|
Author
|
Topic: How Important Is Formal Education?
|
Randall Webmaster Posts: 20479 From: Columbus, GA USA Registered: Nov 2000
|
posted November 01, 2004 01:42 PM
*bump*------------------ "Never mentally imagine for another that which you would not want to experience for yourself, since the mental image you send out inevitably comes back to you." Rebecca Clark IP: Logged |
future_uncertain Knowflake Posts: 477 From: ohio Registered: Aug 2004
|
posted November 06, 2004 01:51 PM
Seems like these days getting a formal education is kind of hit or miss. What I mean is some people get great jobs because they have degrees and some people get great jobs without degrees. I'm currently in college (got a late start two years ago at 25 and I should be graduating sometime around 2008 *exasperated sigh*) and I love it. However, I do believe that my seven years of life experience before college is really what makes the difference in what I am getting out of my education today... Just a thought! Carissa IP: Logged |
geminstone Knowflake Posts: 123 From: Golden, CO Registered: Nov 2004
|
posted November 23, 2004 07:05 PM
What a great thread. I have, personally, known quite a few ' educated idiots ', not to mention I have watched some of the " Jay walking " segments that Jay Leno does! It is amazing. The one that I cannot forget.... young man in a California University was asked how many Moon's earth has...? And he was'nt the only one to get that wrong! Is'nt that kindergarten,... my Daughter is in kindergarten, she knew that one even before school! I, fully, agree that school is nothing more than a social function. I love to learn and, that is why I too, dropped out! Sadly, you are required from the age of 5 to 16, to be an entrant in your local ' popularity contest '. I have, recently, been thinking about how sad it is that, here in the US, they now use education as a punishment. I know people, who have made some poor choices and, got caught. A few of them are drop outs and, upon court day, the Judge slaps them with a fine and ORDERS them to obtain a GED. I am not one for stereotyping so, I have a hard time with the ' helping the misguided ' crap that everyone is made to believe concerning this order. For some reason, I had this idea that education was a choice,.....? but then, I have the odd recollection of hearing it was free too.....? Hhmm, must be my ignorance,.... I am a drop out, afterall! I so wish for more of a positive influence for my kiddos!! It's sad when a program like D.A.R.E feels the need to visit elementary schools and, so many educated adults still don't make the connection! WOW!!! I better be doing something now! This is a great topic Randall, and it is quite nice to see more of the " YAY, Randall, for dropping out!! " responses. I would like to just say too, that I do NOT, think that all those individuals who are and have waded through the BS and, on to personal success, I DO NOT think that every one of them is an ' educated idiot '. Okay, later ~ ~ geminstone IP: Logged |
Johnny Knowflake Posts: 301 From: Colorado, USA Registered: Nov 2004
|
posted November 24, 2004 02:14 AM
These people didn't know how many moons earth has??? That's unbelievable. Really. Surely they staged that! I hope.  I'm in college right now, and I can hardly stand it. It's not even the amount of work that gets me down - it's just the sheer inaneness ( hope that's a word! ) of my classes. Everything I do there seems like such a complete and utter waste of time, it's driving me crazy. I have classes that I do absolutely no homework in, never follow the reading assignements ( honestly, never even wasted the money on the textbook ), and still ace every single test! And this is supposed to be "higher education" ! My personal opinion is that school, or at least school these days, is about 98% bs, 1% common sense, and 1% pure luck. The only life skill I'm aquiring is an intimate knowledge of how to cynically work the work the system. Rrr.
IP: Logged |
geminstone Knowflake Posts: 123 From: Golden, CO Registered: Nov 2004
|
posted November 24, 2004 02:39 AM
Hi Johnny, I don't think it was staged but, only they know for sure, I guess! They were also asking about things that my 6 year old knows, like one was, How many times does the earth rotate in a 24 Hour period? I think that there is the possibility that, they are editing out the people that had the means for a college education in their domes and, hopefully that job was similar to the editors of all the sports broadcasts, only, in a backward kind of way....... Sorry, I think I almost lost myself there.....? Anyway, it's been about 2 years, or so, since I have bothered with the Box, but, I seem to recall it being on the Jay Leno Show on Wednesday nights. It's definatly a laugh, with a slight bit of worry. Later, ~ geminstone IP: Logged |
Randall Webmaster Posts: 20479 From: Columbus, GA USA Registered: Nov 2000
|
posted November 28, 2004 10:02 AM
 ------------------ "Never mentally imagine for another that which you would not want to experience for yourself, since the mental image you send out inevitably comes back to you." Rebecca Clark IP: Logged |
sesame Moderator Posts: 701 From: Brisbane, QLD, Oz Registered: Nov 2003
|
posted November 29, 2004 01:07 AM
Ah, you gotta love geminis  Dean. IP: Logged |
26taurus Moderator Posts: 5381 From: the stars Registered: Jun 2004
|
posted November 29, 2004 03:32 AM
I'm a high school drop out as well. And a college drop out for that matter. I went to college very late, after telling myself for years that I would never go to college, and dropped out after six months. I did get my GED too. My mother made me. I've always believed that college was a big rip off. Sure you learn things. But I can do that on my own. And you arent guaranteed a job after you get out, but you are guaranteed to owe a huge sum of cash to the school. Colleges and Universities are Big Buisness. You are also stuck learning things a certain way, not on your own, not creativly. I dont like other people molding my brain. I'd rather teach myself and there is a big wide world out there to learn from. I think of it as "home schooling mySelf."  I eventually gave into the mindset that had been preached to me for years and years that I wouldnt get anywhere without some form of "higher education". Now I'm kicking myself because I have a huge debt to pay off and although I left with a 4.0 GPA - I barely learned a thing from that school!! They just wanted my money. The school was a joke. So I got out before it was too late and I buried myself alive in debt. Why didnt I just listen to what I had always told myself? That you DON'T need to go to college to "make it" in life. It was always a Knowing inside of me. And I still believe it to be true. I've learned more from the "school of life" and "hard knocks" than I ever wouldve having taken a different route. Somehow I'm still alive after years of drug and alcohol abuse, depression, homelessness, you name it. And taking a deep look at it all I see the beauty of it. It has made me who I am today and I wouldnt change anything. I'm so glad I never took the "easy roads". Every choice I have made has made me who I am today and I dont regret a thing. I think of how differnt I would be if I took different, some might say "better", paths and I thank God I didnt. I've learned so much. Only after youve been to the darkest depths is when you can rise to see the brightest light. I'll eventually be self employed this is something I've always known inside as well. And you dont need a "piece of paper" to make that happen. I just have to pick which idea I want to do. I'm an artist and I dont need a school to tell me that. To me the best schooling you'll ever get is not one you have to pay for. Yes, either way you'll "pay" in some way, but who are you paying? I'd rather pay myself. I think having a high SQ (Spiritual Quotient) is a far greater thing to have than a high IQ. "Beware when the great God lets loose a thinker on this planet." Ralph Waldo Emerson (1803 - 1882)
"The intuitive mind is a sacred gift and the rational mind is a faithful servant. We have created a society that honors the servant and has forgotten the gift." -Albert Einstein "Wisdom is not a product of schooling but of the lifelong attempt to acquire it." -Albert Einstein "Imagination is more important than knowledge." -Albert Einstein "The only thing that interferes with my learning is my education." -Albert Einstein ------------------ "We don't see things as they are...we see things as we are". -Anais Nin
IP: Logged |
geminstone Knowflake Posts: 123 From: Golden, CO Registered: Nov 2004
|
posted November 30, 2004 01:09 PM
Hi again, Sorry Randall, I know, sometimes I produce that, very, same reaction; the unsure giggles...? Thank you sesame, being one, sometimes, I give myself that reaction!! 26Taurus, I wanted to say, Thank Goodness, for people like you! The ol' ' School of Hard Knocks ' makes for an individual, I think. This is not to say that some have not attended both! In my educational experience, the bottom line was all about who you associated and surrounded yourself with. I had a math teacher, in my sophmore year, that deliberatly, showcased my lack of understanding. She had made up her mind about WHO I was, based on WHAT I wore/appeared to be. Truth be told, I had only one other person in the ' clicke ' that I ran with and, we are still the closest of friends. Though I come off as very timid, because I am extremely shy, I have always had a, very, strong sense of self. I do not mean ' self centered '. I have always been honest about myself and, with myself. Everyday, there are new lessons to be learned, I felt school was a way of keeping me divided, seperate from my ' peers ' but, not as an individual....? Sorry, is that my Gemini showing again? I hope I'm making some sort of sense. Anyway, I guess my point is that, only you can be the ' judge and jury ' about how your life unfolds. I have learned that, when you look from the outside and, pass judgement on or, about others, soon it is you, that looks outside from the same place that, once, you had convicted. How do you plead? ...... I admitt, I am guilty of it, however, I am going to err, many times. It is in my decisions that follow where the lessons that guide me, bring me closer to personal understanding. For me, Life is the trial, I am the judge but,.... also the charged...? K, I hope that comes across as I intended!.... Thank You 26Taurus, for BEing! Later, ~ geminstone IP: Logged |
26taurus Moderator Posts: 5381 From: the stars Registered: Jun 2004
|
posted December 01, 2004 03:02 AM
Thank you Geminstone! Same to you, my friend. You made great sense BTW.   IP: Logged |
geminstone Knowflake Posts: 123 From: Golden, CO Registered: Nov 2004
|
posted December 01, 2004 05:30 AM
...whew... ~ geminstone IP: Logged |
LibraSparkle Moderator Posts: 4448 From: Vancouver USA Registered: May 2004
|
posted December 01, 2004 01:45 PM
quote: 26Taurus, I wanted to say, Thank Goodness, for people like you!
My sentiments exactly  IP: Logged |
26taurus Moderator Posts: 5381 From: the stars Registered: Jun 2004
|
posted December 01, 2004 10:38 PM
AWwwww!  It's weird, I was just thinking about you today Sparkle. All you've been through and what a truly special person you are. You really are, and I hope you realize that. Too bad we dont live near each other so we could get together. I love LindaLand. So many beautiful individuals here......and everywhere for that matter. Luv you guys.  IP: Logged |
Kat Smeow Knowflake Posts: 47 From: New Jersey Registered: Nov 2003
|
posted December 04, 2004 09:55 AM
It's been awhile since I've been here last, as is my habit to disappear. I read my last post in this thread and had to chuckle. What a joke this university is that I'm a part of. It's all red tape, politics and money. I dread each class, withdrawn from 3. Why do I put myself through it? For a piece of paper valued at tens of thousands of dollars? Then what? Hang it on the wall of the cardboard box I'll be living in? It's just about time for me to swallow my pride and admit defeat when it comes to university. Although I do look back with fondness on my Associates Degree, which I received from the local community college. I look at my honor society membership, remember the speech I made as valedictorian after having been out of school for *cough cough* a few years. Now here I am, 6 months later, failing at this new system of education. Some education. I learned so much more at county college than I have anywhere. I miss it. And I feel like I've let down those professors/mentors I loved. So what do I do now? *shrug* I never want to stop learning. But college is just not best place for me to learn. How much longer can I put off "real life" and getting a "real job" for the sake of education? Would being a massage therapist (which I also went to school for and graduated with honors) who creatively writes in her spare time (A.A. in English/Writing, honors as well) be such a bad thing? Do I have to "know it all" and get GPAs of 4.0 to feel like I'm worthy of breath? I guess the real question is, why am I so afraid to just do that? I don't really know, but at this moment, I'm positively petrified of being a failure in any regard. I just love to learn. But I have a sneaking suspicion, moreso after reading this thread, that college isn't about that at all. Kat IP: Logged |
Randall Webmaster Posts: 20479 From: Columbus, GA USA Registered: Nov 2000
|
posted December 05, 2004 11:38 AM
 ------------------ "Never mentally imagine for another that which you would not want to experience for yourself, since the mental image you send out inevitably comes back to you." Rebecca Clark IP: Logged |
Johnny Knowflake Posts: 301 From: Colorado, USA Registered: Nov 2004
|
posted December 14, 2004 01:27 AM
Yeah, I'm with you Kat. It's all pretty worthless, when you get right down to it. College is about nothing more than making money - its a business, just like everything else. Hehe, did I mention that the soda machines at the one I go to charge $1.25 for one measly little can of coke? Doesn't that just sum up the entire college experience! IP: Logged |
Kat Smeow Knowflake Posts: 47 From: New Jersey Registered: Nov 2003
|
posted December 14, 2004 08:11 PM
"Hi, can I please have a Bachelor's Degree, with a side of Annoying Administrative Regulations and a Super Duper size cup of Uncertainty and Disillusion. Hold the pickle. To go please.""That'll be 50 grand plus parking permits, lab fees, books that you don't even open, gas money, car maintenence, general fees, gym membership and a 4 year supply of slim fast when you realize what you look like in the obligatory belly shirt. Please drive through. Good luck on finding a job." Is there a chart placement for sarcasm?  Actually, I'm feeling pretty darn good tonight, just finished all my papers for this semester. Break out the carrot juice, it's time to par-tay! *does cabbage patch* Ok, I look ridiculous. No more dancing. And I'm going back next semester. Glutton for punishment? Or stubborn Taurus unwilling to admit defeat? You make the call! And $1.25 for a drink is criminal. They should hang their heads in shame. Do they have pay toilets too? I wouldn't be surprised. Okay I'm done ranting now. lol. Back to being happy Kat. IP: Logged |
26taurus Moderator Posts: 5381 From: the stars Registered: Jun 2004
|
posted December 16, 2004 02:34 PM
ROFL!  IP: Logged |
Randall Webmaster Posts: 20479 From: Columbus, GA USA Registered: Nov 2000
|
posted December 17, 2004 11:38 AM
 ------------------ "Never mentally imagine for another that which you would not want to experience for yourself, since the mental image you send out inevitably comes back to you." Rebecca Clark IP: Logged |
Secret Garden Knowflake Posts: 169 From: Registered: Dec 2004
|
posted January 17, 2005 04:11 AM
Well...sorry to go against all of you guys now since everyone seems to have completely figured out that education cant do much in and of itself... I personally believe that going to college, getting a degree, is very important. Why? Because college isn't supposed to teach you how many moons the earth has. It's an experience about getting along with people, working in groups, getting exposed to diversity, and some of the most educated and fascinating professors ever, its about going to new places and exploring new things, thinking outside of the box, learning to obey and respect authority while questioning society. The kinds of courses we have to take in college pretty much cover the whole spectrum. If it was not for college I would not know a LOT of important stuff. I would not know a LOT of important people mostly. Through my university I am a board member of a business organization. Because I network with professionals (and professionals who hire really admire degrees usually) that's another big benefit I got from college. I have not graduated yet and have quite a few job offers. I don't mean to sound cocky but Ive kept my 4 at the ivy league not because of my hard work (oh no! lol). But because I learned how to 'charm' people, do and say the right things and the right time, as well as learn academic material. Perhaps what Im trying to say is that I learned mostly how to deal with all sorts of people, educated and uneducated, and how to be chamelion-like yet skilled enough to survive, in my opinion, anywhere in the world. A few years ago I suffered severe depression as a victim of hate crime (sexual assault) as well as being jilted at the altar by my first bf. If it weren't for my education; those psychology classes, those good friends I made out of the colleagues and professors, and the rest of my practical education, I would never have made it to today. The Albert Einstein quotes are well and good, but society needs to have structure, and the only reason that degrees provide any use is that they prove a yardstick. They cannot measure your intelligence or your propensity for hard work, or your ambition, but they can tell someone you're willing to invest time and money to learn and educate yourself. Thats a bigger statement than anything else. Think about it; you're willing to invest time and money to change yourself and your outlook on life. What that means is that you realize you do not know everything, and you want to be taught. And that is the key to learning; knowing that you know nothing, and entering the company of scholars. Education, in degree form, has been around for a while. Even unformally, there were tiers and levels and labels that had started in monastic academies, etc. It was simply to distinguish someone based on their dedication to a field of study, and that cannot be replaced by any other thing. Doing ones one thing without a degree , figuring ones own path, can be commendable, but if everyone were to do this, the world could come to chaos. Like I said, education provides structure and stability. The job market may be difficult for educated professionals, but just because the degree is not helping them, that is probably not the one and only factor responsible. Its probably something else, such as lack of social networking, connections, personality to accompany the degree, etc. The degree HELPS you reach the point in life you want to go to, but you have to have it in a combination with other things. If you don't have the whole package, it doesn't mean that education harmed your chances. All it means is that you couldn't figure out what the package was that was needed most then. So far as financial stability goes, I think that the statistics for what a Harvard MBA makes fresh out of grad school pretty much speak for themselves...its true that that will not indicate long term success. But people tend to think they just teach you how to handle money and thats it. ....Wrong! You study endless cases and cases and do internships and study in close alliance with mentors. You form practical projects, launch them, gauge success..and finally you are sent with your degree, to help better the world. Think of it as boot camp. Big advocate of formal education here IP: Logged |
raihs Knowflake Posts: 27 From: eastcoast australia Registered: Oct 2004
|
posted January 19, 2005 10:59 PM
i've got my obe from the school of hard knocks and kept working at it until the title magically changed itself to the School of Life. Attitude will get you everywhere. Once there was a man in a suit waiting for his pizza, as everyone was on that cold winter night, he got really huffy and everyone noticed. The overworked and underpaid kids running the place noticed, but just kept doing what they had to do. This suit wouldn't quit. Everyone laughed when a more sensible person said, quite loudly, "IS IT IMPORTANT TO BE NICE OR NICE TO BE IMPORTANT?" We all got our pizzas in due time, only the rude suit may have had a few extra unordered toppings on his.------------------ If i only end up being a notch on your bedpost, let it be a notch with a smiley face /:) IP: Logged |
Secret Garden Knowflake Posts: 169 From: Registered: Dec 2004
|
posted January 26, 2005 10:03 PM
Being in a suit doesn't teach you to be huffy. The kind of person you ARE has to do with how you apply your education, not the education itself. Education in itself is extremely valuable, and formal education is a support of all education in general. IP: Logged |
Kat Smeow Knowflake Posts: 47 From: New Jersey Registered: Nov 2003
|
posted February 04, 2005 08:13 PM
Hey everyone. Thought I'd update you guys on my continued struggle with formal education. Due to lack of available money of any sort (savings, loans or scholarships) I had to drop out of college this semester. I'm still 3 semesters away from a bachelor's degree. The saddest thing is, I could have taught most of the classes I had last semester. I seemed to know more about the subject matter than they did. And yes, I got all A's. Little good it does me now. My wish is for the athletic department to have a wonderful winning year, since 96.4% of the athletes are attending college for free. And get free housing. And books. (and we're not even talking Division I here) Yes I am bitter. And I will get over it, eventually. I may even try again when I have a spare 15k. In the meantime, I'll wear out my old trusty library card, keep writing, and remember that there are still institutions out there that still believe in actual education, not simply cranking out a product and making a buck. IP: Logged |
Secret Garden Knowflake Posts: 169 From: Registered: Dec 2004
|
posted February 07, 2005 03:14 AM
Kat: I wish you the best of luck in finding a good university. Not all large or 'brand name' universities are doing their job right. Partly its because of corruption and false standards and partly because the education industry is suffering shamefully low wages and new teachers are hard to come by, old ones cant make ends meet and are retiring to go other places. Its not so much the fault of the concept of formal education but that the implementation of it is so faulty sometimes. Nonetheless, do not give up hope and Im sure you will find a better way. Is there any way you can get a student loan or study someplace abroad where it will not cost as much? If you like, we can chat on email if you're interested. I sincerely believe that anyone who yearns for an education should be able to get one without significant barriers, but again, thats an ideal, and ideals almost never work in practical life. However, we should be strong and persistent, and I hope that you find the courage inside yourself as I know you're a brave person...and once again, best of luck in your search for better ways.
IP: Logged | |