries23Degrees Knowflake Posts: 7806 From: South Africa Registered: Dec 2012
|
posted September 22, 2019 02:40 AM
Correct you are.Add to that basket Saturn in Virgo/Gemini,Saturn in 3rd or 6th, Capricorn on the cusp of the 3rd/6th. Raised by grandma or an elder,considerably older siblings or there is a huge gap between them and younger siblings, the only child, learning language through an elder,speaking with authority,being taught to speak with respect, speaking in old/srructured diction,using sentence construction in a very rigid way,you are your own "editor", someone is always shouting at you "speak properly!" and this can create pressure and/or anxiety when it comes to expressing yourself with words, assisted early learning, special needs class, native is elder sibling and is therefore "responsible" for younger siblings, native may be raised by elder siblings, no children their age around to learn from, a childhood that is isolated from peer contact prevents early accumulation of language, native looks up to a sibling that is greatly accomplished in communication, challenges in learning, learning takes longer or there is great pressure to learn early, entering school at an age that is late or too early, a stammer or lisp, a soft voice that doesn't project, a monotonous voice that is off-putting, a voice for radio, an interest in the communication field, being paid for how you express yourself, "dead pan" comic genius,dry sense of humour, sophisticated jargon,using old-style cursive writing and avoiding "sms" language, trouble fitting in with peers as the native often does not relate to people their age etc. Language and learning is a 3rd house/Mercury function as is communication. So Saturn involved there can create delays and/or issues there that may force the individual to either become well versed at Mercury related things early on (due to imposing pressure). Or the native may sincerely struggle by having learning challenges due to the inability to focus or have ADD. And perhaps the parents/guardians have a relaxed attitude in steering the native to learn,speak,read or write. The caution you speak of is because of Saturn.Saturn wants to come across authoritative on the subject expressed by Mercury.This is especially true when there is a conjunction/square. The opposition as well as the square often creates uncertainty on whether the "correct" information is being communicated. And so they may come across self-doubting unless very well-versed with the crowd they are addressing. I actually find Mercury-Saturn people quite funny. But they can also be melancholic and prone to depression. This especially with the tight opp/square and conj. And this is because Saturn brings to the mental sphere chronic thoughts of self criticism. These guys are their own worst critic. My nephew has Saturn in 3rd with Cap on the cusp of the 3rd and he is about 1 year of age. I am observing him closely to see how he does with communication i.e will it come easy to him or will it be delayed? He is currently being raised by my Mom(his Grandma) and the nanny who looks after him is also 50 years of age.So here Saturn(elder) in 3rd is accurate as my mother and the nanny are teaching him how to talk (3rd) His Dad is a manic depressive and so I wonder if he has the genetic predisposition to that? At the time of his birth, Dad was in hospital for a botched suicide attempt. IP: Logged |
MMarie Knowflake Posts: 670 From: Registered: Aug 2018
|
posted September 22, 2019 08:28 AM
I have Saturn in Capricorn in the 6th house trine mercury in Virgo at the end of the second house. A lot of what Aries23degrees wrote is true for me: Speaking with authority/ speaking with respect In part raised by older siblings Early on speaking issues/lisp had to take special classes A soft sometimes monotonous voice (being told to speak louder often) Prone to depression (Saturn also trines mars in Taurus the 10th) I feel good aspects with Saturn can help with authoritative positions - being a manager/ boss/ teacher etc. But overall feel “controlled” internally and yes shy & quiet often. It is really at odds with my sun conjunct moon in 1st house Leo (Leo rising) which is more expressive, heart on sleeve, in your face at times. It is like there are 2 contradictory parts of me but the earth grand trine always wins and especially in work and social settings. IP: Logged |
Leo-Cancer98 Knowflake Posts: 974 From: Toronto,Ontario,Canada Registered: Nov 2014
|
posted September 22, 2019 06:29 PM
quote: Originally posted by cthonicstar: What are some of the trends you've noticed in people who have Mercury-Saturn aspects? To me they always seem careful with speaking. It's as if they are mentally reviewing everything they're about to say to make sure it passes their internal filter. Or they come across as very quiet people.
I'm very serious-minded, when it comes to anything; especially work, fitness, academia, and finances. ------------------ Cancer Rising 2nd House Leo Sun 3rd House Leo Mercury 6th House Sagittarius Moon & Pluto 1st House Cancer Venus & Mars 9th House Pisces Jupiter conjunct MC. IP: Logged |
Lerena Knowflake Posts: 1344 From: Registered: May 2015
|
posted September 22, 2019 07:45 PM
I have Mercury sextile Saturn in my natal chart and I also have Saturn in Aquarius square Sun in Taurus. The orb for the sextile 4 degrees and the square has an orb of 2 degrees, but I also have Saturn in 3rd house. My speech is very restrained and I cam be incredibly critical of myself and my capabilities. I'm doing my best to unlearn this as much as it's healthy, because I think it's important to be self-aware of what you say and how you say it. However, I'm not the best example of this in practice. Socially, I'm very isolated and I feel like an outcast. Some of it is my own fault and some of it is related to my childhood. Needless to say, I have a lot to learn when it comes to social interactions and I'm 27. I'm often self-critical with the intent to improve, but I can take it too far sometimes. For example, if I make a mistake, it'll drive me nuts for months. While I'm aware of this issue, the most I can do is just learn from my mistakes instead of repeating them. This just doesn't stop me from remembering the mistake was made to begin with. My family isn't responsible for how I ended up. In school, I was often bullied and rejected by my peers, and, at some point, I became more of a perfectionist with obsessive-compulsive tendencies. During the Saturn-Pluto conjunction earlier this year, I got put on a medication for anxiety and I'm now on another medication that seems to help with emotional regulation. I'm able to deal with my emotions better than I have in earlier months, but my family didn't even know about my struggles. I was able to hide my internal problems by not displaying that anything was wrong. I did tell my mom about my issues, but she never saw them play out. It took every bit of my will and self-control to avoid snapping on people yet I succeeded. I eventually got to a point where my stress and anger issues couldn't possibly be normal and that's why I told my psychiatrist about it. In terms of my speech. It was slightly delayed, which is a complicated story. It didn't take long for me to catch up, but it's likely I'll always communicate best in writing and on the Internet. IP: Logged |
Dons2angelss Knowflake Posts: 515 From: Virginia, US Registered: Jan 2019
|
posted September 22, 2019 10:33 PM
My son has Merc opposite Saturn 3d and he's always been a very serious thinker and has always spoken like he is much older than his age and it's earned him the nickname old soul at his school. He was talking in full sentences before 2 years old and actually understanding what we were talking about, not just repeating words. It blew everyone's mind lol. He was like an old man in a tiny little body, he'd come up to you, shake your hand and introduce himself and I never had to teach him that. Don't try to get any information out of him though. His moon is conjunct saturn and my God, trying to get him to talk about how he's feeling is like talking to a brick wall. IP: Logged |
teasel Knowflake Posts: 12741 From: teasel#2172 discordapp - to talk Registered: Apr 2009
|
posted September 22, 2019 11:25 PM
I have Mercury square Saturn, and have dealt with bad social anxiety since I was small. PTSD, too. I dropped out of school due to bullying, and finished at home, when we moved over here to the US. IP: Logged |
Somna7H Knowflake Posts: 982 From: East India Company Registered: Apr 2018
|
posted September 23, 2019 12:20 AM
No one understand me the way I talk. Exalted Saturn Square Mercury.IP: Logged |
charlie Knowflake Posts: 4835 From: Registered: Jun 2012
|
posted September 23, 2019 04:15 AM
I only know one person with Saturn/Mercury (sextile) and I think she’s awfully boring!! Always plans everything, calculates every word said, everything needs to be “in place” so not to upset the “perfection”. This person can plan ahead WEEKS at a time and seems to be forgetting that “life happens” every now and then.. One also has to be very careful what one says to her because she takes everything 100% serious. There can be NO tongue in cheek. My Uranus-self can’t deal in all honesty despite having a Cap Moon! IP: Logged |
cthonicstar Knowflake Posts: 80 From: Registered: Sep 2019
|
posted September 23, 2019 02:30 PM
quote: Originally posted by charlie: I only know one person with Saturn/Mercury (sextile) and I think she’s awfully boring!! Always plans everything, calculates every word said, everything needs to be “in place” so not to upset the “perfection”. This person can plan ahead WEEKS at a time and seems to be forgetting that “life happens” every now and then.. One also has to be very careful what one says to her because she takes everything 100% serious. There can be NO tongue in cheek. My Uranus-self can’t deal in all honesty despite having a Cap Moon!
How is this person's writing? Is it the same or different from speaking?
IP: Logged |
cthonicstar Knowflake Posts: 80 From: Registered: Sep 2019
|
posted September 23, 2019 02:36 PM
I see multiple responses related to anxiety issues--would you say that the medications/therapy or both help? IP: Logged |
Leo-Cancer98 Knowflake Posts: 974 From: Toronto,Ontario,Canada Registered: Nov 2014
|
posted September 24, 2019 09:08 AM
quote: Originally posted by charlie: I only know one person with Saturn/Mercury (sextile) and I think she’s awfully boring!! Always plans everything, calculates every word said, everything needs to be “in place” so not to upset the “perfection”. This person can plan ahead WEEKS at a time and seems to be forgetting that “life happens” every now and then.. One also has to be very careful what one says to her because she takes everything 100% serious. There can be NO tongue in cheek.
Yup, that's me! Haha, I have Mercury trine Saturn.
------------------ Cancer Rising 2nd House Leo Sun 3rd House Leo Mercury 6th House Sagittarius Moon & Pluto 1st House Cancer Venus & Mars 9th House Pisces Jupiter conjunct MC. IP: Logged |
Kannon McAfee Moderator Posts: 4017 From: Portland, OR - USA Registered: Oct 2011
|
posted September 24, 2019 02:17 PM
quote: Originally posted by cthonicstar: What are some of the trends you've noticed in people who have Mercury-Saturn aspects? To me they always seem careful with speaking. It's as if they are mentally reviewing everything they're about to say to make sure it passes their internal filter. Or they come across as very quiet people.
Yes. My dad has Saturn/Asc square Mercury. Reluctant conversationalist; tends to let the other person speak more; slow and choosy with his words before replying to my mom who is the more energetic communicator. (Admittedly, some of these tendencies are from Asc in Cancer conjunct Saturn alone.) Major angular aspects between these two (conjunction, parallel, square, opposition, contra-parallel) put Saturn into teaching mode to process thoughts and words more before using them. That can mean more emphasis on the attempt to be more appropriate or precise in speech. So the emphasis is not on speech, but on internal processing and inhibition of frivolous mental impulses. So they tend not to speak until they think they really have something worth contributing. ------------------ Soul Stars Astrology by The Declinations Guy Expert birth chart rectification IP: Logged |
cthonicstar Knowflake Posts: 80 From: Registered: Sep 2019
|
posted September 25, 2019 01:12 PM
quote: Originally posted by Kannon McAfee:So the emphasis is not on speech, but on internal processing and inhibition of frivolous mental impulses. So they tend not to speak until they think they really have something worth contributing. [/B]
So that's the purpose of the internal filter! To make sure that they have something really worthwhile to say. It does fit with Saturn's influence. IP: Logged |
GalacticCoreExplosion Knowflake Posts: 139 From: Somewhere Registered: Sep 2019
|
posted September 25, 2019 11:25 PM
Saturn relates a lot to fear. Fear is the mind and Soul numb'er, it is the love killer, it is the lack of light, it is materialism and the "grass is always greener on the other side" aka different material conditions or more or better things will make me "happier". It is the ego essentially. The more closed the heart, the more careful and self conscious one tends to be. Careful, is often, another way of saying "fear filled". I'm speaking as one who has personally experienced the extremes. Spent first 20 years of life being extremely quiet, introverted, within, and fairly self focused, to the point of moderate autistic like expression. I was miserable and unhappy for most of those years. Actually, severely depressed for most of my childhood. Most of it was a self defense mechanism. However, the more I started to repoen my heart, the more communicative, the more expressive, more open, friendly, and less careful I became. Part of what relates to it astrologically is Moon conjunct Saturn, and Mercury in Capricorn widely square Moon. To be sure, travails, sorrows, challenges beyond my control, etc were a part of all of it too (moving a lot, beloved mother getting sick with cancer at age 16, health problems, being mercilessly bullied throughout grade school, insufferable psychopathic step father, etc). But, I had to choose to change my outlook, my thought patterns, my beliefs, my perceptions to change myself, and the more I did so, the more I changed. But I still like precision in words and communication, for the purpose of clarity and helpfulness. (Plenty o'Virgo and Mercury too). IP: Logged |
charlie Knowflake Posts: 4835 From: Registered: Jun 2012
|
posted September 26, 2019 01:32 PM
quote: Originally posted by cthonicstar: How is this person's writing? Is it the same or different from speaking?
Everything with this person has got to be perfect (in her mind), otherwise she'll have a mental breakdown! IP: Logged |
Ami Anne Moderator Posts: 73335 From: Pluto/house next to NickiG Registered: Sep 2010
|
posted September 26, 2019 05:01 PM
I am really interested in this. Great topic!------------------ Want to Read Simple, Fun,Sexy Articles on Astrology? Check Me Out, DUDE. http://www.mychristianpsychic.com/
IP: Logged |
Ami Anne Moderator Posts: 73335 From: Pluto/house next to NickiG Registered: Sep 2010
|
posted September 26, 2019 05:07 PM
I notice cthonicstar that ou are posted wonderful things. Keep up the amazing work!------------------ Want to Read Simple, Fun,Sexy Articles on Astrology? Check Me Out, DUDE. http://www.mychristianpsychic.com/
IP: Logged |
Leo-Cancer98 Knowflake Posts: 974 From: Toronto,Ontario,Canada Registered: Nov 2014
|
posted September 26, 2019 05:34 PM
quote: Originally posted by charlie: Everything with this person has got to be perfect (in her mind), otherwise she'll have a mental breakdown!
True! Same here, haha 😂 ------------------ Cancer Rising 2nd House Leo Sun 3rd House Leo Mercury 6th House Sagittarius Moon & Pluto 1st House Cancer Venus & Mars 9th House Pisces Jupiter conjunct MC. IP: Logged |
cthonicstar Knowflake Posts: 80 From: Registered: Sep 2019
|
posted September 27, 2019 08:12 PM
quote: Originally posted by Ami Anne: I notice cthonicstar that ou are posted wonderful things. Keep up the amazing work!
Thanks Ami Anne! I'm sure it's because I feel welcomed here in this supportive community! IP: Logged |
mercmercy99 Knowflake Posts: 104 From: Registered: May 2018
|
posted October 07, 2019 04:47 AM
I have the square. I notice that a lot of us tend to put our foot in our mouths very frequently lol. Well, at least I know I do.Re: speech, mine is very concise and maybe a little too curt at times. My writing is like this as well. It's really tough because I'd love nothing more than to just say whatever comes to mind, but I have to think twice, thrice. Quadruple. Quintuple, etc. I'm also secretly an extrovert; so, I love being around people, I just never know what to say. Womp womp. IP: Logged |
teasel Knowflake Posts: 12741 From: teasel#2172 discordapp - to talk Registered: Apr 2009
|
posted October 07, 2019 08:07 PM
quote: Originally posted by charlie: I only know one person with Saturn/Mercury (sextile) and I think she’s awfully boring!! Always plans everything, calculates every word said, everything needs to be “in place” so not to upset the “perfection”. This person can plan ahead WEEKS at a time and seems to be forgetting that “life happens” every now and then.. One also has to be very careful what one says to her because she takes everything 100% serious. There can be NO tongue in cheek. My Uranus-self can’t deal in all honesty despite having a Cap Moon!
This sounds like it's down to more than her Mercury placement. IP: Logged |
StubbornVirgo Knowflake Posts: 2708 From: Welcome to Mercury Registered: Jul 2015
|
posted October 08, 2019 02:53 AM
quote: Originally posted by Aries23Degrees: Correct you are.Add to that basket Saturn in Virgo/Gemini,Saturn in 3rd or 6th, Capricorn on the cusp of the 3rd/6th. Raised by grandma or an elder,considerably older siblings or there is a huge gap between them and younger siblings, the only child, learning language through an elder,speaking with authority,being taught to speak with respect, speaking in old/srructured diction,using sentence construction in a very rigid way,you are your own "editor", someone is always shouting at you "speak properly!" and this can create pressure and/or anxiety when it comes to expressing yourself with words, assisted early learning, special needs class, native is elder sibling and is therefore "responsible" for younger siblings, native may be raised by elder siblings, no children their age around to learn from, a childhood that is isolated from peer contact prevents early accumulation of language, native looks up to a sibling that is greatly accomplished in communication, challenges in learning, learning takes longer or there is great pressure to learn early, entering school at an age that is late or too early, a stammer or lisp, a soft voice that doesn't project, a monotonous voice that is off-putting, a voice for radio, an interest in the communication field, being paid for how you express yourself, "dead pan" comic genius,dry sense of humour, sophisticated jargon,using old-style cursive writing and avoiding "sms" language, trouble fitting in with peers as the native often does not relate to people their age etc. Language and learning is a 3rd house/Mercury function as is communication. So Saturn involved there can create delays and/or issues there that may force the individual to either become well versed at Mercury related things early on (due to imposing pressure). Or the native may sincerely struggle by having learning challenges due to the inability to focus or have ADD. And perhaps the parents/guardians have a relaxed attitude in steering the native to learn,speak,read or write. The caution you speak of is because of Saturn.Saturn wants to come across authoritative on the subject expressed by Mercury.This is especially true when there is a conjunction/square. The opposition as well as the square often creates uncertainty on whether the "correct" information is being communicated. And so they may come across self-doubting unless very well-versed with the crowd they are addressing. I actually find Mercury-Saturn people quite funny. But they can also be melancholic and prone to depression. This especially with the tight opp/square and conj. And this is because Saturn brings to the mental sphere chronic thoughts of self criticism. These guys are their own worst critic.
Wow, this is very accurate for me. I have Mercury in Virgo in my 8th house trine Saturn in Capricorn. I also have Cap ASC and Saturn-ASC conjunction. My parents worked a lot so I spent a lot of time with my grandparents as a child. My grandmother in particular taught me to read, write (also in cursive!) when I was younger. She worked in education. She picked up on the fact that I had a speech impediment, and so I ended up seeing a speech therapist for while, even while I was in school. My grandmother also taught me how to edit my own work, and then later I edited papers for my family. I was cut off from a lot of social contact just by location - I grew up in the middle of a giant farm, and the only other kids around were my cousins. So when I tired of being around them, I had to find ways to entertain myself. I also have a very quiet, soft voice. I'm constantly told to speak up and be louder. I always will be my own worst critic. And I do have a very dry sense of humor. IP: Logged |
Stellia Knowflake Posts: 606 From: Yorks, UK Registered: Jan 2017
|
posted October 08, 2019 09:47 AM
This is so interesting. One of my close friends has Mercury, Saturn AND Sun very tightly conjunct (<1degree) and these themes are absolutely borne out in his case.As a child he was language-delayed for several years, and is very quiet now unless you get him one-to-one or in very small groups or loosened up by alcohol. Emotionally, he really struggles to express feelings in verbal terms. Fascinatingly, though, he is a huge thinker and an exceptionally talented linguist -- in computer programming terms. When he does talk, people listen - and he's renowned for pithy, often borderline rude or disrespectful comments - but gets away with it due to his talent and his Sagittarius rising charm. Language and communication is definitely a key theme in his chart - he also has north node in gemini. Certainly though, the saturn-mercury-sun element is very significant! As an interesting comparison, a mutual friend of ours has sun-mercury tightly conjunct and never ever has a problem with expressing herself - and is in fact very blunt and at times childish with her expressions. Obviously there's a lot of differences at play but as a quick reference, she doesn't have Saturn sitting right on her mercury inhibiting her communication, even though she does have a Capricorn sun.
IP: Logged |
Hikaru29 Knowflake Posts: 2093 From: Asia Registered: Nov 2018
|
posted October 08, 2019 10:30 AM
I've Mercury in 12th house sextile Saturn in 2nd house. I was a quiet child... often in my own thoughts, but I never had problems with speech... never had anyone told me I'd to speak properly & clearly. In fact, my teacher selected me for a story-telling contest when I was 8yo so I couldn't have had problems speaking (lol). I was raised by my parents, no big age gap with my siblings (I'm the youngest). This aspect gives me organised thoughts and a serious mind, and I can see through large-scale plans. I also have a very good memory and can have great deal of concentration on my pursuits. I may not have the fastest minds but I usually have a good collection of facts and knowledge. When I speak, I often come across calm yet authoritative.
IP: Logged | |